Letters from the Coast

Chapter 28: The Break

The wind off Castine Harbor had teeth. Nathan stood at the bench with his hands jammed in his coat pockets, watching Ben walk up the slope from the landing, the box under his arm. The same box. The one Nathan had read half of in Belfast, letters that had carved Daniel's sickness out of the dark and laid it bare. Twenty-six letters Ben had kept for eleven months. Twenty-six Nathan had never known existed.

Ben stopped a few feet away. He didn't sit.

"You said stay," Ben said. "So I stayed."

"I know what I said."

"Then what is this, Nathan? Because I've been driving circles around this coast for two days trying to figure out what you want from me, and I still don't—"

"Neither do I." Nathan heard how flat his own voice was. He hated it. He kept going anyway. "That plaque. Daniel put it there. He wanted me to move on. He built this whole thing — the letters, the route, splitting them between us — like he was setting a clock. And I keep thinking, if he wanted me to move on so badly, why did he make sure it was you I'd have to do it with?"

Ben's jaw worked. "Maybe because he knew."

"Knew what?"

"That I'd never stopped." Ben's voice dropped. "You know that now. You've known since Belfast. I told you the truth because you asked me to, and because I'm done lying to you, even by omission."

"That's the problem," Nathan said. "You're not lying. You never lied. Daniel lied. By not telling me he was dying. By writing letters I wasn't supposed to read until he was gone. By making me walk his last route with you standing at the end of it like — like a door he'd left open."

"Nathan—"

"I can't." The words came out before Nathan had decided to say them, and once they were out they felt true in a way that scared him. "I can't do this. Not here. Not now. Not with you."

Ben's face didn't change, which was worse than if it had. He'd been braced for it. He'd been braced for it since Belfast.

"Okay," he said.

"Don't do that."

"Do what?"

"Agree with me like it's a favor."

Ben set the box down on the bench, slow, deliberate, the way you'd set down something breakable. "You want me to argue? Fine. Stay. Come back to Rockland with me. Open the rest of those letters at my kitchen table and yell at Daniel and yell at me and let me be there for it. That's what I want. I've wanted it for a year. You know that."

"And when the letters run out?"

"Then we figure out what's left."

Nathan looked at the harbor. A lobster boat was coming in, gulls dragging behind it like torn paper. He thought about the painting. Ben on the ferry, and Nathan in the background, painted by a man who was dying and never said so. Daniel had made a picture of a life Nathan hadn't lived yet. Nathan didn't know if it was a gift or a sentence.

"I need to be alone," he said.

Ben was quiet for a long moment. "For how long?"

"I don't know."

"Nathan." Ben stepped closer, close enough that Nathan could smell the diesel and salt on him, close enough that it would have taken almost nothing to close the gap. Nathan didn't. "I'll give you space. I'll give you as much as you need. But I'm forty-six years old and I've spent eleven months holding a box of another man's letters like it was a hostage. I'm not going to stand on a dock forever."

"I'm not asking you to."

"I know you're not. That's the thing." Ben picked up his keys. "But I'm telling you anyway. I won't wait forever."

He didn't touch Nathan. He didn't say goodbye. He just walked back down to the landing, and Nathan stood at the bench with the plaque and the box and watched the ferry lights come on against the gray water, and then he was alone with the wind.

He drove home the long way. Route 1 up through Bucksport, the Penobscot narrow and black under the bridge, then the turn east toward Camden with the headlights carving the dark and the box riding on the passenger seat like a passenger. He kept the radio off. He kept the painting out of his mind as long as he could, and then he didn't, and it was still there, Ben in the wheelhouse and Nathan standing behind him in the light.

It was past nine when he pulled up behind the bookstore. The apartment above was cold. He hadn't told anyone he was coming back. He carried the box inside, set it on the counter, and stood in the dark of the shop with the smell of paper and old floorboards around him, which was the smell of the only thing he'd ever built that had nothing to do with Daniel and nothing to do with Ben.

He turned on the desk lamp. The store looked the way he'd left it — a stack of returns waiting to be shelved, a mug gone cold on the register, the cash drawer he'd forgotten to lock. Normal. He'd wanted normal so badly.

The box sat there. Twenty-six letters, and he'd read most of them, but not all. There was one left on the top of the stack that he hadn't opened, the one Ben had pulled out and turned over in his hands in Belfast and then put back without a word. And there was the sealed envelope from Margaret, still where he'd left it, in the glovebox of the car outside.

He didn't touch either one.

He hung his coat on the hook by the door, and the hook was loose again, the way it had been loose for a year, and Daniel had always meant to fix it, and there was no one now to fix it but Nathan, and he stood there with his hand on the coat and understood that he had come home to a building full of somebody else's ghost, and that he had sent away the only person who knew how to stand in it with him.

He sat down behind the counter. The lamp buzzed. Outside, a car went by on the coast road, slowed, and didn't stop.

Nathan put his head in his hands and did not cry, and did not open the box, and did not call anyone, and the store was very quiet.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 28: The Break · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads