Avalanche Line

Chapter 52: Voss's Counter

The television in the ranger hut was small and old, its speakers tinny, and Ava had it turned up loud enough that the static buzz at the edges of Patricia Voss's voice felt like a thing in the room with them.

Voss stood at a lectern in a Calgary conference room, flanked by two men in suits and a photograph on an easel draped in black cloth. The Vail Ridge logo sat behind her, clean and green and mountains, as if nothing about the last three years had ever happened.

"Thank you for coming," Voss said. She had the flat, patient cadence of a lawyer who had done this a hundred times and expected to do it a hundred more. "I want to be brief, because the facts are brief. The story that has been circulating about Vail Ridge Resort and the January twelfth avalanche is a fabrication. A deliberate, documented fabrication, assembled by two individuals with their own reasons."

Liam sat on the cot with his back against the wall, his bandaged hand propped on his knee. He hadn't said anything since the feed started. Ava watched him instead of the screen for a second, then made herself watch the screen.

"First," Voss said, and lifted the cloth.

The photograph was grainy, timestamped in the corner, a fisheye security-cam angle of the run 7 access gate. In the foreground, unmistakable even at that resolution, was Liam's jacket—the faded red rescue shell with the reflective stripe, the union patch on the shoulder. His back was to the camera. And his gloved hand was on the shank of the cut lock.

Ava heard her own breath go out of her.

"That photograph was recovered from a trail camera we maintain for wildlife monitoring," Voss said. "It is date-stamped the night of January twelfth. Eleven fifty-two p.m. The lock on the run seven gate was found cut the following morning. The man in the photograph is Liam Okafor, formerly of Alpine Rescue, currently suspended pending review. He is not a rescuer. He is a man who cut a lock on a closed terrain gate during an active avalanche advisory, and who then, three years later, built a story that would make that cut look like heroism."

"That's not the gate," Liam said. His voice was very level. "That lock's a different cut pattern. I've looked at that gate a hundred times."

"Shh," Ava said, not because she didn't believe him, but because she needed to hear it all.

"Second," Voss said, "we have confirmed with the provincial avalanche center that the field log and audio recording being circulated by these individuals were not, as claimed, recovered from a snow-study station. They were manufactured. The center has no record of the station being occupied. They have no record of any such recording equipment being issued."

"That's a lie," Ava said. It came out quiet. "Dev has the issue log. It's in the system."

"Third," Voss said, and her voice changed, subtly, into something a degree warmer and more dangerous, "a matter of professional judgment. In 2022, Mr. Okafor was suspended from Alpine Rescue following an incident in which he declined to authorize a helicopter insertion during a window that, in the opinion of Alpine Rescue's own review board, was within safe parameters. A guest died. The Okafor review was never made public. It is public now."

The room on the screen shifted—reporters, a stir, the sound of a dozen people typing at once. Ava felt it happen in her chest like a physical drop. Three years. Three years of Liam carrying that—not the death, which was not his, but the fact of the review, the fact that a room full of people had once decided he was the kind of man who hesitated.

The clip ended. The anchor came on and said something about "allegations" and "ongoing investigation" and Ava turned it off.

Neither of them moved for a long moment. Outside, the light was coming up gray and flat over the ridge.

"The cut pattern," Liam said finally. "It's wrong. Vail Ridge gates use a Master Lock 6230. That lock in the photo's a 5400D—different shank diameter, different indentation. If they'd gotten a real photo of the run seven gate, it would be the 6230."

Ava pulled her phone out and pulled up the photo of the run 7 marker they'd taken in the second cabin. She zoomed until the pixels went to mush, then stopped. "The timestamp's fake too. Look at the shadow at the bottom of the frame. The gate post casts left. At 11:52 p.m. on January twelfth, there's no sun. That's a daylight shadow."

"It could be a light source."

"It could be a parking lot light. It could be anything. But it's not consistent with a trail cam running under infrared." She set the phone down. "None of this matters if nobody looks. They've got four hours on us before the morning shows pick this up as fact."

"Then we give them the tape."

"We gave them the tape transcript. Marguerite ran the story." Ava checked the time—6:04 a.m. "It's up. It's online. The interview's in three hours."

