The bell over the door of Haskell's Hardware hadn't changed in twenty years, and neither had the smell—sawdust, oil, the faint mineral cold of the pipe fittings in back. Nathan had come for a box of wood screws and a new weatherstrip for the shop's back door, the one that leaked whenever the wind came off the water. He had the screws in his hand and was crouched in front of the weatherstripping rack, reading the sizes like they were a language he'd once known, when a voice said his name.
"Guess it's a small town after all."
Nathan didn't have to turn around. He'd have known the voice in a dark room, at the bottom of the sea, anywhere.
"I live here," he said. "It's my town." He picked a strip off the rack, didn't look at it. "You're the one who keeps washing up."
Ben came down the aisle and stopped a few feet away, hands in the pockets of his jacket, the same captain's coat as last week. He looked like a man who'd been sleeping on a boat that rode rougher than it used to. "I'm in for the week," he said. "The *Greta*'s in dry dock. Rotten plank in the stern. She's older than both of us put together."
"Everything is," Nathan said, and stood up.
For a second neither of them said anything. There was a cashier at the front of the store pretending very hard to be reading a catalog, and the radiator ticking somewhere in the back, and the two of them standing in the narrow aisle like they'd been arranged there by somebody with a cruel sense of composition.
"You want to have a cup of coffee," Ben said. It wasn't a question exactly, but it wasn't a command either.
"No."
"All right."
Nathan went up to the register with his screws and his weatherstrip. The cashier rang him up—thirteen dollars and change—and Nathan paid and took the bag and got most of the way to the door before he stopped, because he was forty-five years old and he wasn't going to walk out of a store like a kid caught doing something.
He turned around.
"There something else?" he said.
Ben was still standing in the aisle, holding a length of chain he'd picked up off the shelf without appearing to notice. He looked at it, then set it down. "In the fall of the year before he got sick," he said, "Daniel came to me. He wanted eight thousand dollars. I gave it to him."
The bag in Nathan's hand went heavier, like the screws had grown.
"I know," Nathan said.
"You know, because I believe you were sitting right there," Ben said. His voice was even. "You told him not to take it. I remember exactly what you said. You said, we don't borrow from friends."
"And Daniel took it anyway."
"He took it anyway." Ben turned his wrist a little, like he was looking at a watch that wasn't there. "And it was never paid back. Not by him. And not by you."
Nathan felt the floor of his chest go out from under him, the way it did when a call came in the night, the way it had when the lawyer phoned two years ago and said there was a box and did Mr. Cole have an hour. Only this was stupider. This was money. This was an old number.
"Isaac," he said. "You're standing in Haskell's Hardware bringing up money."
"I'm not bringing it up for the money."
"Then why."
"Because I wrote it off," Ben said. "Years ago. I wrote it off the day Daniel told me he was dying. I never expected a dollar back from either of you, and I never wanted one." He paused. "But I notice you never once said the words. That's all. That's the whole thing. It's been eight years and I've never heard you say the words."
Nathan's face was hot. He hated it, hated that his body was still this easy to work, hated that Ben could still find the lever after all this time.
"I haven't forgotten," Nathan said.
"No," Ben said quietly. "I don't imagine you have."
The cashier closed the register drawer with a bang. The radiator ticked. Outside, somebody's truck coughed to life and idled and then drove off.
Nathan looked at the bag in his hand, at his own knuckles gone pale around the handle. "You want to hear me say thank you," he said. "After everything."
"I want to hear you say anything that isn't the two sentences you've been saying to me since I walked into your store."
"I said three sentences. You just don't count the one where I asked you to leave."
Ben almost smiled. Almost. Then he let it go, and reached into his jacket and brought out a folded paper—a route sheet, torn out of a logbook, the kind of thing a ferry captain carried in his coat because he never knew when the schedule would change under him.
"You're going north," he said.
Nathan looked at him.
"Daniel's letters," Ben said. "I don't know what's in them. I don't want to know. But he asked me to give you the box and he asked me to give it to you in the fall, and he didn't grow up in Maine and there's only one reason a man maps out a fall." He held the paper out. "The first one's Rockland. It's not far from where I run. The *Greta* goes up past there twice a week even in dry dock, I've got a man running the route while she's being fixed. I'll be on the water anyway. I could take you."
"I'm not going."
"Then it doesn't matter."
"I'm not going," Nathan said again, "and if I were, I wouldn't go with you."
Ben stood there with the paper in the air between them for a beat longer than he should have. Then he folded it once and put it back in his pocket.
"You were the one who said it," he said. "We don't borrow from friends."
And he walked past Nathan to the door, and the bell went, and he was gone, and the glass held a little shiver of cold where he'd passed.
Nathan drove home the long way, past the wharf and the fish house and the boatyard, where a hull sat up on blocks with the stern peeled open like something on an operating table. He didn't go in. He sat in the truck with the engine off for a long time, looking at the water.
Eight thousand dollars. Twenty-four months of it before Daniel got sick. He remembered exactly how it had gone: a Tuesday, the three of them at the kitchen table in the apartment on Third Street, Daniel talking with his hands the way he always did, saying the shop needed the roof, saying he had a line on it, saying Ben, Ben, listen, if you've got it just for a year. And Nathan had sat with his coffee going cold and said *we don't borrow from friends*, and Daniel had looked at him with that flicker—half annoyance, half the old thing they'd had, the shorthand of two people who'd already decided to grow old in the same room—and said *it's not borrowing, it's Ben.*
And then it was.
The year had come and gone, and the year after it, and somewhere in there Nathan had stopped being able to say it. Not *thank you*, not even never mind, just the whole sentence, the one that acknowledged the money had ever crossed a table between them. He'd decided, in some part of himself he didn't look at, that to say it would be to owe it back, and what he owed Ben he couldn't measure in dollars, and so it was easier to owe nothing and stand in the doorway of his own store and tell a man to leave.
The phone buzzed in the cup holder. His sister, probably, wanting to know if he'd eaten. He didn't pick it up. He sat and watched a gull take something off the top of a piling and fight the wind for it, and lose it, and dive again, and the whole time the two of them sat in his head: the box with the twelve letters in it, and the man he'd just told to his face he would not go with.
*The *Greta* goes up past there.*
He started the truck and turned toward home, and it was only halfway down the point road that he understood what had actually just happened—that Ben had come to Haskell's on purpose, had known he'd be there, had carried a route sheet folded in his pocket for a week. That when Ben said *I'll take you,* he hadn't been guessing about Rockland at all.
Which meant Ben already knew what was in the first letter. Which meant Daniel had told him. Which meant that two years ago, in a room Nathan had never seen, the two of them had sat down over that box and talked about him like a man who needed to be walked to the water.
The truck turned into the drive. The lights of the apartment were off.
Nathan sat a minute with his hand on the keys, and then he did something he hadn't done in two years. He pulled the box down off the shelf by the stairs, set it on the kitchen table, and opened the lid again.