Breaking the Ice

Chapter 55: The Original Data

The conference room smelled like burnt coffee and printer toner. Megan had been in it since seven-forty, and by ten the table had accumulated three laptops, one recorder no one had asked permission to bring, and a stack of paper an inch thick that kept getting reshuffled by people who wanted to look busy.

Vasquez sat at the head. She had brought a lawyer, a woman named Okonkwo with gray-streaked braids and a manner so flat it could have been used to level a table.

"Read it," Okonkwo said.

Megan read it.

The independent lab had received the tablet under seal on Tuesday at 4:12 p.m. Signature of the courier, signature of the receiving tech, photographs of the packaging before and after. The drive had been imaged in the presence of two witnesses. The file bearing Megan's name — the one the league auditing office had wanted to discuss — was dated March 3, last year, at 11:47 p.m.

Megan remembered that night. She remembered because Ethan had had a fever and she had sat up with him until eleven, and then she had opened her laptop and finished the baseline battery because Luke's score had dipped that afternoon and Warren wanted a second data point on the same instrument before he'd sign anything.

She had emailed it at midnight. The email was on page nine, in the appendix. Sent March 4, 12:03 a.m.

The lab's summary was four paragraphs. The first three were technical. The fourth said the submitted file was consistent with a native entry, not a backdated or transcribed import, and that the timestamp cluster matched the surrounding work session.

"Say it plainly," Megan said.

Okonkwo turned a page. "Your note is authentic. Someone copied it out of your account and put it on a server they didn't have the right to touch. That's the finding."

"Someone."

"Two someones, listed by name," Okonkwo said. "One is a systems contractor the Wolves retained in early March. The other is a staff assistant in Dr. Warren's office who signed the access log eleven times in six weeks."

Vasquez leaned back. "The league gets this at four o'clock today. I'm walking it in myself."

"Press," Megan said.

"Not yet. Tomorrow, maybe. The panel first."

The recorder on the table clicked off. Someone had finally noticed it.

The league took six days.

Megan spent most of them in the clinic, which was the only place that didn't require her to sit still and think about what was coming. She taped ankles. She ran a pitcher through scapular strengthening. She watched Luke's team practice from the glass twice and did not wave, because the boys were watching and he understood.

On the seventh morning, a Friday, the panel issued a two-page release.

The league cleared Megan Chen of any alteration of neurocognitive records. It stated that the data she had produced was accurate, contemporaneous, and clinically sound. It stated that the Wolves' medical staff had failed to preserve original documentation as required, that records submitted to the return-to-play review had been "incomplete and materially misleading," and that the conduct of certain individuals was under referral to the appropriate licensing and enforcement bodies. It did not name Warren. It didn't have to. Everyone in Chicago who cared already knew who the team doctor was.

Luke called her at 8:20.

"Did you read it?"

"Twice."

"'Clinically sound.' That's you." His voice was rough, the way it got when he hadn't slept and was trying not to show it. "You know what they didn't say? They didn't say sorry."

"They said it in the only way that matters."

"That's not the same thing, Meg."

"No," she said. "It isn't."

Silence. Then, quieter: "Ethan asked me this morning what a deposition is. I told him it's like when a teacher asks the class a question and you have to tell the truth even if it's scary."

She closed her eyes. "What did he say?"

"He said he's good at that."

She laughed, and it came out wet.

The licensing board moved faster than anyone expected, which Okonkwo said was because the league referral was the equivalent of a letter written on stationery nobody wanted in their file.

Warren had thirty days to respond to the complaint. He used eleven.

The hearing was in a rented room in the Loop, on the fourth floor of a building full of insurance offices, and Megan sat in the second row next to Okonkwo and did not look at Warren once. She had promised herself that going in. She broke it within four minutes. He was smaller than she remembered. Last year he'd filled a room. Now he looked like a man who had stopped sleeping and started reading his own press.

The state's expert was a neuropsychologist from Ann Arbor who had never met any of them. She explained, in the tone of someone reading a grocery list, what a baseline battery was for, how it establishes an athlete's personal normal, and how a fabricated low score on a post-injury evaluation could be used to justify withholding clearance indefinitely.

"Why would anyone do that?" the board chair asked.

"To keep a player off the ice without having to explain it to him," the expert said. "Or because someone above them wanted him off the ice."

"Objection."

"Noted. Not sustained."

Warren's attorney argued that his client had relied in good faith on digital records provided by the club, that he had no knowledge of the discrepancies, that he had been as deceived as anyone. It was a decent argument for about twenty minutes.

Then the board asked Warren directly whether he had ever instructed his staff assistant to pull a player's file from a specialist's private account.

Warren said he had no recollection.

The board produced the access log with the eleven signatures and asked again.

Warren said the assistant had come to him with concerns.

And then Tom Kirby, who had been sitting in the back the whole time with his cap in his lap, stood up and said, into a room that had gone completely silent, "He told me to lose the March papers. He stood in my office and said it. There's a second set in the machine room if you want it."

The chair called a recess. There wasn't one.

The order came down on a Wednesday, three weeks after the league release.

Warren's license was suspended. Not revoked — the language was careful, and Okonkwo said the difference was a procedural courtesy for a first finding — but suspended pending a formal revocation hearing with a presumptive permanent bar. He could not practice. He could not consult. He could not sign his name to a medical opinion in the state of Illinois. It ran four pages, and the last one said, in the flattest sentence in the whole document: *The licensee's conduct placed an athlete's health and career at material risk and undermined the integrity of the patient record.*

Megan read it standing in her kitchen at six in the morning, coffee going cold on the counter, Ethan still asleep down the hall.

She texted Luke one word. *Done.*

He called nine seconds later. She could hear the rink behind him, the slap of pucks, someone yelling a count.

"He's out," Luke said.

"He's out."

"You okay?"

She thought about it honestly, which was something she was trying to do more of. "I thought I'd feel taller," she said. "I don't. I just feel like it's over."

"That's how it feels when it's over."

"Are you at practice?"

"Yeah. I gotta go in a second, we're doing breakouts." A pause. "Hey. Meg. Tomorrow, after the deposition — I want to take you and Ethan somewhere. Nowhere fancy. Just somewhere that isn't a conference room."

"Okay," she said.

"Okay." He breathed out. "One more thing. The auditor called my agent this morning. They're pulling Warren's entire case history. Every player, four years. That's going to touch a lot of people."

Megan set her mug down. "How many?"

"I don't know. A dozen. More." A beat. "Some of them are still playing. Some of them aren't playing anymore because of him, and nobody ever told them why."

She looked down the hall at the half-closed door to Ethan's room.

"You should tell the union," she said. "Before they read it in the paper."

"Yeah."

"And Luke —"

"I know."

He said it before she could finish, which was its own kind of answer, and she stood there in the gray kitchen light holding the phone and understanding, finally, that the part that was over was the part about her. The rest of it was just starting.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 55: The Original Data · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads