The Algorithm of Us

Chapter 36: The Cover-Up

Claire took the stairs two at a time, badge already out, and hit the annex doors at 7:41. The guard, a wiry man named Deshawn she'd come to know across three visits in six days, barely looked up from his screen.

"Ms. Bennett. Early."

"I need the evidence room. My logs."

"Panel's got a session at eight."

"I know. That's why I'm here at seven forty-one."

He checked something on the monitor. Then he checked it again. His jaw shifted.

"I can't let you back there."

The floor seemed to tilt a degree. "Deshawn."

"There's a sign-out on your records. Seven fifty-two—"

"It's seven forty-one."

He turned the screen toward her. The timestamp read 5:40 a.m. Under *authorized by*, a name she didn't recognize: *T. Reyes.*

"Reyes signed out my originals?"

"I can't discuss—"

"I'm the submitting party. I have the right to verify integrity of my own exhibits within the review window. That's in the panel's own procedure, section twelve."

Deshawn looked past her, toward the hall. A door opened at the end of the corridor and a man in a gray suit stepped out — T. Reyes, presumably, holding a manila envelope the size of a paperback.

He saw Claire and stopped walking.

"Ms. Bennett."

"Dr. Reyes." She didn't move out of his path. "You signed out my chain-of-custody logs at five forty this morning."

"I'm panel counsel. I have discretion to review exhibits."

"At five forty in the morning, alone, without a countersignature? Walk me through the procedure."

He tucked the envelope under his arm. "The procedure is that I don't discuss ongoing review matters with interested parties."

"I'm not an interested party. I'm the custodian of record."

"You're a witness." He stepped around her. "There's a difference."

She watched him go through the lobby doors and out onto State Street, into the gray morning, the envelope tucked under his arm like a newspaper. Deshawn said nothing.

Her phone buzzed at 7:49. Unknown number. She let it go to voicemail, then listened in the stairwell.

"Ms. Bennett." The voice was mild, unhurried, and unmistakable. Mark. "I heard you were at the annex. Good — saves me the trouble of reaching you through counsel, which I gather your side is currently arranging. I want to give you something to think about before the eight o'clock session. The panel has questions about your custody records. They're going to have more questions about you. There's a matter from your time before Helix — a lawsuit, if I recall, that didn't go the way you wanted. I have the file. I have the plaintiff's statement. I have some things you said under oath that I don't think you want read aloud in a room full of reporters."

A pause. She could hear him breathing.

"I'm on leave, technically, but I still have friends. Drop the case. Withdraw the exhibits. Say you made an error in documentation. The panel will accept that — they'd rather close this than open it. You go back to your career, I go back to mine, and none of this has to be about you."

Another pause.

"You have until four thirty. I'll know either way."

The line clicked. Claire stood in the stairwell with her back against the concrete and her heart doing something she didn't like. She had told herself, for six days, that her past was hers. That the lawsuit had been dismissed. That it was a disagreement over process, not a scandal. She had not told Ethan. She had not told anyone at Helix. She had built her career on being the person who was right, and the lawsuit was the one page in the file where she had been wrong.

She called Ethan from the sidewalk.

"Meet me at the office. Ten minutes."

He got there in nine. She told him the whole thing — the 5:40 sign-out, Reyes with the envelope, the voicemail. She played it for him in her office with the door shut and the blinds down, and watched his face go very still.

"Say the sentence again," he said, when it finished.

"*There's a matter from your time before Helix.*"

"He's not bluffing. That's not how he plays." Ethan sat on the edge of her desk. "What's the matter?"

"Three years ago, at MedLine. There was a recall I flagged late. A device went out with a calibration error and a patient was harmed. I caught it, but I caught it eleven days later than I should have, because I trusted a report I shouldn't have. The family sued. It was dismissed. The truth is the dismissal was procedural, not vindication. If Mark reads it the right way, I look like someone who missed a safety signal — and then spent three years telling the world that *other* people miss safety signals."

"He'd weaponize it."

"He'd frame it as hypocrisy. Same story, smaller scale. 'Claire Bennett sat on a risk once. Why should the panel believe her now?'" She rubbed her eyes. "It's not even false. That's the part."

