Letters from the Coast

Chapter 72: The Book Club

The chairs were already circled by the time Nathan unlocked the front door. Beatrice had done that—arranged eight folding chairs in the reading nook by the window, one for each person who'd signed up, with a ninth added at the last minute because Ruth from the ferry had called to ask if there was still room.

"There's room," Nathan had said.

Ben arrived first, carrying two cups from the diner down the block. He set one in front of Nathan's chair and kept the other for himself, then looked at the circle and laughed.

"It looks like a support group."

"It is one. Kind of." Nathan slid a stack of paperbacks off the counter and stacked them on the low table at the center of the circle. Fifteen copies of the same book, spines out, the cover a photograph of an empty rowboat on gray water. *The Wild Geese of Winter.* "Claire's idea. Grief-adjacent fiction. Stories where people lose something and come out the other side."

"Adjacent."

"Her word."

The bell over the door rang. Margaret came in first, sixty-something, a retired nurse who'd been coming to the store since before Nathan bought it. Then Paul, who ran the hardware store and had lost his wife two years ago and hadn't said more than a dozen words to Nathan in all that time. Then Ruth, and a younger woman Nathan didn't recognize, and by seven o'clock the circle was full and one of the last arrivals was standing, holding a mug of tea she'd brought from home, looking around like she'd boarded the wrong boat.

"I'm sorry," she said. "Is this the—the book thing?"

"It is," Nathan said. "Pull up a chair. We're loose."

She did. Her name was Cora. She'd seen the newspaper piece. She'd lost her brother in the spring. She didn't say more than that, and nobody pushed.

Nathan waited until everyone had settled, then picked up his copy and turned it over in his hands. He'd marked it up all week—corners folded, a few lines underlined in pencil—and now he felt oddly like he was about to read his own mail out loud.

"So," he said. "I picked this one because it's not a book about dying. It's a book about the year after. The man in it—Thomas—he's a widower. His wife is gone before the first page. He spends most of the book trying to figure out what to do with the rest of his life, and he's not good at it. He makes a mess of it, actually."

"That's honest," Margaret said.

"That's why I picked it."

They went around the circle. Margaret thought Thomas was too hard on his daughter. Paul, who had barely spoken, said the part about the wife's garden rang true—that Thomas couldn't bear to touch it, and then one day he did, and that was the whole book for him, right there, the day he touched the garden. He said it flatly, looking at his hands, and nobody said anything for a moment.

Ben went next. He'd read it in three nights, he said, sitting up late in his apartment above the ferry office. He said the scene where Thomas gets angry at a stranger for being kind was the one that stayed with him—that there was a kind of grief that could only take kindness from certain people, and everybody else got the door.

Nathan's turn came and he found he didn't want to say the thing he'd written in the margin. He said it anyway.

"There's a line on page ninety-four," he said. "'He was not waiting for her to return. He was waiting for permission to stop.'" He closed the book and set it on his knee. "I underlined it twice. I sat in my kitchen at one in the morning and read it to myself out loud."

Cora, the new one, looked up. "Did you get it? The permission?"

"No," Nathan said. "Not from a book. From—" He glanced at Ben, just a flick of the eyes. "From someone who was there at the end. Who knew him."

"He knew she was gone," Ben said quietly. "And he knew you were still here. Those aren't the same sentence."

"That's the whole book," Paul said again, and this time he almost smiled.

They talked for an hour. By the end, Ruth had cried twice and apologized for it both times, and Margaret had told her not to be ridiculous, that this was the room for it. Cora stayed after the others left, helping Nathan fold the chairs, and asked if she could come back next week. She didn't say why. Nathan said yes.

When the last person was gone, Ben turned the lock and leaned against the door and looked at Nathan across the empty store.

"You were right," Ben said.

"About?"

"Adjacent. This is your thing. Books and grief and strangers in a room." He pushed off the door and walked back to the circle, stood in the middle of it where the chair with Nathan's mug still sat. "I've been watching you all night. You're more yourself in this room than you've been in months."

Nathan looked at the empty chairs, the copies scattered on the table, the water still on the cover of the rowboat.

"I used to think it was my job to run the store," he said. "Keep the lights on, sell the paperbacks, be a good neighbor. I built a whole life out of not saying the important thing."

"And now?"

"Now I say it. To strangers. In front of you. Apparently."

Ben laughed—not loud, the low kind that started somewhere in his chest—and closed the distance between them and put a hand flat on Nathan's sternum, over the sweater, over the pulse.

"I'm going north with you tomorrow," Ben said. "That's not a question. I just wanted to say it out loud, in the room, before we go."

"I know. I—" Nathan's phone buzzed on the counter. Then again. Ben's eyes flicked toward it and back.

"Go," Ben said. "It might be Vance."

It wasn't Vance. It was a number Nathan didn't recognize, and the message was short, all caps in a way that felt deliberate, like a person learned to text in a hurry.

*MR. COLE. YOU WROTE A BOOK CLUB. GOOD. HERE IS A READING ASSIGNMENT. THE LIGHTHOUSE ON YOUR LIST IS NOT THE ONE YOU THINK. THE ONE YOU THINK IS THE ONE THEY USE TO DISTRACT YOU. A.H.*

Nathan read it twice. Then a third time, slower.

"When did you first see my lighthouse," he said, without looking up.

"I don't know what you mean."

"Portland Head. That was on my list. Daniel's list. That's the one you wanted—that was the one we climbed." He turned the phone around so Ben could see it. "The letter says the address is 'the lighthouse.' I assumed Portland Head because it's the one on the list. Because it's the one we've been to. Two weeks ago."

Ben took the phone and read the message. His face did the thing it did when he was working a route in his head—the ferry schedule face, the weather face.

"There's more than one lighthouse on that coast," he said.

"There's eleven in Maine."

"And they know we've been to one." Ben handed the phone back. "They want us to keep looking at the wrong one."

"Or they want us to think we've been looking at the wrong one."

"Which is also a way of keeping you from going north tomorrow." Ben said it carefully, then stopped, and Nathan watched him change his mind in real time. "No. You know what? That's not the interesting part. The interesting part is they know about the book club. Something we decided four days ago. Something that wasn't in the newspaper until Tuesday."

Nathan looked at the empty chairs. The copy on the table, the rowboat and the gray water.

"So somebody's been in here," Nathan said. "Or someone close to one of them is."

"The newspaper piece," Ben said. "It listed the store hours. Everybody who read it knows where to find you."

"It listed Tuesdays." Nathan shook his head. "Not tonight. The club met tonight because I changed the day for the ferry schedule."

They stood in the middle of the reading nook looking at each other, and neither of them said the obvious. Someone had known. Someone had been close enough, or near enough, to know a decision Nathan had made in a text message that afternoon.

The phone buzzed again in Nathan's hand, one more line from the same number.

*STOP LOOKING AT THE AUTHOR. LOOK AT WHAT THEY WROTE ABOUT. THE BOX WAS NOT THE ONLY THING THE HOUSE GAVE UP.*

Nathan read it out loud. Ben turned toward the front window, which was dark now, the street beyond it empty under the one streetlight that always flickered.

"Book club," Ben said. "You're going to tell them, right? Claire. Meg. Vance."

"I'm going to tell everybody," Nathan said. "Tomorrow. At the ferry, at the dock. Whoever will listen." He pocketed the phone. "And I'm not going north for the lighthouse. I'm going north to find out who else was in that house."

He reached past Ben and turned off the reading lamp, leaving the circle of chairs lit only by the streetlight coming through the window—nine empty chairs, one book on the table, and a message from a stranger who knew exactly where Nathan Cole was going to be, and exactly when he'd be there.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 72: The Book Club · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads