Letters from the Coast

Chapter 50: The Letter to Daniel

The man waiting at the bookstore was named Arthur Petty, and he was seventy-one years old, and he had known Daniel in 1998.

Nathan learned this over the course of forty minutes while Claire hovered and made tea nobody drank. Arthur had been a deckhand on the ferry in those years, back when Daniel ran the summer route out to the islands. He talked about Daniel the way people talked about weather they'd lived through — offhand, enormous. How Daniel once stayed up all night with a passenger's lost dog. How he kept a flask of coffee in the wheelhouse in January and drank it cold without complaining. How he'd borrowed Arthur's truck for a week and returned it with a new radiator and a note that said *no charge, I owed you for the coffee*.

Nathan listened. He had spent two years listening to strangers tell him about Daniel and he had learned to do it without flinching, which was its own kind of scar tissue.

"Do you know why he stopped?" Arthur asked, at the end, standing up with his hat in his hands.

"I thought I did."

"I don't either," Arthur said. "He just quit one spring and never came back. I always figured it was a woman."

Nathan smiled at that, and it didn't hurt, which was new.

After Arthur left — after Claire asked twice if he was okay and he said yes both times and meant it the second time — Nathan went up to the apartment and found the box of blank paper he used for bookmarks and took one sheet, and sat down at the kitchen table with a pen.

He didn't know why he sat down. He only knew the table was where he paid bills and drank coffee and where, for twenty-two years, Daniel had eaten breakfast across from him with his hair wet from the shower, and that this was the first time in a month he'd sat here without wanting to leave the room.

*Daniel,* he wrote.

Then he stopped for a long time.

He had written Daniel eleven other letters. Letters one through eleven were in the tin under the register, one per season, and they were all the same letter underneath: *I'm still here and you're not and I don't know what to do with that.* He had never intended to stop at twelve. He had expected to write them until he died.

But he wasn't the same man who'd written the eleventh. He picked up the pen again.

*Daniel. I met a man today who remembers your cold coffee and my heart didn't break. That's the news. That's the whole headline. Your cold coffee and I survived it.*

*Here's what I need to say, and I'm going to say all of it because you can't leave the room.*

*I loved you. I loved you for twenty-two years and I'd have loved you for twenty-two more and I'd have followed you anywhere, including into the ground, which I nearly did. You were my whole life and you knew it and I think you were glad of it, mostly. I think you liked being the sun. I think you stood in the doorway of my store and looked at me the way you looked at the water and I let you, because it was warm, because you were Daniel, because I never once wanted to be anyone else's.*

*And I'm angry.*

*I'm so angry, Daniel. You knew before me. You had it in your chest for weeks and you didn't say a word, you just started writing letters and painting boats and getting your affairs in order like I was a piece of paperwork. You let me find out the way a stranger finds out. You got to be brave and mysterious and I got to stand in a hospital corridor holding a coat.*

*You left me the ferry and the letters and the painting with a sentence on the back of it and you never once asked what I wanted. You made all of it a treasure hunt. You made dying a mystery, something for me to solve, and I have spent two years solving it because you asked me to, because you couldn't stand to just say it to my face, and that — that is the part I have to stop forgiving.*

Nathan's hand had cramped. He set the pen down and read it back and the kitchen was very quiet and he found that he was not crying, which surprised him.

He wrote one more line.

*I forgive you anyway. Not because you earned it. Because I'm done carrying it and it's heavy and it's not mine.*

He folded the letter and put on his coat.

—

The cemetery was on the hill above the harbor, and it took him eleven minutes to walk there, which he had never once counted before. He counted now. It felt important, somehow, to know how far it was.

Daniel's stone was the low grey one under the maple, the one Nathan had picked because Daniel hated anything that looked new. NATHANIEL BURKE, 1972–2021. DANIEL, WHO LIKED THE WATER.

He stood there for a while with his hands in his pockets.

Then he took out the letter and read it aloud.

He read the cold coffee part and laughed a little. He read *you were my whole life and you knew it* and had to stop and start again. He read *I'm so angry, Daniel* and his voice went loud enough that a woman walking her dog at the bottom of the hill turned her head, and he didn't care, he read it anyway, he read the whole last line with his jaw tight — *it's heavy and it's not mine* — and then he folded the paper back up and stood there with the wind coming up off the water and the maple ticking above him.

And nothing happened.

That was the thing. He had half expected something — a flock of birds, a break in the clouds, the sensation of a hand on his shoulder. Daniel would have engineered it if he could have. He had always been a man who liked an occasion.

Instead the wind moved, and the church bell down in town rang three, and Nathan stood in his own body on the hill above the harbor and felt — light. Not happy. Not finished. Light. As if someone had taken a foot off the scale.

He said, out loud, to the stone: "Okay."

Then he took the letter back to the truck and put it in the glove box, next to the painting, which was still wrapped in its blanket, still unexamined.

—

He called Ben from the parking lot.

"I read it to him."

A pause. "The letter you just wrote?"

"I read it out loud. To the stone. I yelled a little bit." He leaned against the truck and looked out at the water. "I told him I was angry and then I told him I forgave him anyway."

"How do you feel?"

"Light." He turned the word over. "I feel like I could go a week without thinking about him. Which sounds like an awful thing to say and I mean it as the best thing I've ever said."

"It's not awful," Ben said. "It means he's a person again. Dead people get to be gods. It's miserable for everyone."

Nathan laughed — a real one, short and surprised. "You say things like that and I keep forgetting you've done this before."

"I've done it badly before. That's why I know what good looks like." A beat. "Nathan. What are you telling me?"

He looked at the truck, at the glove box, at the shape of the painting under the blanket. There was still the manila envelope on his desk with a key in it and a question nobody had answered. There was still the twelfth letter, unread. There was still Ben's sealed envelope from the stern locker, sitting in a drawer, waiting for a courage Nathan hadn't had yet.

He could have said *we'll do it Saturday.* He could have said *not yet.*

"I'm telling you I'm ready," he said. "Not for Saturday. For all of it. The envelope. The letter. Whatever Daniel put in that keyhole. I want to open it — I want to open all of it — and I want to do it with you in the room."

Ben was quiet for long enough that Nathan checked the phone to see the call hadn't dropped.

"Say that again," Ben said, and his voice was rough. "Say the last part again."

"With you in the room."

"Okay," Ben said. "Then get in the truck. I'm at the marina. And bring the envelope. Because I have to tell you something first, and I need you to hear it standing next to me instead of over a phone."

Nathan's hand went cold on the door of the truck. "What is it?"

"I opened mine," Ben said. "Daniel's letter. The one he left for *me*. About a year ago." A breath. "You're going to want to sit down for it, and I'm not going to let you, so drive slow."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 50: The Letter to Daniel · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads