Counterpoint

Chapter 11: The Backroom Fiddle

The alley smelled of rain that hadn't fallen yet, wet brick and cold metal, the promise of it in the air. Milo had his hands in his jacket pockets and his back against the wall like he'd been there an hour, like finding Jonas half-collapsed against a dumpster was just the night's scheduled stop.

"You're green," Milo said.

"I'm fine."

"You're the color of the urinal cakes in there." Milo pushed off the wall and came closer, not crowding, just close enough that Jonas could see the pupil dilate under the sodium light. "You played that melody eight nights ago with no one watching. Tonight four hundred people chanted it back at you. That's a lot of firsts for one evening."

Jonas pressed the heel of his hand against his sternum. His heart was doing something arrhythmic and stupid. "Why would you play it as the closer? You said—"

"I didn't play it. The room did. I just left the door open." Milo's mouth tilted. "You want to sit down? You look like you're about to do something embarrassing."

Jonas didn't sit. He straightened and made himself breathe from the diaphragm, the way he'd been taught at nine years old by a woman who hit his knuckles with a pencil when he breathed wrong. "That was my playing. In a room full of people. And they—"

"Knew it by heart, yeah." Milo tipped his head. "That's what happens when a thing is good."

It wasn't the compliment that undid him, it was the ordinariness of it. Milo said *good* the way Jonas's conductor said *again*. As if the fact were settled and boring.

"You should have told them," Jonas said. "It's not mine anymore. It's out there. I can't undo it."

"No."

"You're not sorry."

"I'm not." Milo turned and walked three steps down the alley, then stopped, half-turned, hands still pocketed. "Here's the thing, though. That was a recording. A file. It's a ghost. It played out of a laptop at eleven forty-five and a room sang along to a ghost."

Jonas said nothing.

"What happens if it's not a ghost," Milo said. "What happens if you're there."

The cold came up through Jonas's shoes, through his socks, into the bone. He knew what Milo was asking. He'd known from the moment he stepped out of the venue doorway and Milo was already in the alley, waiting, like he'd known Jonas would break before Jonas did.

"No," Jonas said. "Absolutely not."

"Okay."

"Don't—" Jonas stopped. "Don't just say okay. You're going to say it anyway. You're going to say it three more times in different voices until I—"

"I said okay." Milo shrugged. "You said no. I heard no. I'm a professional. I respect no."

"You're not going to—"

"Next month's set. Same room, bigger rig, they're putting in a proper stage. I'm booked for the closing slot again." Milo looked up at the strip of sky between the buildings, the orange underlit clouds. "I'm going to keep the door open. That's all I'm saying. The door stays open."

"That's the same thing dressed up."

"It's completely different." Milo looked back down. "One of them involves me asking you for something. This doesn't involve me asking you for anything. You can show up or you can't. That's yours."

Jonas laughed, and it came out wrong, too high, too close to something. "That's manipulation."

"That's an open door." Milo started walking again, back toward the venue's rear service entrance, and Jonas fell in beside him without deciding to. Their shoulders were maybe a hand-width apart. The alley narrowed. "I'll tell you what's manipulation. I could put your name on the credits. One email to my distributor. Jonas Frei, violin, track two. You'd have a fucking problem with your orchestra for the rest of your life."

Jonas's feet stopped before his brain did.

"I won't," Milo said, still walking, then stopped too, a few steps ahead. "That's the thing you should be worried about and you're not even thinking about it. You're over there having a crisis about four hundred strangers singing a melody. Meanwhile I have your legal name in a folder on my phone."

The two unread messages from the Pflegeheim sat in Jonas's pocket like two smooth stones, and beneath them the envelope sealed at home, and beneath that the clause he'd signed, and the word *uncredited*, which Jonas had read seven times in Kessler's office and which Milo had just used like it was an insult he was choosing not to throw.

"Why wouldn't you?" Jonas said. His voice came out flat. "You'd sell more."

"I would." Milo turned around. His face in the sodium light was unreadable, which meant nothing, because his face was unreadable in every light. "I don't want your name on my track. I want your hands in the room."

"That's—" Jonas couldn't finish. *Worse*, he wanted to say. That's worse.

"Come inside," Milo said. "It's cold and you're shaking and there's a kettle in the back and I have to break down the rig. You can stand there and be furious at me while I coil cables."

The back room of the power station was a concrete box with a single bulb and a folding table and somebody's abandoned leather jacket on a chair. Milo's crew had already stacked the speakers along one wall. Milo filled a kettle from a plastic bottle because the tap was industrial and put it on a camping burner with the same economy Jonas used to tune a string.

