The reporter arrived at ten past nine in a rental Twingo with snow tires and a smile Julie recognized immediately—the kind that photographs well and asks for nothing until it has already taken something.
"Cécile Marchand. *Le Dauphiné*." She shook hands with a grip that lingered half a second too long. "I've been following the Annecy story. Your shareholders' meeting was a gift, frankly."
Julie led her through the lobby, past the fire where two guests were arguing about lift passes. "The meeting was closed to press."
"It was. But people talk." Cécile unbuttoned her coat and let Julie take it, her eyes already moving—counting heads, counting empty chairs, reading the brass plaque by the reception desk like it owed her money. "You have a real story here. Family lodge, foreign consultant, David against Goliath. And now the avalanche confession. I want to write that it's working."
"You want us to be working."
"I want the truth to be interesting. Usually they're the same thing."
Etienne was waiting in the small salon, the one with the good light and the bad radiator. He'd worn the grey sweater Julie had told him to wear—she hadn't told him, but she'd thought it hard enough that he'd done it anyway. He stood when they entered, and Cécile's notebook came out before his hand.
"Cécile Marchand."
"I know who you are."
"Then you know I'm going to ask about your grandmother."
Julie stepped in before Etienne's jaw could set hard enough to read. "Sit. Coffee? The kitchen sent up something with cardamom. Don't ask."
They sat. The recorder went on the table, a small black rectangle no bigger than a door key.
Cécile started easy—occupancy numbers, the night skiing event, the audit Julie had announced. Julie gave her the clean version: thirty-two covers, the bar covering the lights, a profit that wasn't a fortune but wasn't a fiction. Etienne talked about the service deck, about the staff who'd stayed through the worst of it. It was good. It would read well.
Then Cécile turned a page and didn't look up.
"And the engagement."
Etienne's coffee cup stopped halfway to his mouth and kept going, smooth as if he'd planned it.
"What about it?"
"How long have you been together."
"Two months," Julie said. "Give or take."
"Give or take."
"We met in the fall. It moved quickly. That happens."
"It does." Cécile finally looked up. "It also happens in resort towns when a landlord wants a different story than a consultant wants a different story, and both of them need the same story. But that's not very romantic, so papers don't print it."
The radiator ticked. Julie felt Etienne's stillness next to her, the specific weight of a man deciding not to stand up.
"I'm not sure what you're implying."
"I'm not implying anything. I'm asking a question." Cécile's pen didn't move. "Two weeks before you were engaged, Odile Bertrand signed a power of attorney transferring her shares to her grandson. Five days after, you announced the engagement at the Christmas market. That's a very tidy sequence for a couple who met in the fall."
Julie laughed—a real one, short and cold. "You've been reading the Annecy minutes."
"I've been reading a lot of things. Including the insurance file on the 2007 avalanche, which is public, which is badly indexed, and which has four separate policy numbers for one event." She let that sit. "You announced an audit. Of the platform fees. Was the audit also going to cover the insurance?"
Etienne said, "That's not what the audit is for."
"I know what it's for. I'm asking what it's shielded."
Julie put her hand on Etienne's knee under the table. He didn't flinch, which meant he'd wanted it there, which was another problem for another morning.
"The insurance matter," Julie said, "is closed with the family and open with the authorities. You'll forgive me for not rehearsing it for print."
"Of course. I'd never ask you to." Cécile smiled, and it was the same smile from the doorway. "One more. Your contract with the lodge. Section four is a no-fraternization clause. I have the terms—they're in the shareholder packet, they were distributed to forty-one people, and at least one of them dislikes you." She capped her pen. "How do you work around it? Or is that the whole reason for the announcement?"
The fire spat. Somewhere down the corridor a soup tureen dropped, and someone swore in dialect Julie couldn't place.
"Ms. Marchand," Etienne said, very evenly. "If you print that we are lying about our engagement, you will be printing a claim you cannot prove, about two people you have never met, in order to sell papers to a town that has already decided what it thinks of us either way. That's your right. But you should know it's also Vasseur's argument. His people will read it and say: see, the management is unstable, the family is a fiction, sell now before the season ends."
"I don't work for Alain Vasseur."
"Nobody does. He just keeps finding people who happen to benefit him."
Cécile looked at Etienne for a long moment, and something in her face softened by a degree, or maybe sharpened. Julie couldn't tell which.
"I'll write it straight," Cécile said. "I'll say the engagement is disputed and that you declined to discuss the insurance. I'll quote your audit announcement in full, because it's good, and I'll note that the shareholders' vote is in one month and that the lodge is currently profitable, which is more than anyone expected. That's fair. But I'm not the only person at the paper, and I'm not the only paper." She slipped the recorder into her bag. "The story may not stay as dull as I write it."
Julie walked her to the door. Snow had started again, fine and driven, and the Twingo looked small against the mountain.
"One thing," Cécile said, pulling on her gloves. "Off the record."
"Nothing's off the record with you."
"Fair enough." She opened the car door, then paused. "Thibault Bertrand. He confessed. He's still here. He's stayed past the one night he announced. Why?"
Julie said nothing.
Cécile nodded as if she'd answered. "That's what I thought," she said, and got in the car.
Etienne was in the office when Julie came back, standing at the window with his arms crossed, watching the Taillights of the Twingo cut down the access road.
"She's going to run it," he said.
"She's going to run the straight version. The version that doesn't call us liars in print."
"The straight version says the engagement is disputed. That's the same sentence with better manners." He turned. "Forty-one people have the shareholder packet. Any one of them can hand a reporter the contract. And the phrasing—'disputed'—if Vasseur's proxies read it before the vote, they'll call you Thursday and ask which of us is the liar."
"They were always going to."
"Not with a newspaper agreeing." He moved a stack of folios from one side of the desk to the other, which was what Etienne did with his hands when he wanted to do something else with them. "I counted. There are six proxies not in Vasseur's pocket. Two of them have already asked me, in writing, whether the engagement is real, because it affects whether the operational plan is a family plan or a contract gig."
"And what did you tell them?"
"I told them it was real." He looked at her. "I lied to my own shareholders, Julie. That's the problem. Every time this story gets told, someone has to keep lying, and the lies are starting to cost more than the votes they're buying."
The office smelled of cold coffee and toner. Outside, a piste-basher ground past, its lights yellow through the snow.
"Then we stop lying," Julie said. "To ourselves, at least. You and I need to decide what this actually is before Thursday, not what we're telling reporters or proxies or your brother."
Etienne was quiet. Then: "I know what it is. I've known since the lift." He said it without drama, which made it worse. "That's not the conversation we're having. The conversation is whether it survives the vote."
Julie turned to the door. "Then let's get through the vote. Everything after that is after that."
"Julie." She stopped. "If the story turns ugly—and it will, she as much as said so—you should know that the thing they'll print first isn't the insurance. It's you. The outside consultant who came in to save a family business and somehow ended up wearing its ring."
"I've been printed worse."
"Maybe. But not by someone who was right."
She left him there and went down to the lobby, where the fire had burned low and the arguing guests had gone to dinner, and she stood a long moment at the reception desk, looking at the arrivals list for Thursday, which now had four names on it that all traced, one way or another, back to Alain Vasseur.
She took out her phone and texted Etienne: *The story will turn. Plan for the ugly version. We have three days.*
His reply came in under a minute. *I never plan for anything else.*