"It's *stale*. It's a dismissed suit from a different company."

"It's a *pattern*. He only needs the pattern."

Ethan was quiet a moment. Then he pulled out his phone.

"We hire someone. Today. Not a company lawyer — ours. Someone who can run interference, review the subpoena, and handle the press if it leaks."

"I don't have—"

"You don't have time to *not* have one. Catherine Moriarty. She does white-collar defense and she's handled medical-device whistleblowers. I've worked with her."

"You've worked with her?"

"After Anna died." He said it flat, the way he said it now. "I sued the hospital, or I almost did. She talked me off it. She's careful and she's fast and she's on our side before Mark gets to her."

Claire looked at him. "You're putting your name on this."

"I'm putting my name on *you*." He met her eyes. "You didn't ask me to. I'm doing it."

She nodded, because if she spoke she would have said something she'd regret in the room with the blinds down.

Catherine Moriarty was at Claire's office by ten, in a gray suit and a low ponytail, with a legal pad she filled two pages of before she said a word.

"Sit down," she said finally. "Both of you. Here's what we do." She ticked it off. "One: I file an emergency preservation order on the thirty-four logs. Whoever has them cannot alter or destroy them. Two: I demand the panel produce a chain-of-custody log of their own — every person who touched the originals since you submitted them. Three: if Reyes is holding that envelope, we find out what's in it and whether it was a copy or an original. Four: the voicemail. You saved it?"

"It's on my phone."

"Forward it to me. Don't delete anything." She looked up. "Now the hard part. What's in your past?"

Claire told her. Catherine wrote nothing down, which Claire understood was a courtesy.

"Okay," Catherine said. "It's survivable. But you need to get ahead of it. If Mark's been digging, he'll have a reporter by Thursday. You want your version of the story out before his version."

"I don't want my version out at all."

"I know. That's the cost." She closed the pad. "Pull the dismissal order, the plaintiff's filing, your deposition transcript, anything you still have. If you've lost them, I'll subpoena them. And Claire — no more one-on-one conversations with Mark. No voicemails after this one. If he calls again, you forward it and you don't answer."

"He won't call again. He gave me a deadline."

"Then you've got until four thirty to decide something he doesn't get to decide for you." Catherine stood. "I'll have the preservation order filed within the hour. After that, we talk strategy, and I want to know everything — including anything you think makes you look bad."

She left. The office was quiet. Claire sat with her hands flat on the desk and stared at the wall of windows, at the gray morning turning to gray noon.

Ethan was still there. He hadn't moved.

"You don't have to stay," she said.

"I know."

"I mean it. This isn't your fight. He came for me."

"He came for the case. You're the case." He crossed to the window and stood behind her, not touching her, which was the right distance to keep in an office with the blinds up. "Claire. The MedLine thing. If we'd met then, what would you have told me?"

"That I made a mistake, and I reported it, and I paid for it. And that the reason I've spent every day since checking things three times is *because* of it."

"Then it's not a weapon. It's your evidence." He said it quietly. "You missed a signal once and it changed how you work. Mark's missed a hundred and changed nothing. If he wants to go there, we'll go there. In the open."

She turned to look at him. "You say that like it's simple."

"It isn't. But it's honest, and Mark isn't."

Her phone buzzed. Not Mark. Sarah Okafor, texting: *Heard about the 5:40 sign-out. I still can't get into my desk. But I know someone who saw Reyes leaving the annex this morning with an envelope. I'll get you a name.*

Claire read it twice, then looked up at Ethan.

"Mark says he has my file."

"What else does he have?" Ethan asked.

That was the question, and she didn't have an answer. But it occurred to her, standing there with her phone in her hand, that Mark hadn't said *a* file. He'd said *the* file — as if there was one, specific, known. As if someone had handed it to him. As if someone had been reading her past the same way someone had been reading the panel's motions before the panel did.

"Ethan," she said slowly. "How did Mark know about the lawsuit? It was dismissed. It was sealed."

He went very still.

"Someone told him," she said. "And I think I know who's been feeding the press."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 36: The Cover-Up · The Algorithm of Us · Lumen Reads