The Maine Diner was already full at eight in the morning, and Nathan stood outside on Commercial Street with his hands in his coat pockets, watching the door like it might bite him. He hadn't slept. The motel in Rockland had thin walls and a broken ice machine, and he'd spent the night with the urn on the nightstand, upright, as if it needed to be kept that way.
Ben was already inside. Nathan saw him through the window, hunched over a coffee cup at a booth near the back, reading something on his phone. He looked older than eight years. Everyone did. Nathan pushed the door open and the bell chimed and Ben looked up.
"You came," Ben said.
"I said I would."
"That's not the same thing." Ben slid the menu across the table without being asked. "Sit."
Nathan sat. The vinyl creaked under him. A waitress appeared, poured coffee, vanished. Nathan wrapped his fingers around the mug and didn't drink.
"Daniel checked out the logbook in April," Ben said. No preamble. That was Ben. "The twenty-second. I drove him down. He'd called the museum ahead, talked to a curator named Hargreaves, told him he was researching a family connection to the old lighthouse keepers. They let him take it on a loan agreement because he had credentials from the historical society. He was supposed to return it in three weeks."
"And he didn't."
"He got sicker faster than anyone expected." Ben turned his cup a quarter turn. "Including him."
Nathan watched him. "You knew he was sick."
"I knew he was tired. I knew he was losing weight. He told me it was stress." Ben's jaw worked. "He told me a lot of things that weren't true. I'm not going to pretend I figured it out before you did."
"You were with him. In April. You drove him to Portland Head Light." Nathan set the mug down. "That's a hundred miles from Rockland. You don't just drive someone a hundred miles and not ask why."
"I asked."
"And?"
"And he said it was for the book." Ben looked at Nathan then, level. "He said he was writing something for you. That it was going to be a surprise."
The coffee was bitter in Nathan's mouth. He put the mug down. "He wasn't writing anything for me. He was writing letters, and I didn't get them until after. He never mentioned a logbook. Not once."
"No," Ben said. "He wouldn't have."
The waitress came back. Ben ordered eggs. Nathan ordered toast and didn't eat it when it arrived. The diner hummed around them, regulars talking about the ferry schedule, a man at the counter arguing about the price of lobsters. Nathan kept his hands on the table and his eyes on Ben and tried to feel the eight years instead of just the coffee.
"You run a ferry now," he said finally.
"Two. Rockland to Vinalhaven and the Portland run in summer." Ben buttered a piece of toast he'd stolen off Nathan's plate. "I bought the company six years ago when the old owner retired. It's small. I mostly move freight and the occasional tourist. It pays less than the harbor job did."
"You stopped driving the harbor run."
"I stopped driving the harbor run."
Neither of them said why. Nathan had a memory of that night like a photograph left in the sun, bleached in places, sharp at the edges—Ben at the wheel of the ferry with his jaw set, refusing to turn the boat around, refusing to call for a launch, and Daniel beside Nathan on the dock saying it's fine, it's fine, I can wait till morning. Nathan had never asked. Eight years, and he'd never asked.
"The logbook," Nathan said. "Why does it matter."
"Because he wanted it back to you." Ben wiped his fingers on a napkin. "He told me that. He said if anything happened, if he ran out of time, I should make sure the logbook got into your hands. He didn't tell me what was in it. He just said you'd understand when you read it."
Nathan stared at him. "You've had eight years."
"I didn't have anything for eight years except a phone I didn't use." Ben's voice stayed flat. "You didn't answer the door. You didn't return calls. You moved the bookstore onto the same street but you stopped walking on my side of it. I wasn't going to show up at your counter with a piece of paper and demand you read it."
"You could have mailed it."
"I could have." Ben nodded slowly. "I thought about it. Every year around April I thought about it. And every year I told myself you'd come find me when you were ready. And then Daniel died, and I heard about it from the harbormaster, and I thought, well, that's it, he's never coming. And then you texted me a picture of a lighthouse at nine o'clock at night."
Nathan didn't have anything to say to that.
Ben finished his toast. "The museum's going to give us trouble. It's a loan agreement signed by Daniel as next of kin with a deceased parent, and the next-of-kin paperwork is going to want proof that you're the rightful person to return it. I called Hargreaves yesterday. He's willing to meet us tomorrow morning, nine o'clock, and he said he'd walk us through the paperwork. Bring the death certificate. Bring a copy of the will."
"You called him."
"I called him."
Nathan took a breath. "Why are you doing this."
Ben looked at him for a long moment. "Because he asked me to. And because I owe you." He didn't say the rest. The $8,000 sat between them on the table like a third plate nobody touched. "And because he was my friend too."
That was the sentence that landed. Nathan had spent eight years arranging Daniel into a box, and the box had a lid with Ben's face pressed against it, and now Ben was sitting across from him eating his toast and telling him about April and Hargreaves and a loan agreement, and the box wouldn't close.
"Tomorrow morning," Nathan said.
"Nine. I'll pick you up at your motel."
"I have a motel in Rockland."
Ben almost smiled. "You're going to need one in Portland tonight. I know a place on Congress with parking. It's not much."
"I'll find my own place."
"Suit yourself."
They sat there a minute longer, both of them finished with their food, neither of them standing up to leave. Nathan watched a man outside pull a dog away from a trash can. The morning was gray and cold and the window was streaked with salt from the night's rain.
"There's something else," Nathan said. "The ranger in Rockland said Daniel used to come to the breakwater. Alone. With a notebook. He asked about the keepers' logbook more than once. The ranger remembered him."
Ben's face stayed neutral. "That tracks."
"Tracks how."
"Daniel spent a lot of the last year driving around the coast. He'd disappear for a day or two and come back with a full notebook and no explanation. I asked him once what he was doing. He said he was looking for something he'd lost a long time ago." Ben turned his cup over and set it down. "I assumed he meant you."
Nathan didn't answer.
"You should get going," Ben said. "The museum opens at nine tomorrow. Bring the certificate."
"I know what to bring."
"Good." Ben stood up and laid a twenty on the table. "Nathan."
"What."
"I'm not asking you to forgive me." He put his coat on. "I'm asking you to read whatever's in that book before you decide what he was."
He walked out. The bell chimed. Nathan sat alone with the coffee and his uneaten toast and the twenty dollars Ben had left for both of them, and he thought about the ferry, and the night Daniel said it's fine, and how he'd never once in eight years asked Ben why he stopped the boat.
He pulled out his phone and looked up motels on Congress Street. Then he called the number Ben had mentioned, and it turned out Ben had already reserved a room under Nathan's name, paid for with his own card, and the woman on the phone said he could check in any time after three.