Avalanche Line

Chapter 74: Verdict

The hallway outside Judge Halvorsen's courtroom smelled like wet wool and floor wax, and Ava had been standing in it for eleven minutes trying to remember how to hold a paper cup without crushing it.

"Drink the coffee," Liam said.

"I don't want the coffee."

"You're holding it like it owes you money."

She looked down. The cup had folded slightly along one seam and a brown bead was running toward her thumb. She set it on the windowsill. Outside, Calgary lay flat and bright and indifferent under a sky that had no opinion about any of this.

The doors opened at 9:40.

They took their seats behind the Crown's table. Reyes was already there, in the same grey jacket she'd worn every day of the trial, and she didn't turn around, which Ava understood was a kindness — if Reyes looked at her now, Ava would have to feel something, and she was holding very still on purpose.

Cole came in through the side door with a deputy. He was wearing a suit that didn't fit him, and he had shaved, badly, and when he passed the gallery he looked at the floor. Ava watched him and waited for the anger and found, instead, a dull flat recognition. He had brought two children up a closed route to save a lodge that had no legal roof over its own foundation. Everything after that had been arithmetic. He was still the worst kind of coward. He was also the only witness who had told the truth out loud.

The clerk called the court to order.

Halvorsen read for nineteen minutes. He did not editorialize; he never did. He read the findings in the same dry voice he'd used all week — that Marcus Voss, as general manager of Vail Ridge operations, had received a confirmed avalanche advisory at 2:18 p.m.; that he had logged the alert at 5:05 p.m.; that the two hours and forty-seven minutes between those times were not a judgment call but a documented suppression of a warning he had personally ordered routed to his office instead of the dispatcher's desk; that four people had died on a slope that would have been closed.

"On count one," Halvorsen said, "criminal negligence causing death. Guilty."

Ava's hands were flat on her thighs. She heard the word and felt almost nothing, and then her body caught up — a long slow release down through her shoulders, like a knot being worked out of a rope she'd been hanging from.

"On count two, criminal negligence causing death. Guilty. On count three. Guilty."

Liam didn't move beside her. She could feel the heat off him, the absolute stillness. When she glanced sideways, his jaw was set and his eyes were fixed on the judge and there was water standing in them, not falling.

Halvorsen turned to Cole.

"Mr. Cole, you entered a plea on the lesser included charge and the Crown accepts it in light of your cooperation. You will serve eighteen months, suspended, with two years' probation and three hundred hours of community service performed in a mountain community, at the direction of the court." He paused. "You carried the last two people up that slope. That is the only reason you are not going to prison. Do not mistake it for absolution."

Cole nodded, once.

The two engineers from Vail Ridge — the ones who had certified the snow study as complete — pled out on the lesser counts before lunch. Fines, licenses suspended, both barred from professional practice for five years. Ava had read their names off the work orders a hundred times in three years. She watched them stand and answer and sit, and they looked like men who'd spent a decade approving documents they never read, and she thought: that's how it happens. Not with a villain. With a stamp.

Then the restitution.

The Crown's numbers were already on the record, but hearing them recited in the flat air of the courtroom was another thing. Vail Ridge Holdings would pay two hundred and forty thousand dollars to each of the four families. It would fund the Nora Lindqvist Memorial Avalanche Station at Vail Ridge Pass — operations, salary lines, equipment, snow-safety education contracts — for five years, fully endowed, with an independent board.

Five years.

Ava put both hands over her mouth. It came out of her as a sound, just one, and Liam's hand closed over her wrist and held.

The judge adjourned at 11:52.

The lobby was chaos. Reporters layered three deep at the doors; someone had a microphone aimed at Reyes and Reyes was walking through it like weather. Dev was on the phone somewhere and Ava could hear his voice, pitched high, saying *say that again — say it again* to whoever was on the other end.

She and Liam got out the side door onto the north steps.

And it was spring. That was the thing she hadn't accounted for. The whole trial had been winter — ice on the courthouse steps in January, the grey closed sky, Nora's voice on a courtroom speaker. Now the steps were dry and the sun was coming down at four in the afternoon with real weight in it, and the lilacs along the fence on the far side of Sixth Avenue were already past bloom and dropping petals onto the sidewalk in papery drifts.

Liam stopped two steps down and turned his face up into it.

"Okay," he said.

Ava laughed — a real one, cracked at the edges. "That's your statement? After eleven weeks?"

"Okay," he said again, and then he did the thing he'd been not-doing since the day she met him. He took her hand — just took it, no preamble, fingers slotting between hers — and stood there on the courthouse steps in front of God and the CBC and held it.

Neither of them said anything for a while. Cars went by. A guy on a bike yelled at a taxi. The lilac petals moved along the gutter in a slow tide.

"I'm going to have to tell Dev about the endowment," Ava said finally. "He'll want to hire somebody. He's been sending me staffing memos with *urgent* in the subject line since Tuesday."

"Let him hire somebody."

"We have a board now. We're going to have meetings."

"I know."

"Liam. We're going to have *governance*."

"Okay."

She looked at him and he was grinning, actually grinning, and it was so unlike his face that she had to look away, out at the street, at the mountains standing low and blue and improbable at the end of every westward street in this city.

"He wanted to talk to me," Ava said. "Cole. Before his testimony."

"I know."

"The courthouse officer told me he asked three times. I said no."

"You said no," Liam agreed. "I stood there."

Ava turned the paper cup over in her other hand — she'd carried it out of the building without noticing. "I still don't know what he wanted."

"I do," Liam said. "Reyes told me this morning while you were in the witness room. It wasn't about the trial." He looked at her steadily. "He wants us to testify about the south route. Same way he did this one."

Ava was quiet.

"He's not asking for immunity to get out of something," Liam said. "The second route — the one toward the Lodge. It's not a route Cole built. It's a route somebody's been using. Cole's motion says there are private snow-cat operators taking clients up the south drainage, on Forest Service land, on a permit that was cancelled in 2019. He's willing to name every one of them."

"Which means he's been guiding it," Ava said.

"He's been guiding it. Since before Nora died. The Lodge has been running client trips up the south arm the entire time we've been building a station on the other side of the pass."

Ava looked down the steps at the street, at the lilacs, at the sun doing its slow ordinary work on the pavement.

"Reyes wants us tomorrow morning," she said. "The file."

"Eight o'clock."

Ava let go of his hand, then took it back — she'd forgotten she was holding it and she wanted to notice this time. Behind them the lobby doors banged open and a wall of camera flashes went off, and somebody was already shouting Liam's name, and neither of them turned.

"If we take this," she said, "we're the ones who have to walk that drainage. Somebody has to map it."

"I know."

"Snowpack's still got five weeks of corn up there. Melt's starting."

"I know."

Ava looked at him.

"You already went up there," she said.

Liam didn't answer for a second. Then he said, "I walked the lower two switchbacks yesterday morning while you were testifying. There are stakes. Orange, new ones, driven into a slope that's got a mid-pack facet layer under six inches of wet slab." He met her eyes. "It's going to go out this summer, Ava. With people on it. And there's no station on that side, no forecast, no closure, because the permit's cancelled and nobody's watching."

The lilac petals went past in the gutter and the sun kept on.

"Then we'd better get the map," Ava said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 74: Verdict · Avalanche Line · Lumen Reads