Jonas stood by the door. Then he sat on the abandoned chair. Then he took his phone out.

The Pflegeheim messages were both from the same number, eleven minutes apart. He opened the first. *Herr Frei, Fr. Weber says your mother has not eaten the evening meal for three days. Please call at your convenience.* The second: *Also the Pflegeversicherung adjustment requires your signature by the 15th.*

He locked the phone and put it face down on the table.

Milo poured water into two enamel cups and dropped a tea bag in each. "Family?"

"Don't."

"I didn't ask."

"You asked."

"I asked a one-word question with a rising intonation. That's not asking." Milo slid a cup across the table. It stopped a hand-width short of Jonas's fingers, exactly the same distance their shoulders had been in the alley. "Drink it. You look like a haunted Victorian child."

Jonas drank it. It was terrible. It was the best thing he'd had in a week, and he hated how easy that was to admit to himself.

"Your hands," Milo said.

Jonas put the cup down. "What about them."

"You were holding the rim like it was a neck." Milo sat on the edge of the table, not the chair, the table, which put him a head above Jonas in the low room, and looked down. "Left hand. The calluses. Let me see."

"No."

"Okay."

Jonas put his left hand on the table. Palm up. The calluses were exactly where thirty years of the same four strings had put them: the ridge on the index, the split at the middle fingertip, the flat pad on the pinky from tenths that never came clean. Milo leaned in and didn't touch them, just looked, the way Jonas looked at a score before he played it, reading ahead.

"How long," Milo said.

"Since six."

"*Six*."

"Six years old. My mother—" Jonas stopped. The phone was face down but it was in the room. "There was a teacher in the neighborhood. She had a studio above a bakery and she took students by audition. I got in."

"Did you want to?"

The question was so stupid that Jonas almost didn't answer it. Nobody had asked him that. Not Kessler, not his stand partner, not Alma since before the strokes, no one, the entire apparatus of the Staatsorchester rested on the assumption that the wanting was pre-installed at the factory.

"I don't know," he said. It came out honest. He heard it land.

Milo nodded like that was the answer he'd expected, which meant he'd either asked the question before or read it off Jonas's face, and Jonas couldn't tell which possibility made him more uncomfortable.

"So you've been behind a wall for twenty-three years," Milo said. "And last month I put a wall around your wall and you're mad at me for noticing."

"I'm not mad at you."

"You're something at me."

Jonas stood up. The chair scraped concrete. He was close enough now, in the low room with the single bulb, to see that Milo was tired — the crease under the eyes, the way he'd been running on adrenaline at the set and was now running on fumes. He looked younger without the lights on him. That was the unfair part. Everyone looked younger in the dark.

"I'll do one night," Jonas said.

Milo's face didn't change.

"One. The next set. Unannounced. No credits, no recording, nothing exported, nothing—" He stopped. His pulse was in his throat. "One night. And then we're done with the violin. You keep the B-side. You don't get another."

Milo looked at him for a long time. Then he picked up his cup and drank the tea, which Jonas had been unable to make himself do.

"Okay," he said.

"Say it means something."

"It means something." Milo set the cup down. "It means you're going to walk into a room of four hundred people with your instrument in your hand and no wall between you and any of them. That means everything and none of it is mine." He stood. "One condition."

Jonas's jaw tightened. "You said no conditions."

"I lied. You'll want to know this one." Milo reached past him, close, so close Jonas could smell cigarettes he hadn't smoked and the wet wool of his jacket, and flicked off the bulb. The room went dark except for the strip under the service door. "When you're up there, play something they haven't heard. Not the session melody. Something of your own."

"I—"

"Something of your own," Milo said, from the dark, from the door. "That's the whole condition." The door opened onto the alley, and the sodium light came in and hit Jonas's face. Milo was silhouetted in it, hand on the frame. "And Jonas."

"What."

"You've got a face that doesn't belong in the dark." He stepped out. The door swung shut.

Jonas stood there for a minute in the concrete room with the two cups and the kettle. Then he picked up his phone, face down, the two unread messages still waiting, and he didn't read them, and he didn't call anyone, and he walked home the long way, and the line Milo had said went around in his skull like a theme he couldn't place, a contour with no key, and by the time he reached his building he'd stopped trying to make it stop and had started, without deciding to, to hum.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 11: The Backroom Fiddle · Counterpoint · Lumen Reads