Snowbound Vows

Chapter 59: Spring Thaw

The meltwater started in March, and by April the mountain sounded like it was breathing again. All day and all night, water ran under the snowpack and down the gullies behind the Cendrier, and the icicles on the north face of the roof let go one by one, cracking on the terrace stones like small gunshots. Étienne had learned to stop flinching at them.

He was in the lobby at seven, as always, unhooking the shutters and letting the morning in. The light had changed. It came in low and yellow now, with pollen in it, and it showed him things winter had hidden — a water stain above the fireplace, a hairline crack in the third windowpane, the scuff marks on the parquet where forty years of skiers had dragged their boots. He wrote them all on his list.

The list was Thibault's idea. Thibault had a great many ideas.

"You can't keep it all in your head anymore," Thibault had said in January, when Étienne had forgotten to order the firewood and they'd burned the old ski-rental pallets for two days. "You're not the owner. You're the general manager of a company that happens to be all of us. The distinction matters."

"It's a hotel," Étienne had said.

"It's a cooperative," Thibault had said. "Act like it."

So now Étienne kept a list, and on Thibault's orders he brought it to the Tuesday meeting in the staff dining room, which was no longer the staff dining room but the board room, on Tuesdays. The lemon cake tin still sat on the shelf behind the coffee machine, though nobody had baked since Perrin left for Chamonix in February to run a bistro with too many tables and not enough staff. Étienne had asked him to come back. Perrin had said he'd think about it in the autumn.

That was the thing about spring. Everyone said they'd think about it in the autumn.

The Tuesday meeting ran ninety minutes. Marguerite from housekeeping wanted the boilers looked at before the summer shutdown. The booking figures were up eleven percent on last spring but still twenty percent under the year before the fire. The new website had been live three weeks and had 340 visitors, which Thibault said was excellent for a site nobody had yet linked to. Étienne read the list aloud. Everyone argued. Carole took the minutes and made him sign them at the end, which he found absurd and did anyway.

When it was over, he took his coffee out to the terrace and stood at the rail. The snow was gone from the lower meadows. The river at the bottom of the valley was full and brown and fast. Somewhere below, on the road that led toward Annemasse, a van was coming up — the linen service, first run of the season, three weeks early because Thibault had renegotiated the contract.

Thibault found him there twenty minutes later, two coffees in hand, wearing a fleece that had once been Étienne's.

"You're brooding," Thibault said.

"I'm inspecting the terrace."

"The terrace is fine." Thibault handed over the second cup. "The parapet is fine. The sky is fine. You've been standing here since the meeting and you haven't written anything on your list."

Étienne drank the coffee. Below them the valley was very green.

"You know what I did this morning?" Thibault said. "I opened the dossier on the spa refurbishment, and I read the consultant's specification, and I thought, this is good work. This is really good work. And then I saw the name in the header, and I thought, of course it's her, who else would write a forty-page spec on a Finnish sauna for a hotel with eleven rooms and a leaking roof." He waited. "That's the fourth time this month, Étienne."

"I know how many times."

"Do you also know that you have read her report every night since she left? Because I do. I collect the cups in the morning."

Étienne turned. "You count my cups?"

"I run this hotel," Thibault said. "Counting things is the job."

He was not wrong. Étienne had read the report every night, or almost every night, since February. Not the whole ninety-four pages; he had his routes through it now, the way you have routes through a house you know. Page 12, where she wrote, without any apparent irony, that the Cendrier's principal asset was "the loyalty of its returning guests, which is an unusually durable form of capital." Page 47, where she recommended that the general manager "should be visible at breakfast, but not too visible, and should never be seen to carry a tray." Page 88, the staffing table, with names in it. Thibault's name. Marguerite's name. His own name, in a box, with a footnote that said Director / owner-operator / not a consultant.

He had found the pearl ring the night she left, which was three months ago now, sitting on his desk under the desk lamp like something placed, not dropped. He had not asked Odile about it. He had put it in the drawer with the deed and the fire insurance file and the letters from the bank and he had not touched it since.

"Say something," Thibault said.

"The boilers need servicing."

"Étienne."

"If I say something," Étienne said, "what exactly do you propose I say? She has a contract in Paris. She has a life in Paris. She told me precisely why she left, and it was a good reason, and I am not going to call her up and explain to her that I've been rereading her footnotes like a boy with a schoolgirl's photograph in his wallet."

Thibault considered this. "You could have said the part about the wallet out loud in court," he said. "That would have been more sympathetic than the burying-the-file part."

"That's not funny."

"No," Thibault said. "It isn't."

They stood a while. The linen van came up the drive and stopped and the driver got out and complained, as the drivers always complained, about the final kilometer and the state of the road.

The sentencing was in April. Étienne had to give a statement, and he gave one that was twelve lines long, in which he repeated that he had concealed the 2019 insurance assessment at his own initiative, that no employee of the Cendrier had known, and that he accepted whatever the court determined. The judge gave him a suspended sentence and a fine and was, Étienne thought, not unsympathetic. Alain got eighteen months, most of it suspended, restitution of four hundred and twenty thousand euros over six years, and a ban from serving as a company director for five. The newspaper in Annecy ran the story for two days and then stopped.

On the way out of the courthouse, Alain had caught his arm in the corridor and said, fast and quiet, "You sold the land. You sold our mother's land."

"Odile sold it," Étienne said.

"To pay for your staff."

"To pay for your restitution," Étienne said. "The debt was in the company's name, Alain. It was our name. You signed it."

Alain had let go of his arm and walked away down the corridor, and Étienne had stood there in the marble corridor with the echo of it and felt nothing much, which was itself a kind of information. He had spent the winter being furious. Now it was spring and the fury had run out, and what was left under it was just the shape of the family, three people, thinning.

Odile came to the Cendrier at the end of April. She came up on a Thursday, unannounced, driven by the notary's secretary, and she walked into the lobby with the same unhurried step she had walked into it for sixty years, as if the building belonged to her, which legally it no longer did.

Étienne was at the desk. He had a spreadsheet open. He closed it.

"Madame."

"Étienne." She looked around. "It's brighter."

"We took the shutters off the mezzanine."

"I see that." She walked the length of the lobby and back, touching the banister post, the stone lintel of the fireplace, the new thermostat, which she regarded with visible suspicion. "Thibault is the general manager now?"

"Thibault is the chairman," Étienne said. "I'm the manager. It's a distinction he insists on."

"Good," Odile said. "He's better at it than you."

She sat in the armchair by the window, the one that got the morning sun, and Étienne brought her tea without being asked, and she held the cup and looked at him for a long moment.

"You're thinner," she said.

"I'm busy."

"You're not sleeping."

"I'm busy at night."

She drank her tea. "I spoke to Vasseur in March," she said, and Étienne's hand stopped on the arm of the chair. "Don't look like that. He came to me. He's old and he's frightened and he's spent a year not understanding what he was actually bought for. The fire memo — it was a copy, Étienne. A photocopy of a photocopy. Somebody made it and put it in a bank packet and somebody else extracted it. He doesn't know who. He was paid to hold it."

"By whom?"

"He doesn't know. A man in Lyon. There is always a man in Lyon." She set the cup down. "It doesn't matter now. The file is closed. Beauval is dissolved. Alain is sentenced. I came up to tell you that the parcel is sold and the money is spent and the family name has been in the paper and will be again when somebody writes a book, and there is nothing more to hold."

"Then why did you come?"

Odile looked out the window at the green valley.

"Because the snow is melting," she said, "and you have been standing on this terrace every morning since February looking down that road like a dog at a gate, and I have run this family — badly, it turns out — for fifty years, and I recognize the look."

"Madame —"

"She is not staff," Odile said. "I told her that in February, and I meant it, and she took it as an insult, which tells you how little she understands about this house. There is no position here for her that would satisfy me, Étienne, because she is not a position. She is a person who did a very great deal for us and asked for nothing and was handed a courtroom instead of a ring."

Étienne sat very still. The room was full of yellow light and the sound of water running down off the mountain.

"You put the ring in a drawer," Odile said.

"I —"

"The day she left, the third drawer of the desk, beneath the insurance file. You've opened that drawer four hundred times and never once taken it out." She stood, slowly, and picked up her gloves. "I know everything that happens in this building, Étienne. I was here before you and I'll be here after you, and the ring is not a relic. It belonged to my mother and I gave it to her, and if she gave it back to the room rather than to me, then the room is where it should stay until someone with some courage does something about it."

At the door she stopped and turned.

"Go get her," she said. "You have a hotel and it runs itself now, because you hired the right people and you wrote the lists and you learned to ask for help, and you have no more excuses. So go. It's spring. The roads are clear."

She got into the car and was driven away down the valley, and Étienne stood in the lobby with the tea things on the table and the meltwater running and the door open behind him, letting the warm air in.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.