Breaking the Ice

Chapter 15: The Independent Opinion

Dr. Beatriz Alvarez's office smelled like burnt coffee and old paper, and she was already holding out her hand before Megan cleared the doorway.

"Give it to me."

No greeting. No small talk. Alvarez had been Megan's clinical supervisor fifteen years ago, and she had not softened in the decade since. She took the laptop, spun it toward herself, and started scrolling through the raw output before Megan had even sat down.

"Processing speed here." Alvarez tapped the screen without looking up. "Percentile?"

"Eleventh. Down from forty-first on his baseline."

"And the baseline is his own? Same hardware, same protocols?"

"Same battery, same version. I revalidated it overnight Thursday."

Alvarez made a low noise in her throat, the kind she used to make during grand rounds when someone had fumbled an obvious diagnosis. "Reaction time variability, this spread — Megan, this is not borderline. This is a man whose brain is still injured and getting worse." She swiveled in her chair. "Who told him he was clear?"

"Dr. Warren. Team physician."

"And Warren saw these numbers?"

"He saw the club's own version of them. Which is not these numbers."

Alvarez sat back. For a long moment she just looked at Megan, and Megan felt the full weight of it — the eight days, the signed promise, the words she had not yet said out loud.

"How long have you known?"

"Eight days."

"Eight." Alvarez took her glasses off, folded them, set them on the desk. "You ran an unvalidated-on-site battery on a symptomatic professional athlete at nine forty-five at night in a public rink—"

"I had an independent witness. Priya Patel."

"Good. That was good." Alvarez nodded once, grudging. "And you've sat on data showing a man with unresolved post-concussion syndrome is taking contact shifts for eight days."

"He asked me not to tell anyone."

"He asked you." Alvarez's voice stayed level, which was somehow worse than shouting. "Megan. In 2011 I watched a forty-six-year-old man eat soup through a straw for the rest of his life because a team doctor cleared him. You know what the widow said to me? She said, everyone knew. Everyone just did what the athlete asked." She leaned forward. "How many hits has he taken since your test?"

Megan didn't answer, because she couldn't.

"That's what I thought. So here is my independent opinion." Alvarez pulled a legal pad toward her and began writing in her cramped, slanted hand. "Unresolved concussion with objective neurocognitive decline, abnormal symptom burden, and progressive deterioration across serial testing. Recommend full removal from contact and competition, minimum six weeks, followed by graded return-to-play protocol only if serial testing returns to baseline. Recommend formal neurological evaluation, not team-based." She tore the page off, signed it, and held it out. "This is you. I reviewed, I concurred. My name's not on it. I'm not licensed to practice in Illinois and I'm not getting subpoenaed for you."

"Bea—"

"I spent an hour with you and a laptop. That's what I can give you." Alvarez's face softened, a fraction. "The rest is yours. Send it to him tonight. Not tomorrow. Tonight."

Megan folded the page into her bag. At the door she stopped. "He's going to hate me."

"He's going to be alive to hate you," Alvarez said. "Go."

She wrote the email three times.

The first version was clinical — patient name, testing date, methodology, conclusion, recommendation. She deleted it because it read like a court filing and Luke would hear the lawyer in it, not her.

The second version was soft. *I know this isn't what you wanted. I know what's riding on this season.* She deleted that one too, because softness would read as apology, and she wasn't sorry for the data.

The third version she sent. She attached the scanned page, photographed her laptop's raw output, and wrote four lines:

*Luke — independent review of the results, completed this morning. Attached. The numbers are what they are. Minimum six weeks off contact, then re-test. Call me when you've read it. Doesn't matter what time.*

She hit send at 6:12 p.m. and then sat at her kitchen table with her phone face-up and did not move.

Ethan came through the door at 6:40 with his backpack hanging off one shoulder and a permission slip for a field trip to the Shedd Aquarium that had been due yesterday.

"Mama, I forgot."

"I know you did." She signed it, kissed his hair, made him macaroni, and did not look at her phone until he was in bed.

Nothing.

At 10:15 she checked again. At 11:40. At 12:30 she took the phone into the bathroom with her while she brushed her teeth, which she had never once done in her life.

She lay in the dark and reasoned with herself. He's busy. He had a game. He's processing. He's angry, and angry men go quiet, and Luke had always gone quiet before he went loud — that was the whole shape of him. He was the one who'd walked out of her apartment eleven years ago without a word and called her three weeks later from a rink in Ontario.

Except he was also the one who had answered her text about the Damen rink in forty seconds flat.

At 2 a.m. she turned the phone face-down and slept badly.

Day one, she reasoned. He's on the road. The Wolves had played in Denver. Commercial flights, media, a back-to-back. Men didn't read their email on days like that.

She called Karen at lunch and got exactly the response she should have expected.

"So he's ghosting you."

"He's not ghosting me. He's a professional athlete with a brain injury who just read a piece of paper saying his season is over. Give the man a minute."

"Uh-huh." Karen's voice carried the particular flatness of an older sister who had been right before and remembered it fondly. "Meg. You broke a promise to him. You told the neurologist. And then you sent him a report he asked you not to send anyone. He's not 'processing.' He's deciding whether he can trust you."

"I didn't send it to anyone else. I sent it to *him*."

"After you'd already shown it to her. He told you to report to him first. You reported to Alvarez first."

Megan pressed the phone harder against her ear. "It's a five-hour drive to see him in Denver. I could—"

"You could not drive to Denver to ambush an injured man in a hotel lobby. You are a mandated reporter, not a stalker."

She laughed, once, unwillingly. "What am I, then?"

"For now? You're someone who sent an email. Sit still."

Day two was worse, because day two carried a game.

Megan told herself she wouldn't watch. She watched. She put Ethan to bed at eight, sat on the couch with the laptop, and pulled up the stream on mute, and there he was on the second line, number nineteen, skating the neutral zone with that abbreviated stride he'd had since his groin in '22 — except he wasn't skating it right. His turns were wide. Twice, in the first period alone, he went into a corner and came out half a beat late, and the broadcast caught him on the bench afterward with his helmet tipped back and his glove pressed flat against his forehead.

The color commentator said, "Nineteen looks like he's fighting something tonight."

Megan closed the laptop before the second period and sat in the dark with her hands flat on her knees, breathing.

He'd read it. He had to have read it. The timestamp said delivered. He'd read it and he'd gone out and played anyway, forty-eight hours after a specialist signed a page saying twenty more shifts like these could cost him the rest of his life.

At 10:52 p.m. her phone lit up on the coffee table. She lunged for it.

It was a notification from the Wolves' front office account: *Contract signing — final notice.* The deadline, five days out, blinking up at her like an eye.

She sat with the phone in both hands. No message from Luke. No call. Somewhere in Denver his bus was pulling into a hotel, and he was somewhere in it, choosing silence.

Then, eleven minutes later, one more line of text on her screen, this time from an unknown Illinois number:

*Ms. Chen. This is Diane Reisman. I'd like to see you in my office at nine tomorrow morning. We have paperwork to finish.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 15: The Independent Opinion · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads