Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 17: Knives

Two nights later — the twentieth — he came down at nine at night, which he had never done, and he was carrying the folder.

I was at the table with the lamp on and the Pilny statement in front of me, face down, because I had not decided yet whether to tell him about it, and I had been not deciding for two days.

He put the folder on the table and sat down on the stool on the other side and said, "You didn't open it."

"No."

"Two weeks."

"Two weeks."

"Why not."

I looked at it. Buff, printed tab, my name typed on it, 2018.

"Because you left it where I'd see it," I said, "and I don't take things people leave for me to find. If a thing is left for you to find, then somebody has decided what you should find first."

He was quiet for a moment.

"That's the correct answer," he said. "It's also the reason I left it. I wanted to know whether you'd take it."

"Did I pass."

"You passed the first test and failed the second, because you've been sitting down here for two weeks thinking about it." He pushed it an inch toward me with one finger. "Open it. I'll sit here."

I opened it.

Eleven pages, typed, on good paper, in a plastic sleeve. No letterhead, no signature block, no file number.

Page one was my license, photocopied, with the issue date and the expiration circled in pencil. The photograph was still clipped to the inside of the front cover — the steel door, the man in the raincoat, the sidewalk — and I turned past it without stopping, which cost me more than page nine did.

Pages two and three were a list of cases. Not all of them — twenty-two of them, the ones with a body and a family and a dispute, the ones where I had been the person whose hands were on the face. My name was at the top of each. The dates ran from 2014 to 2018.

Pages four and five were a list of eleven names, mine at the bottom, with columns beside them: *state, credential, mobility, availability, notes.* Beside mine, in the notes column: *no partner. no children. no press. no malpractice. excellent hands.*

I read that line four times.

Page six was money. My accounts, my debts, the eleven hundred a month, the loan on the extractor, the four thousand I had borrowed in 2016 and repaid in 2017 in cash.

Page seven was the lease on my studio, and the name of my landlord, and a note that the landlord was ninety-one.

Page eight was a lawsuit I had been named in in 2015 and dismissed from in 2016, and somebody had written in the margin, in pencil, in a small exact hand: *dismissed on the papers. She never testified.*

Page nine was my mother.

St. Michael's, East Elmhurst. Section four. Date of interment. The plot number. The fact that there was no stone. The fact that the ground was paid in cash, annually, by a woman who came in person, and the office's record of the four months in 2019 when it was not.

I put the page down and found that my hands were cold.

Page ten was one word and a number.

*Compliance: 0.*

I did not understand it. I turned the page.

Page eleven was the recommendation.

*Ellery. Recommended without reservation. Handles pressure without escalation. Reads documents fully. Does not require supervision. Will not go to the press.*

And then, on its own line, in the same type:

*She signs.*

The lamp buzzed. I had never noticed that it buzzed.

"Where did this come from," I said.

"It came to me in September of 2019, in a box with four other files, from this house." He had not moved. "I read it the way you read a thing you've asked for."

"You asked for it."

"I asked for a name. That's all I said to anyone. I said, I need a name of somebody who can do a face that nobody will look at twice." He said it without any particular weight, and then he stopped, and then he said, "That is a sentence I have had three years to think about and I still don't know how to say it in a way that doesn't sound like what it is."

I turned back to page eleven and looked at the two words at the bottom.

"Who typed this."

"Look at the last page."

I turned it over. At the foot of page eleven, in eight-point type, at the very bottom where nobody looks:

*Prepared: N.R.*

I sat with it.

N.R. A small exact hand in the margin on page eight. A small exact hand on a visitor log in a dental lab in Yonkers on the ninth of October, 2019, where it had written *Nadia Reyes* under a signature that was not hers and not his.

"She was in this before there was anything to be in," I said.

"Yes."

"Before your brother died."

"Yes."

"Before your hand."

He looked at his hand, which was on the table, and then he put it in his pocket.

"Before my hand," he said.

I should have asked him about Nadia. I know that. In the account I have written three times I have put the question here, and in the first two versions I had it, and both times it read like a woman doing her job. It wasn't. I didn't ask, and the reason I didn't ask is that I had just spent an hour reading a file about myself and had understood, somewhere around page six, that I had been chosen the way you choose a tool, and a tool does not interrogate the hand.

So instead I asked him something else. I asked him why he closed houses.

He looked at me for a moment.

"Because I'm a knife," he said.

"That's not an answer."

"It's the answer I was given." He turned his cup — he had brought a cup down and I had not noticed — a quarter turn. "I was thirty. My father had a chapel in Yonkers that was losing twelve thousand a month and had a man in it — Mr. Boyea — who had worked for this family since 1979 and had buried my grandmother. My father told me to close it. Not sell it. Close it. Shut the door and put the whole staff on the street and take the license and let the building go."

"And you didn't."

"I sold it. To a firm out of New Rochelle that wanted the license and was willing to keep the staff for two years as a condition." He said it flatly. "It was a good deal. It was the best deal that could have been made with those numbers, and I made it in nine days, and I was proud of it, and I brought it to him at dinner."

"What did he say."

"He said, *you're a knife. Knives don't get names.*" He turned the cup back. "And then he called his lawyer in the morning and had me struck out of the will, and I was thirty years old and I had a salary and a car and no name, and I understood by about noon that he had not been punishing me. He had been telling me what I was. A knife is a thing you use to cut a thing, and you don't ask it what it wants to cut, and you do not put its name on the building."

"And then you took a name anyway."

"I took the job." He looked up. "There is no Roarke who closes houses. There's a man who closes houses and his name happens to be Roarke, and every family in this county that has a bankruptcy and a funeral in the same month knows the phone number, and none of them know what to call me. So they call me the Roarke who does it."

I sat with that.

"So whose name did you take?" I said.

He reached into his breast pocket and took out a pen.

It was a fountain pen, black, worn at the edge where a thumb goes, and he set it on the table between us and did not let go of it, and it was the first time in six weeks that I had seen him hold a writing instrument, and he held it the way you hold a tool you are not going to use.

"Nobody's," he said. "I've been borrowing."

I looked at the pen. There was engraving on the nib, small, the kind you have to tilt into the light.

I did not ask. I want to be exact: I saw the letters and I did not ask, because I had spent an hour reading a file about myself, and I did not have any room left for one more thing that somebody had decided when I should find it.

He stood up.

"You'll want to know what compliance means," he said.

"I do."

"It means how many times in four years you did what you were told without understanding why." He put his left hand in his pocket. "Zero is not a compliment, in this house. Zero is a risk assessment."

He went to the stairs. He got to the third step and stopped and came back and took his watch off his wrist and set it on the table beside the pen, and then he went up without saying anything at all.

I sat and looked at it.

It was a good watch. Steel, thin, the kind that costs more than it looks and is worn by men who do not want to be asked about their watch.

It had stopped at three-forty.

I picked it up. I turned it over. There was no inscription on the back and no maker's mark that I could find in the lamplight, and the crystal was scratched, and the second hand was standing straight up at the twelve.

Three-forty, and the second hand straight up at the twelve. Somebody had stopped it. A watch that runs down loses the balance wherever it happens to be and the second hand lies where it falls; this one had been stopped dead, at a round minute, at an hour when a man would be asleep.

I thought: that's the accident. That's what time it was when they put his brother in the ground.

I put it down on the table and did not touch it again, and I did not know — I could not have known, that night, with the lamp buzzing and the folder open at page eleven — that I had just been given the only object in that house that was telling the truth, and that it was not finished telling it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 17: Knives · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads