The Algorithm of Us

Chapter 13: The Trial Begins

The conference room on the fourth floor had been repurposed overnight—someone had wheeled out the vendor demo chairs and replaced them with a folding table long enough to seat eight, though only five of them showed. Claire counted twice. Five women, plus her and Ethan, plus the two patient advocates from the community health center in Dorchester who had agreed to observe.

"Thank you for coming," Claire said. "I know some of you traveled a long way."

The woman at the far end of the table—Lourdes, sixty-one, a retired postal worker with a stent she hadn't needed—folded her hands and said nothing. Next to her, a younger woman named Priya, thirty-four, who had been told for two years that her palpitations were anxiety, had brought a folder thick enough to be a medical record. Claire suspected it was.

Ethan stood near the window, arms crossed, wearing the same gray sweater he'd worn for three consecutive days. He hadn't spoken yet. She'd learned to read the difference between his silences—the flat one meant he was bored; this one, with his jaw set and his eyes tracking each face at the table, meant he was listening.

"Before we start," Claire said, "I want to be clear about what this study is and what it isn't. We're not testing a drug. We're testing whether the system that flagged each of you as low-risk actually made that call for the right reasons. You'll be asked questions. Some of them are intrusive. You can stop at any time."

Lourdes spoke first. "The hospital said the same thing before they sent me home."

The room went quiet.

Ethan uncrossed his arms. "That's why we're here," he said. "Not to apologize for them. To document what happened."

Claire glanced at him. It was the most he'd said in a meeting since she'd known him.

The trial structure was straightforward on paper: forty patients over eight weeks, structured interviews, chart review, and a comparison of the algorithm's risk scores against the clinicians' documented impressions. What the protocol didn't account for was the administration's response.

Dr. Hollis, the hospital's research compliance officer, called Claire at 4:15 that afternoon. His voice had the particular smoothness of a man delivering bad news he'd already decided was good news.

"Congratulations on the IRB approval. I want to make sure we set you up for success."

"Thank you."

"A few parameters. Given the sensitivity of the subject matter, we're limiting chart access to the de-identified summary layer. No raw notes, no physician annotations. And the interviews need to be scheduled through the clinical trials office, not directly."

Claire squeezed the phone. "The de-identified layer strips out the timing of the flags relative to the clinical decision. That's the entire point of the study."

"I understand. But legal has concerns about documented evidence in an active complaint."

"Whose complaint?"

A pause. "Maria Vasquez has named the research office in her filing. We're being cautious."

Claire set the phone down after he hung up and sat very still for a moment. Then she pulled up the de-identified dataset on her monitor and stared at it. You could prove correlation with what they'd given her. You couldn't prove causality. You couldn't show which nurse had flagged which patient, or what the algorithm had said the night before a discharge, or whether the "reevaluation" flag the ward clerk remembered had ever reached a human being.

She typed a message to Ethan. *Hollis just cut our data access. Summary layer only.*

His reply came back in under a minute. *The interviews are ours. They can't schedule around us if we don't ask permission.*

Claire looked at the message for a long moment. Then she typed: *I have an idea. Dinner?*

They met at a diner on Tremont because it was between the hospital and Ethan's apartment and because it had booths that faced the door. Ethan ordered coffee. Claire ordered a turkey club she had no intention of eating.

"Night shifts," she said.

"Explain."

"Housekeeping goes in at eleven. The night nursing staff comes on at seven p.m. and hands off at seven a.m. Between midnight and four, nobody's watching the floors. I can pull the chart supplements for the patients who've already consented—the ones who came in through the ED and have paper addenda, not just the digital record. Those don't live in the summary layer. They live in the physical charts."

Ethan set down his cup. "That's not a workaround. That's a felony."

"It's not a felony. The patients signed consent. Their records are part of the study. The only thing Hollis did was restrict our *access path*."

"You're rationalizing."

"I'm problem-solving." She leaned forward. "You worked nights for six years. You know those floors. You know which charge nurses will look the other way."

He was quiet for a beat. "That's a low bar."

"Are you in or not?"

Ethan picked up his coffee again, took a sip, and set it down. "I'll ask Dr. Reyes. She runs the night float on the cardiac floor. She's been saying for two years that the risk scores are wrong for women and nobody's listened."

Claire pulled out her phone to make a note—then stopped. She'd been doing that all week, catching herself. The phone sat in her hand like something that might bite.

Ethan noticed. "Still?"

"I don't know. That last text came four minutes after I left the coffee shop where I met Maria. Four minutes."

He didn't argue. He reached across the table and turned her phone face-down, so the camera was against the laminate. "Use the hospital pager," he said. "Old-school. They're not tracking those."

Claire looked at him, and something in her chest shifted—not the sharp thing she was used to feeling, but something slower. "Thank you."

"For what?"

"For taking it seriously."

"I take everything seriously," he said, and the corner of his mouth moved in a way that was almost—almost—a smile.

The first night shift was Thursday. Claire arrived at the hospital at 11:40 p.m. and found Ethan already on the third floor, standing at the nursing station with a clipboard he'd brought from home.

Dr. Reyes was a compact woman in her fifties with reading glasses pushed up into her hair. She looked at Claire, then at Ethan, then at a chart in her hand.

"I have a rule," she said. "If anyone asks, I don't know what you're doing, and you didn't talk to me."

"Understood," Claire said.

"The addenda for the October admits are in the back file room, third shelf from the top, alphabetized by last name. The night housekeeper goes on break at two." Reyes handed over a key. "It's the old key. Don't lose it. If someone asks, it's missing."

They worked until 5:30 a.m. The file room was cold and smelled faintly of paper dust. Claire photographed addenda with her personal phone—the hospital one stayed in her bag—while Ethan read aloud from the nursing notes, his voice low and even, marking the places where the documented clinical impression diverged from what the algorithm had scored.

At 4:50, Ethan set down a chart and went quiet. Claire looked up.

"Third one tonight," he said.

"Third what?"

"Where the nurse wrote *patient reports pressure in chest, requesting EKG.* The algorithm scored her low-risk at 12:04 a.m. The EKG wasn't ordered until 7:15 the next morning." He looked at the page like it had personally insulted him. "Eight hours. That's the whole window. If she'd been a man, she'd have had the EKG in fifteen minutes."

Claire wrote it down. Her hand was shaking slightly, from the cold and the hour and the thing that was building behind her ribs.

They left through the service entrance at 6:10, stepping into a gray-blue morning. Ethan walked her to her car without either of them deciding to.

"Tomorrow," he said.

"Tomorrow," she agreed.

Her phone buzzed in her pocket. She pulled it out—then froze.

The message was from an unknown number, and it contained no text at all. Just a photograph. The image was dark, shot from across the parking garage, and it showed two people walking toward her car—her, in the wool coat she'd worn Thursday, and Ethan, half a step behind, his hand just touching her elbow. The timestamp on the image was 6:10 a.m. Twenty seconds ago.

Claire held the phone up so Ethan could see. He looked at it for a long moment.

"Whoever it is," he said, "they're inside the garage."

Claire turned toward the concrete levels rising behind them, and the emptiness of the ramp, and the sound of her own breathing in the cold. "No," she said. "Whoever it is is inside the trial."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 13: The Trial Begins · The Algorithm of Us · Lumen Reads