Liam stood, and she saw him try, reflexively, to use his right hand to steady himself against the wall, and fail. He caught himself with his shoulder instead and pretended it hadn't happened.

"The review," he said. "That's the part that'll stick. Voss knew it. She led with the fraud because she wanted the room to remember the photograph, and she closed with the review because that's what the room will actually repeat."

"It's not a real review. It was a preliminary finding."

"It was a finding."

Ava crossed to him. She didn't touch him—she wasn't sure he'd want it—but she stopped close enough that he had to look at her instead of the window. "The review said you declined insertion. It didn't say you were wrong. The avalanche ran eleven minutes later. You were right."

"The board thought I was wrong."

"The board had a resort's attorney in the room."

He looked at her for a long second, and something moved behind his eyes, and then he looked away. "The press won't ask about the board. They'll ask about the guest's name. They'll find her family. They'll call them."

Ava's phone buzzed. Then again. Then a run of them, one after the other, a machine-gun of notifications she couldn't keep up with. She picked it up and read the first one and felt the floor tilt.

It was a tweet from a mountain-sports columnist with a blue check, screenshotting Voss's photograph and the Okafor review side by side. *"So the hero rescuer cut the lock, and then a woman died. Ask yourself who you believe."*

Below it, three hundred replies and climbing. Some of them were calling Liam a killer. Some of them were calling Ava a liar—*the analyst who's sleeping with her source*—and she didn't know how they knew that, except that someone had told them, and she could guess who.

"Marguerite," she said, and hit call.

Her editor picked up on the second ring. "I'm watching it."

"Then you know what they did."

"I know what they did." Marguerite's voice was tight but steady. "The story's still up. Traffic's enormous. That's the one thing working in our favor—Voss's conference just sent a hundred thousand more readers to your piece than would have found it otherwise. People want to know what the photograph doesn't say."

"What does it not say?"

"That Voss produced it nine hours after the recording surfaced, that the center issued a statement contradicting her, and that the timestamp doesn't hold." A pause. "I called the center myself. They confirmed the station log, Ava. The equipment was issued to Nora Chen in 2022 and never returned. They'll say so on the record."

Ava closed her eyes. "That's the whole ballgame, then. She lied about the log."

"She lied about the log. She didn't lie about the review, which means the interview this morning is going to be about Liam, not about her. You need to know that going in."

"I know it."

"Do you?" Marguerite said, and there was something almost gentle in it. "Because if you go on national television and defend the man, you're not the analyst anymore. You're a party. Voss will use that. She'll say you're compromised."

Ava looked at Liam. He had turned back to the window, and his reflection floated over the ridge, thin and doubled by the glass.

"Then let her say it," Ava said. "I'll be on at nine."

She hung up. Liam didn't turn around.

"You don't have to do that," he said.

"I do."

"You don't. You could go on that show and talk about the tape and the log and the falsified alarm time, and you could say the review is a separate matter, and you'd be fine. You'd keep your credibility."

"Credibility with whom?"

"With the people who matter."

She walked over and stood beside him at the window. Below, the plow had cut a raw brown line down to the highway, and past it the trees were black and wet in the early light.

"You told me once," she said, "that the only thing worse than being blamed for something you didn't do is being blamed for something the truth can't reach. This can reach. The shadow's wrong on the photograph. The lock's wrong. The center has the issue log." She paused. "And the review—Liam, I've read the review. Nora sent it to me. Two years ago. I never told you because I didn't want to open it up. But I have it, and it says the board had a Vail Ridge consultant sitting in the room, and it says the finding was 'preliminary and contested.'"

Liam turned his head slowly. "You have it."

"I have it."

"You never—"

"I know. I'm sorry."

For a moment he just looked at her, and she couldn't read what was in it, and then his phone rang on the cot, loud in the small room.

He crossed to it, looked at the screen, and his face changed in a way she'd never seen before—not fear, exactly. Something further back than fear.

He answered. Listened. Said, "When." Listened again. Said, "Five days." And then, "No. No, I'll be there."

He hung up and stood very still with the phone in his hand.

"That was my union rep," he said. "The hearing's been moved up. They want me in front of the board in five days. Voss's filing made the case 'time-sensitive.'" He looked up at her. "I have to testify. And I don't have a lawyer."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 52: Voss's Counter · Avalanche Line · Lumen Reads