Build and Release

Chapter 60: The Review Bomb

The first sign was Hana's face.

She came through the kitchen door at eight-forty in the morning holding her laptop open like it was something contaminated, and the whole room went quiet in the way it did when someone walked in with bad news but hadn't said it yet. Owen was pouring coffee. Felix was at the table pretending to eat a bagel, because he was still on three days of no-screens and had negotiated himself down to two hours a day and had blown through both hours by Monday.

"Okay," Hana said. "Don't panic."

"Great start," Owen said.

"Steam reviews."

She set the laptop down and turned it around so they could see. Owen put his coffee down without drinking any of it. Felix did not bother pretending to eat the bagel anymore.

Four hundred and twelve negative reviews. In ninety minutes. The score had dropped from Overwhelmingly Positive — twenty-one hundred reviews, ninety-four percent — to Very Positive, and it was still falling while they watched.

Most of them were one or two lines. *Don't buy, they put their politics in it.* *Ruined a good game with a romance nobody asked for.* *Refunded.* Some of them were longer and worse, paragraphs of it, the kind of thing that had clearly been copied, pasted, and edited only enough to look organic. Owen scrolled. The same phrases kept surfacing like fish. *Agenda.* *Forced.* *Every time I try to play it I get preached at.* One review had been posted eleven times by accounts with no other reviews, no playtime worth mentioning, created in the last two weeks.

"New accounts," Owen said. "Look at this. These accounts didn't exist last month."

"Yeah," Hana said. "A hundred and eighty of them were created in the last ten days."

"Then we report them. This isn't a review bomb, this is fraud, we've got the pattern—"

"Owen." Felix's voice was quiet.

Owen looked up.

"Let them," Felix said.

There was a beat where Owen was sure he'd heard it wrong. "What?"

"Let them." Felix pulled the laptop toward himself even though he wasn't supposed to be looking at a screen, and scrolled slowly, one hand flat on the table like he needed to brace himself. "I know what this is. I've seen it before — not on a game, on a Kickstarter, back in the day. You go in and you argue. You report them, you post your receipts, you say *actually, here's the evidence,* and it doesn't matter. Because the people who were going to buy the game already bought it, and the people posting this were never going to. The only audience you're playing to is the fight itself." He closed the laptop. "And the fight is what they want. That's the whole point. If we make it a fight, it becomes a fight."

"It's already a fight. It's a fight about whether our story gets to exist—"

"It's a fight about whether it gets to *matter*." Felix looked at him. His eyes were still bad — the doctor had said four more days and he had done two, maybe — but his voice was steady. "If we go out there and start swinging, the story becomes *studio responds to criticism.* We become the studio with the controversy. And every outlet that was going to write 'two founders made a game about a love they hid for five years' writes 'studio under fire' instead. That's a worse article. That's a worse article *for us,* Owen."

Hana had her arms crossed. "He's right. I hate it, but he's right. Nadia will say the same thing, and so will I."

Owen walked to the window. The light out there was flat and white, the usual San Francisco morning that couldn't decide whether it was fog or just overcast, the whole city the color of a browser window that hadn't loaded. He put his hands in his pockets.

Four thousand people had bought the game in the two days after he'd posted the update. Eighty-one percent of the people who'd downloaded the stripped build had turned around and paid for the real one. That was the number he'd been carrying around like a stone in his pocket since last week. Real people, choosing it. And now four hundred people he had never met were standing in the doorway telling everyone who'd listen not to come in.

"I hate it," he said.

"I know," Felix said. "So do I."

"So we just — watch."

"We watch. And we finish the build. We ship the patch, we fix the save migration for the people still crashing on load two, we answer every actual support ticket in the queue, and we let the honest reviews do the thing honest reviews do."

Owen turned around. Felix was still sitting there in yesterday's hoodie with his hand on the closed laptop, and the thing Owen felt was not agreement. It was the same thing he'd felt at four in the morning in the office two weeks ago, watching the sun come up on the floor: the specific vertigo of trusting somebody with the part of your life you can't see the bottom of.

"Okay," Owen said.

They watched.

It was worse before it got better.

By eleven the score was at eighty-eight percent and the negative count was up to six hundred and forty. By one it was eighty-six, and the store page's "recent reviews" summary — the one that only looked at the last thirty days, the one that most people actually read — had flipped to Mixed, with a yellow flag where the blue one had been, and Owen stood at his desk and looked at that yellow flag for a long time and did not say anything.

The support queue was four hundred tickets deep. Owen took two hundred of them himself, sitting in the back with his headphones off, answering people who couldn't get their old saves to load, people whose cloud sync had grabbed the wrong file, people who wrote *hey, no problem, take your time* at the end of a paragraph of detailed crash logs. He liked those people. He liked them so much it was almost unbearable.

At two-fifteen, Felix came and put a hand on his shoulder. "Look."

He had Hana's laptop. The recent-reviews score.

Eighty-nine.

"What happened," Owen said.

Felix sat down on the edge of the desk. "A reviewer with about four hundred thousand followers played it last night."

"Oh no."

"She said it was the best-written romance she'd played since—" He glanced at the laptop. "Since a game we are legally not allowed to be compared to. She said the last hour made her cry. She posted a screenshot of the boot statement."

The boot statement. The three paragraphs they'd written at four in the morning, the ones they'd shoved into the launch build's first thirty seconds so that anyone who started the game would see them before they saw anything else. Nadia had wanted to cut them. Owen had refused. They'd stayed.

"People are posting their own reviews now," Felix said. "Real ones. Long ones. People who've been playing since early access and have two hundred hours on the clock and are *upset* about the review bomb. They're going through and downvoting the fake accounts themselves. Somebody made a spreadsheet."

"Of course somebody made a spreadsheet."

"Somebody always makes a spreadsheet."

Owen refreshed the page. Ninety-two percent. The count was up to three thousand and something. He refreshed again. Ninety-two.

He should have felt exultant. Instead he felt like someone who had held his breath so long his chest hurt, and was only now noticing.

"We're still down from where we started," he said. "Ninety-four to ninety-two. We lost two points and we're getting an article out of it either way, and the thing that got Marcus's attention is still—"

"Owen."

"What."

Felix reached over and turned the laptop so it faced him, and Owen looked, and the number had ticked to ninety-three. And underneath the score, in the little box where developers could pin a note, there was a new comment from Hana. She must have posted it while they were talking.

*Thank you to everyone who played and left an honest review today. 4,106 people restored their saves this week. Every one of you is the reason this game exists.*

Owen read it twice.

"That's good," he said.

"It's Hana."

"Yeah."

Felix's phone buzzed on the desk. He glanced at it, and something crossed his face — not surprise, exactly. More like the arrival of a thing that had been scheduled and had taken its time.

"It's Nadia," he said. "She wants us on a call in ten minutes. She says Marcus filed something against the release this morning. And she says —"

He stopped.

"Says what," Owen said.

Felix looked up. "She says Diane Keller called *her* first."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.