Counterpoint

Chapter 60: The Admission

The hearing was in the Kammermusiksaal, the small one on the second floor, the one they used for auditions. Jonas had played his probationary audition here eleven years ago, behind a screen, while Kessler sat in the dark deciding whether he was worth keeping. Now the screens were stacked against the wall and the table was pushed to the front, and there was no screen between him and anyone.

Four of them behind the table. Kessler in the middle. The personnel director, a woman from the legal office with a folder she never opened, and Brendel, the second violinist who had been on the board longer than anyone could remember and slept through most of it. Ruth Weber sat in the third row of empty seats, which she had not been asked to do and had done anyway.

"Thank you for coming," Kessler said. "You may sit."

"I'll stand."

"As you prefer." Kessler lifted a page. "The purpose of this hearing is to establish the facts of an undisclosed external engagement, publicly attributed, that has caused material damage to the orchestra's reputation. There is a transcript. You have had it for a week. Do you dispute it?"

"No."

"You're aware the transcript identifies you as the arranger of a work that has been streamed four million times under another artist's name."

"I'm aware."

"And you recorded a string part for that work in a private studio in Kreuzberg on the ninth of January, four days after submitting a written request for leave on grounds of a family matter."

"Yes."

"Was there a family matter?"

Jonas looked at the four of them. He had rehearsed this. He had rehearsed it walking from the U-Bahn, and on the stairs, and standing in the lobby pretending to read the notice board. Every version of it had sounded like an excuse. So he used the one that didn't.

"No," he said. "There was no family matter. I invented it so I could be in Kreuzberg that week without anyone asking where I was. The request was a lie, and I wrote it on orchestra letterhead and signed my own name to it, and I apologize for that in a way I don't expect you to accept."

Brendel's pen stopped moving. The woman from legal opened the folder after all.

"Go on," Kessler said. His voice gave nothing.

"In December I assigned a piece of my own to a broadcast under an unaffiliated pseudonym. I didn't declare it. I told myself it was a small thing, that it was anonymous, that it wouldn't touch the orchestra. That was also a lie. I knew what I was doing. I knew it could be traced to me and I did it anyway."

"Who knew you were doing it?"

"Nobody here."

"Someone must have encouraged you."

"Nobody here," Jonas said again. "There's a DJ. He's the one on the record. He didn't ask me to break any rule. He put a melody on a stage because he believed it was worth putting on a stage, and I let him, and the only person who knew what it would cost was me."

Kessler set the page down and flattened it with two fingers.

"Then I'd like to understand the cost to you," he said. "Because from where I sit, the arithmetic doesn't work. You were offered a spring solo. You were nine weeks from a position with tenure. Whatever this paid you, it cannot have paid you that."

Jonas reached into his jacket and took out the letter.

It was two pages, handwritten, folded twice. He had written it on Ada's dining table at three in the morning while her kettle clicked itself off over and over. He had written it to the board. He had not sent it, because sending it would have made it a document, and he wanted it to be a thing he said out loud while people watched him say it.

"I'd like to read this to you," he said. "It's addressed to you. I didn't send it because I wanted to read it in the room."

Kessler glanced at the legal woman. She shrugged.

"Read it."

Jonas unfolded it. His hands were steady, which surprised him, because his hands were never steady.

"'To the board of the Staatsorchester Berlin. On the fifth of January I requested leave on the grounds of a family matter. There was no family matter. I wrote those words because I was frightened of the truth, and the truth is this.'"

He paused. The room had a hum to it, the ventilation, the same hum he had heard on this floor every day for eleven years.

"'Since March of last year my mother has been a resident of the Pflegeheim Sonnenhof in Reinickendorf. The monthly cost exceeds the income from my seat by a margin I will not detail here, except to say that it is not small, that it grows, and that I have covered it by accepting work I have no business accepting and by borrowing from people who were generous enough not to write it down.'"

Ruth Weber's head came up.

"'I did not disclose this. Not to the personnel office, not to my section, not to anyone, because disclosure would have made me a case rather than a violinist, and because there is a version of the story in which a man who cannot cover his mother's care is not a man who should be given the solo. I suspect that version is the true one. So I took the money and I kept the story to myself, and the story is what you are here to judge, but the money is why the story exists. I would rather you knew both.'"

He turned the page.

"'I have no defense of the omission itself. I had the remedy of disclosure and I declined it, repeatedly, over months, in full knowledge of the rule. What I did, I did deliberately, and I am not asking you to treat it as carelessness, because it was not.'"

The legal woman was writing now.

"'I offer my resignation from the seat of first violin effective immediately, and I ask that it be accepted without prejudice to the other members of my section, who knew nothing. If you would prefer a suspension without pay pending your own findings, I will accept that instead. I ask only that whatever you decide, it is written down and signed, so that nobody in this building has to wonder afterward what was true.'"

He folded the letter and put it on the table, and stepped back.

The hum went on.

Brendel was looking at the table with an expression Jonas couldn't read, and then he said, quietly, "The ninth of January you were also at the Streichquartett rehearsal for the Meistersaal. Three hours. My wife saw you."

"I was."

"Before or after the studio."

"Before."

Brendel nodded slowly and said nothing else, and Jonas understood that Brendel had known something for months and had been waiting to find out whether it mattered.

Kessler hadn't moved. He looked at the letter on the table like it was something that had crawled in.

"The board will deliberate," he said. "Please wait in the corridor."

"That's all?"

"What more would you like?"

"I'd like to know whether the Pflegeheim has called this office," Jonas said.

The legal woman looked at Kessler. Kessler did not look at her.

"That's a question for another proceeding," he said.

"It isn't, because the answer changes what I'm asking for. If you intend to make my mother's placement part of your reasoning, I need to know now, because I will withdraw the resignation and fight it, and you'll lose the press cycle you think you're buying."

"You're in no position to threaten this board."

"I'm not threatening. I'm telling you where the line is."

Kessler stood up. "Clear the room."

Ruth Weber didn't move. Kessler looked at her and she looked back and after a moment she stood and walked out, and the legal woman gathered her folder, and Brendel pushed his chair in very carefully, the way a man does when he has decided not to say the only sentence he has.

Jonas picked up his letter. Nobody stopped him.

In the corridor the light came through the tall windows and lay in stripes across the parquet. He stood in one of the stripes and put his back against the wall and waited, and after about four minutes his phone buzzed in his pocket.

A message from a number he had saved under no name at all.

*Is this Jonas Frei? I'm sorry—*

He looked at it for a long time.

Then, under it, another message arrived from the same number. Three words this time, and no apology in them.

*I need to tell you something before you read it in a newspaper.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 60: The Admission · Counterpoint · Lumen Reads