Breaking the Ice

Chapter 43: The Final Diagnosis

Dr. Alvarez's office was on the fourth floor of a building across from Northwestern Memorial, and it did not look like a place where careers went to die. It looked like a dentist's waiting room. Beige chairs. A rubber plant. A receptionist who offered Megan coffee while Luke sat with his hands on his knees and read the same consent form four times.

"Stop," Megan said quietly.

"I'm reading."

"You read it at home. You read it in the car. It says the same thing."

He put the clipboard down. "It says I authorize the release of my medical information to my employer."

"That's a formality."

"That's a sentence that ends with me not playing hockey."

Megan didn't answer, because she'd spent the last three weeks saying versions of *it's going to be fine* and she was running out of ways to make it true.

The door opened. Dr. Alvarez came out herself—no nurse, no assistant—and shook Luke's hand like she was meeting a colleague, which, in a way, she was. She was fifty-one, small, with gray at her temples and a way of looking at people that suggested she'd already seen the worst version of the conversation she was about to have and had decided to have it anyway.

"Mr. Kirby. Megan." She held the door. "Come in."

The office was smaller than the waiting room. Two chairs, a desk, a monitor turned so they could both see it. Alvarez sat and pulled up a file that Megan recognized, because she'd helped assemble half of it.

"Before I start," Alvarez said, "I want to say something. This is the sixth assessment you've had since January. Four of them were performed by people who had a financial relationship with the hockey club. One of them was signed by a man who is currently suspended from practice. I've looked at all six. I've also looked at your imaging from last August, the baseline you did at the start of camp, and the scans from the night you were taken off the ice."

"Which ones do you believe?" Luke asked.

"Yours," she said. "The baseline. That's the only one nobody had a reason to lie about."

She turned the monitor. A series of scans, side by side, dates in the corners.

"Here's your brain in September." She pointed. "This is what a healthy thirty-four-year-old professional athlete looks like. Here's the night of the collision." A different image, a bloom of gray. "Subdural hematoma, small, resolved on its own. That part was handled well. Whoever cleared you to come back in November did not handle it well."

Luke said nothing.

"Here's where we are now." She clicked. "The hemorrhage is gone. The tissue looks intact. If I were clearing you for a desk job, I'd sign tomorrow. But you're not asking me for a desk job."

"Say it," Luke said.

"Post-concussive syndrome, persistent, moderate to severe. Your reaction time is down eighteen percent from baseline. Your vestibular testing is abnormal on the left side. You've had two episodes in the last month that you described to Megan as *losing the room*—"

"That happened once."

"Twice," Megan said.

Luke looked at her. She didn't look away.

"Twice," Alvarez said. "And each time the recovery window got longer. That's the pattern that worries me more than the numbers."

She flipped to a page of notes, handwritten, and Megan recognized the handwriting as her own. She'd sent Alvarez a timeline of every symptom Luke had mentioned in the last six weeks—headaches, the light sensitivity, the way he'd had to sit down on the stairs at her apartment on a Tuesday and pretend he was tying his shoe. She hadn't told him she was doing it. She'd decided that if he hated her for it, she could live with that.

"The question you're asking," Alvarez said, "is whether you can play in the finals."

"Yes."

"The answer is no."

The room was very quiet. Somewhere down the hall, a printer ran.

"For how long?" Luke said.

"Six weeks minimum. Absolute rest—no contact, no skating, no weight room, no flying. After that we re-test. If your vestibular function has returned to baseline and the episodes have stopped, we can talk about a graduated return. If they haven't stopped, we talk about whether you play again at all."

"Six weeks is—" He stopped. Did the math. Megan watched him do it. "The finals end in three."

"The finals end in three."

"Then I miss them."

"Yes."

"And next season—"

"Opens in October. If you rest now, you'll be at training camp. If you play now and take one more hit—" Alvarez paused, and for the first time her voice changed, lost its clinical flatness. "I've had three patients in my career who took a second impact while still symptomatic. Two of them can't work. One of them can't live alone."

Luke stared at the scans. Megan could see his jaw working.

