The hearing was in a room on the fourth floor of the county courthouse, and it lasted eight minutes.
I know it was eight minutes because I wrote the time down when we went in and the time when we came out, in the margin of my log, the way I write down the temperature of a room before I start work. 9:14. 9:22.
Owen wore a suit. It was a good suit and it had been bought for a larger man, and he had shaved too close and there was a piece of toilet paper on his jaw that he did not know about, and he stood at the lectern with a folder and read from a page in a voice that was too loud for the room.
He was good. I want that in the record. He was a man who had taught himself the rules in a kitchen over three years and he made four arguments and three of them were the right ones, and he said the word *exhumation* the way a man says a word he has practiced in a mirror.
The estate's lawyer did not stand up for the first two.
She was in her fifties, in gray, with a folder of her own, and she let him finish, and then she stood and said, "Your Honor, the remains were cremated on the eighth of November, 2019. There is nothing to examine."
The judge looked at the ceiling.
He was old and he had a cold and he had clearly read the papers, which is more than most of them do, and he said, "Mr. Kessler, I've read your submission and I've read the respondent's opposition, and I want to tell you that I understand what you're asking and why you're asking it."
"Then grant it," Owen said.
"I can't." The judge took his glasses off. "The relief you're asking for is the examination of remains. There are no remains. The certificate of cremation is in the record and it is not disputed. Whatever it is you're looking for, sir, it's not in a grave, because there is no grave. There is an urn."
"There's a box," Owen said. "There's a box in my mother's closet."
"Then that is a different motion," the judge said, "and I would encourage you to make it, and I would encourage you to make it with a lawyer."
"I don't have a lawyer."
"I know," the judge said. "It's in the papers."
He denied it from the bench. No written findings. He said the word *denied* and he said *without prejudice* and he said *next case* and it was over.
I went to the clerk's window afterward and asked for the order.
"There's no order," the woman said. "He denied it from the bench."
"Then what do I have."
"You have the minute entry. It'll be in the file in a week."
"A week."
"A week." She looked at me over her glasses. "You want my advice, honey, get a lawyer."
In the corridor, the estate's lawyer walked past us at a good speed and I stepped into her path, which is a thing I had never done to anyone in my life.
"Your opposition papers," I said.
She looked at me. She had a good face, tired, the kind that has stopped enjoying being clever.
"They're public," she said. "You can order them from the clerk for a dollar a page."
"I'd rather have them from you."
"Why."
"Because yours will be the ones you filed, and the clerk's will be the ones that got photocopied twice." I did not move. "And because you attached an exhibit list."
She looked at me for a moment longer than was comfortable for either of us.
"Page twelve," she said. "And Ms. Ellery — it won't help you. The permit's not in dispute. The permit is the one thing in this whole business that nobody has ever tried to argue about."
She went down the stairs.
We sat on the top step outside because Owen would not come into a coffee shop in a suit.
The exhibit list was on page twelve, as she had said, and there were nine exhibits, and the fourth one was *Certified Copy of Cremation Permit (2019)*, and the exhibits themselves were not attached, because exhibits never are; you get the list and you order the papers and you pay a dollar a page and you wait.
"The permit is in the record," I said. "They put it in themselves. Voluntarily. In November."
"Because it's clean," Owen said.
"Because it's clean," I said, "and because a lawyer who attaches a clean document attaches it early, so that when somebody later asks about it, the answer is *it's been in the record since November.*"
He put his head back against the stone.
"Nine days," he said.
"I know."
"Then I file and your name goes in it."
"I know."
He was quiet for a while. Traffic went past at the bottom of the steps, and a man came out with a hand truck, and somewhere behind us a woman was arguing with a clerk about a parking ticket, and it was the Friday before Christmas and everybody in that building was having the worst week of somebody's life.
"I want to tell you something," Owen said, "and then I'm going to go home and not answer the phone for two days, so don't call me."
"All right."
"In 2019 they gave me a box." He was looking straight ahead. "The funeral home gave me a box with my sister's — with what they said was my sister in it, and it was sealed, and I signed for it, and I put it in the trunk of my car, and I drove it to my mother's apartment in Astoria, and I put it in her closet on the top shelf behind the Christmas things."
"Mr. Kessler—"
"I have not opened it." He said it evenly. "Three years. It's still on the shelf behind the Christmas things. My mother asks me about it every year in November and I say I'm going to take care of it and I don't."
"Why not."
"Because if I open it and there's nothing in it," he said, "then I have to do the next thing. And I don't know what the next thing is. And as long as it's sealed, I get to be a man with a box on a shelf, which is a thing a man can be." He stood up and brushed the back of his trousers. "So I'm telling you because you're the only other person in this who has to live with knowing a thing they can't use."
He went down the steps.
I stood on the courthouse steps for a while after he left.
It was cold and the light was going and I had a bag with a dollar-a-page exhibit list in it and a log with a time in the margin and a phone full of photographs of the inside of a safe.
I took my phone out and called him.
He answered on the first ring. Not the second, not the fourth. I had called that number maybe six times in six weeks and it had always taken him three or four rings to get to it, because a man with one good hand does not answer a phone quickly, and I had thought about that every time.
The first ring.
"Ms. Ellery."
"They denied it," I said.
"I know."
"It was eight minutes. The judge said there's nothing to examine because there's no body, there's an urn, and then he said next case."
"I know," he said. "I was there."
I did not say anything.
I had sat in that room for eight minutes and looked at the back of the head of every person in it, and there had been thirteen people, and I had counted them, and I had not seen him.
"Where," I said.
"Back row. By the door. I came in after you and I left before the judge finished." A pause. "You were looking at the judge. You should have been looking at the door."
"Why were you there."
"Because I wanted to see what you'd do when it was taken away from you," he said. "That's the honest answer and I'm not going to dress it up."
I stood on the steps with the phone against my ear and the cold coming up through my shoes.
"Where are you now," he said.
"On the steps."
"Stay there," he said, and hung up.
I stood there for eleven minutes.
I want to write down what I was thinking in those eleven minutes and the truth is that I was not thinking. I was standing in the cold with a bag of papers, waiting, and it took me about nine of the eleven minutes to understand that I was waiting, and about one more to understand that I had never in my life waited for a man to arrive somewhere, not once, not for twenty minutes, not for five.
Then a black car came around the corner and stopped at the foot of the steps and the back door opened.