The hospital in Rockland kept Ben overnight for observation, and Nathan stayed in a plastic chair by the bed until a nurse made him leave at two in the morning. He drove back to the cottage in Ben's truck, because his own was still at the marina where he'd left it when he borrowed the boat. The rain had stopped. The roads were littered with branches and the occasional shingle, whole roof sections lying in ditches like the coast had shed its skin.
He didn't sleep. He sat on the cottage porch in the dark and listened to the ocean, which sounded wrong now—too loud, too close, like it had followed him home.
In the morning he drove back to the hospital. Ben was sitting up, eating Jell-O, a bandage on his forearm where the ferry's railing had cut him when the wave hit.
"You look like hell," Ben said.
"Thanks."
"There's a mirror in the bathroom if you want to confirm."
Nathan sat down in the chair, which was still warm from whoever had been sitting there—a nurse, maybe, or one of the ferry crew who'd come by. He didn't ask. He looked at Ben's hands, which were scraped raw across the knuckles, and at the IV line taped to the back of one of them, and felt something in his chest pull tight.
"I need to tell you something," Nathan said.
Ben set down the Jell-O. "Okay."
"When the storm hit. When I didn't know where you were." Nathan stopped. Started again. "I borrowed a boat. I shouldn't have. The harbormaster said it was suicide. I didn't care. I got out there and I couldn't see anything and the swell came up and I went under. The boat flipped. I was in the water for—I don't know. A minute. Two. Long enough to think."
"Think what?"
"That I was going to die out there and nobody would know for days. That the last thing I'd ever done was lie to you about a text message."
Ben's face changed. "What text message?"
"Claire's. The Historical Society wants Daniel's papers. All of them. The letters, the folders, everything. They want a permanent collection and they want a decision by Monday."
Ben was quiet for a moment. "Why didn't you tell me?"
"I don't know. I panicked. I thought if you knew, you'd tell me I should donate them, and I wasn't ready to hear that. I'm still not ready. But I almost died, Ben. I almost died and the last thing I did was lie to you about something stupid."
Ben reached over and took his hand. His grip was weaker than usual, because of the IV, but it was there. "You didn't almost die. The Coast Guard said the water was fifty-two degrees. You had forty minutes before hypothermia set in. You were out there for twenty."
"That's not the point."
"I know it's not the point." Ben's thumb moved across Nathan's knuckles. "I'm just saying, you're not dead. You're here. I'm here. That's the thing we get to keep."
Nathan looked at their hands. He'd spent two years keeping things. Daniel's letters. Daniel's paintings. Daniel's silence about Ellis, which he now understood was shame. He'd kept all of it like a man holding water in his cupped hands, terrified of losing a single drop.
"I want to sell the bookstore," Nathan said.
Ben blinked. "What?"
"The bookstore. I want to sell it. I'll move onto the ferry. There's room. You've got the cabin below deck, the one with the—"
"Nathan."
"—the little window that looks out at the water. I could live there. I could be with you. I wouldn't have to worry about the store, the rent, the—"
"Nathan." Ben let go of his hand. "Stop."
Nathan stopped.
"Look at me." Ben waited until he did. "You love that bookstore. You've loved it since you were twenty-three. It's the only thing in your life you've never had to apologize for."
"It's just a store."
"It's not just a store. It's where you hid when Daniel got sick. It's where you went when he died. It's where you read his poem in front of forty people last week and finally felt something other than grief. You think I don't see that? I was there. I watched your face."
Nathan didn't say anything.
"And you want to sell it and move onto a ferry that's currently got a hole in its hull and a survey due in June and a captain who's been grounded pending repairs. That's not a plan, Nathan. That's a panic attack with a suitcase."
"I'm not panicking."
"You almost drowned yesterday. You're panicking."
Nathan opened his mouth. Closed it.
"I'm not saying no," Ben said. "I'm saying not like this. Not because you got scared. If you sell that store, I want it to be because you're done with it, not because you're running from what it means."
"What does it mean?"
"It means Daniel. It means the life you had with him. It means the life you're building now, without him, which is harder and lonelier and also—I hope—starting to include me. You can't shortcut that by moving onto a boat."
Nathan sat back in the chair. The room was bright and beige and smelled like antiseptic. Somewhere down the hall a machine beeped steadily. He thought about the bookstore—the crooked floor near the poetry section, the radiator that clanked all winter, the way the light came through the front window in the late afternoon and turned the whole room gold.
He thought about Daniel, who had never set foot on the Sagacity but who would have loved the cabin below deck, the little window, the sound of water against the hull.
"I don't know how to do this," Nathan said.
"Do what?"
"Keep both. Keep the store and keep you. Keep Daniel and keep—" He gestured vaguely at Ben, at the room, at the whole enormous fact of him. "I keep thinking if I love you, I'm saying goodbye to him. And if I keep him, I can't have you. And I can't—"
"Hey." Ben's voice was low. "You don't have to choose. I'm not asking you to choose."
"Everybody's asking me to choose. Claire wants the letters. The Historical Society wants the letters. You want me to sell the store or not sell the store. Daniel's dead and I can't ask him what he wanted."
"Daniel wanted you to be happy. That's what the letter says."
Nathan looked up.
"I wasn't going to tell you until Saturday," Ben said. "But I think you need to hear it now. That's what the letter says. Not in those words exactly. But that's the shape of it. He wrote it before the hospital, before he knew how bad it was going to get. He told me if anything happened to him, I should make sure you didn't stop living. He said—" Ben paused. Cleared his throat. "He said you were the best thing that ever happened to him and he was sorry he couldn't be the same for you. And he asked me to look after you."
"Look after me."
"I know. I told him I would. I didn't know then what it would mean."
Nathan sat with that. The beeping machine down the hall. The light through the blinds, making stripes on the floor. Daniel, in a hospital room like this one, writing a letter to the man who would later fall in love with Nathan. Asking him to look after him. Trusting him with the thing he couldn't trust himself with.
"He knew," Nathan said. "About you. About how you felt."
"He guessed. He was perceptive."
"He was a bastard."
"He was. He was also kind. People can be both."
Nathan laughed, which surprised him. It came out wet and short. But it was a laugh.
"I'm not selling the store," he said.
"Good."
"I'm not moving onto the ferry."
"Also good. The cabin's too small. You'd hate it by Tuesday."
"I want to keep the letters."
Ben nodded slowly. "Then keep them. Or keep some of them. You don't have to give them all to the Historical Society. You don't have to give them any of them. You just have to decide something by Monday."
"I know."
"What are you going to decide?"
"I don't know yet." Nathan looked at their hands again. Ben had reached for him again without Nathan noticing. "But I'll tell you. Before I decide. No more secrets."
"No more secrets," Ben said.
They sat like that for a while. The nurse came in and checked Ben's vitals and told Nathan he should go home and sleep, and Nathan said he would, and then he didn't. He stayed until they discharged Ben at noon and drove him back to the cottage, where the porch was littered with seaweed and the power was still out.
They ate cold sandwiches on the porch because the stove wouldn't light. The ocean was calmer now, gray and flat and almost friendly. Nathan watched it and thought about the first time he'd seen it, twenty-two years old with Daniel beside him, both of them sure they'd only stay a summer.
"Do you want to stay here tonight?" Ben asked.
"Yeah."
"I've got a generator. It's loud but it works. The fridge'll come back on."
"I don't care."
Ben looked at him. "You okay?"
"No," Nathan said. "But I'm getting there."
Ben leaned over and kissed him, brief and dry, and Nathan let himself be kissed. It felt like something settling into place. Not a resolution—nothing so neat. Just the next thing, whatever it was, with Ben beside him.
The light was fading. The ocean kept moving. And in his pocket, Daniel's twelfth letter sat unread, waiting for whatever Saturday would bring.