"Can I have a minute," he said. It wasn't a question.

Alvarez stood. "Take ten." She looked at Megan, and there was something in it—not permission, exactly. A handoff. Then she left and closed the door.

For a while neither of them said anything. Luke sat forward with his elbows on his knees, looking at the floor. Megan stayed in her chair. She'd learned, over the last few months, that the worst thing you could do to a man like Luke in a moment like this was try to make him feel better before he'd let himself feel bad.

"I knew," he said finally.

"Knew what."

"At your apartment. The Tuesday. When I sat on the stairs." He laughed, once, without any humor in it. "I told you my hamstring was tight. You knew."

"I knew."

"You didn't say anything."

"You weren't ready to hear it. If I'd pushed you then, you'd have gone to Warren and gotten another fake form signed. You had to get here yourself."

He nodded slowly. Then he said, very quietly, "I was going to lift the Cup for him."

Megan didn't have to ask who.

"He's seven. He's going to be in the building, in the stands, wearing my jersey that doesn't even fit him yet, and I was going to skate out there with the whole thing on the line and show him—" He stopped. His voice was breaking and he was fighting it, the way he fought everything, with his shoulders, with his hands. "I was going to show him what it looks like when you come back."

"You are."

"Don't."

"I'm not being kind. I'm being accurate." She moved to the chair next to him. "Ethan doesn't know what a Cup looks like. He knows what you look like when you come through my door. That's the part he draws."

Luke put his hand over his eyes.

Megan sat with him. She didn't touch him, because she wasn't sure he wanted to be touched and she wasn't going to guess wrong today. Outside, a siren went by and faded. The printer down the hall stopped.

"Six weeks," he said.

"Six weeks."

"And if I do it right, camp."

"If you do it right, camp."

"And if I don't."

"Then you don't get camp. And I'll still be here, and so will he, and that's the whole answer. That's the only answer I've got."

He took his hand down. His eyes were red but dry. He looked at her for a long moment, and she could see him doing the thing he always did—deciding what kind of man he was going to be in front of her, and then being it, whether or not it was true yet.

"Okay," he said.

Alvarez knocked and came back in. She sat down and folded her hands.

"Questions?"

"Two," Luke said. "First—how often do you get this wrong?"

"Not often. And when I do, I err toward caution, which means the players I clear come back and the players I don't are sometimes angry at me for years. I've made peace with that."

"Second," Luke said. "Can I make a call? From here. Today."

"You can make it from the parking lot."

"No." He shook his head. "I want it on the record that I asked you, in this office, with my rehab specialist sitting next to me, and you told me no."

Alvarez looked at him. Then she looked at Megan, and this time her expression was easy to read: *this one's a keeper*, which was a strange thing to think under the circumstances.

"I'll put it in the chart," she said. "You were advised against play on—" she checked her watch—"November twelfth, four forty-one p.m. You asked for it in writing. I gave it to you."

"Do I get to make the statement how I want?"

"You get to say whatever you want. You just don't get to say I cleared you."

Luke stood. He shook her hand, and he shook it the way he shook hands with men he'd fought, which was the highest compliment Megan had ever seen him pay anyone.

In the hallway, by the elevator, he stopped. He put both hands flat against the wall and stood there with his head down. Megan waited.

"I have to call the GM," he said.

"I know."

"And the owner. He's expecting me at the apology on Thursday. I said I'd stand next to him."

"You can still stand next to him."

"Not in a suit. He wants the jersey." Luke lifted his head. "He wanted the photo."

Megan said nothing, because he was already three steps ahead of her, and she could see him arriving somewhere she hadn't expected.

"Then I'll wear the jersey," he said. "And I'll hold the press conference right after. Before he can spin it as *mutual.*"

"Luke—"

He turned to her. "You asked me what I was going to show Ethan." The elevator dinged. He didn't move. "I'm going to show him what it looks like to walk away from the thing you want most. He needs that one too. Somebody should have shown me."

The doors opened. Nobody got in or out.

"Then I won't play," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 43: The Final Diagnosis · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads