The Algorithm of Us

Chapter 9: The Missing Data

The shared drive had a smell. Not literally—Claire had never once caught an odor from the fluorescent-lit server farm that lived three floors below her office—but there was a stale quality to it, a veneer of order over something rotting underneath.

She found it at 9:47 p.m., long after the floor had emptied. The pilot trial folder for CardioSense's original feasibility study: forty-two subjects, eighteen months of data, the foundational evidence the FDA had cited when greenlighting the pivotal trial.

The adverse event log was gone.

Not misfiled. Not moved. The folder structure was intact—enrollment records, device logs, statistical analysis. Everything exactly where it should be. But the AE log, a document that had been referenced in eleven separate places, now resolved to nothing.

Claire clicked refresh. Then she clicked it again.

"Okay," she said out loud, to no one. "Okay."

She pulled up the revision history. The document had been there as recently as three weeks ago, accessed by someone whose username she didn't recognize: jkwan.

She'd never heard of jkwan. She'd been at Veridian Health for two years and knew every name on the pilot trial roster. She opened the personnel directory. J. Kwan had been a contract data coordinator, terminated eight months ago.

Terminated. Eight months ago. A week before the pilot trial's data had been locked and submitted to the FDA.

Claire sat back. Her hands were cold.

She pulled her private file from the encrypted folder, the one she'd named with a string of numbers that meant nothing, and added an entry: Pilot AE log deleted. Access revoked by jkwan (contract data coordinator, terminated 8 mo ago). Timestamp of last save: three weeks. Someone is covering something.

She saved it. Then she did the math again, because the math was the only thing that kept her steady. Nineteen adverse events in her count. Three from Ethan's records. Two still unreconciled. A pilot trial whose AE log had vanished.

Someone had built a wall around the data. She was starting to understand why.

Ethan was in the supply room when she found him, the one they'd converted into a two-desk operation, and he was eating cold noodles out of a plastic container like a man who'd forgotten food was supposed to matter.

"You're late," he said without looking up.

"I know."

He frowned at her tone and finally looked. She must have looked exactly as she felt, because he set down the noodles.

"What happened."

"Pilot trial. The original feasibility study. The adverse event log has been deleted from the shared drive."

He was quiet for a moment. "Deleted or moved."

"Deleted. The folder path still exists. The document doesn't. Access log points to a contractor who was terminated eight months ago, one week before the data lock."

Ethan picked up a pen from the desk and turned it over in his fingers, a nervous habit she'd noticed in the four days since they'd started working together. "You're sure."

"I refreshed it four times. I checked the versions. I called the overnight IT line and asked, hypothetically, how a document gets to look like that. The tech said it looks like a hard delete—not a recycle-bin situation. Something that takes administrative privileges."

"So someone with admin access decided that document needed to stop existing."

"Right before it was supposed to be permanent."

Ethan set the pen down. He looked at the wall for a moment, the way he did when he was deciding whether to say the thing he was actually thinking.

"You think this connects to the nineteen," he said.

"I think the pilot trial is where the algorithm was trained. I think if the training data had female presentation problems, they'd show up in the pilot AE log first. And I think someone figured that out and made sure the log wouldn't be around when the confirmatory trial data starts getting scrutinized."

"Mark."

"I didn't say that."

"You didn't have to." Ethan stood. "You told Mark two weeks ago that you wanted to add gender-specific variables. You told him the device looked biased. And now the pilot data is gone."

"Mark doesn't have admin access to the trial drive. He'd have to request it from IT, which would leave a paper trail."

"Unless he asked someone who does."

Claire sat down in the chair across from his desk. Her legs had gone a little weak, which annoyed her. She was a product manager. She was supposed to be good at exactly this—the politics, the plausible deniability, the moving of pieces.

"Who else knew you were looking at this," Ethan said. "Besides me."

"Nobody. I've been careful."

"Then whoever deleted it doesn't know you found it. That's the only advantage you have right now. You have to keep it." He rubbed his jaw. "Where do you back up your files."

"Personal drive. Encrypted. At home."

"Good. Do the same with everything from this week. And I mean everything—the binder, my notes, the Mrs. Chen file."

"I know." She was aware her voice had come out sharper than she meant. "I've been doing this."

"I know you have." He said it evenly, which somehow made it worse. "I'm just—" He stopped. "I'm trying to help. That's all."

The silence stretched. Somewhere down the hall, a cleaning cart rattled past.

"Sorry," Claire said.

"Don't be." He picked up his noodles, seemed to realize they were cold, and set them down again. "You're scared. You're allowed."

"I'm not scared. I'm—" She stopped. "I'm scared that someone above me thinks deleting a file is an easier solution than fixing the device. That's not the same as being scared."

"No. It isn't."

He looked at her for a moment longer than the conversation required. She noticed, the way you notice a stair that's slightly off-height, and looked away first.

"Backups," she said. "The pilot trial was 2009. Pre-cloud, pre-anything. Where would data from that era live."

"IT has tape archives. Legacy server room, probably third floor basement." Ethan thought. "But if the log was deleted from the shared drive, the backup might have been pulled too."

"Or it might not have been. Backups are tedious. People forget." She pulled out her phone and started typing notes. "I'll put in a request tomorrow. Routine records audit, something boring. Claim I'm reconciling historical enrollment figures for a regulatory filing."

"That's a good cover."

"It's a true cover. I do actually have to reconcile historical figures for a regulatory filing. It just happens to overlap."

Ethan almost smiled. It was a small thing, gone as soon as it appeared, but she caught it.

"You're good at this," he said.

"At lying to my employer's IT department? Thank you."

"At not letting people see you." He corrected himself. "At choosing what to show."

She didn't have a response to that. She busied herself with her phone, which was a coward's move, and she knew it, and she did it anyway.

"One more thing," Ethan said. "The contractor. Kwan. Terminated eight months ago, right before data lock."

"Right."

"A contract data coordinator doesn't usually have reason to delete anything from the corporate drive after termination. Their access should have been revoked the day they left. The fact that it wasn't means someone kept it open on purpose."

Claire looked up. "To have a name attached that isn't theirs."

"Exactly. So if anybody ever went looking, they'd find jkwan and stop there. A ghost."

She wrote it down. Contract access, retained post-termination. Deliberate. Name used as decoy.

"So we find Kwan," she said.

"We find Kwan. And we find the backup. And we don't tell anyone else until we have both."

He was right. She hated that he was right, mostly because she'd been about to say the same thing, and she wanted to have gotten there first.

"Friday," she said. "The November cohort review. We were going to do that anyway. We add this."

"Friday." Ethan reached for his noodles one more time, gave up, and tossed the container in the trash. "You should go home. You look like you haven't slept since the weekend."

"I slept Tuesday."

"That's not a number of hours."

"It's more than you've slept."

"Also not a rebuttal." He picked up his jacket and then, unexpectedly, held it out toward her. "It's cold out. You walked here."

She had walked here. She'd wanted the cold. She took the jacket because refusing would have been a statement, and she'd made enough statements for one night.

It smelled like him—coffee and something faintly antiseptic, the way doctors always did, even out of scrubs. She pulled it around her shoulders and tried not to think about that.

"Ethan."

He turned in the doorway.

"If this is real—if the pilot data was deleted on purpose—we're not just arguing with Mark anymore. We're arguing with someone who's willing to destroy evidence."

"I know." His face was unreadable. "That's why we find the backup first."

He walked out. His footsteps receded down the corridor, and Claire stood alone in the supply room with his jacket over her shoulders, looking at the folder on her screen where the pilot data used to be.

Three weeks ago, someone had decided this document needed to not exist. Three weeks ago, someone had been thinking about the FDA, and about what she might find, and about what it would take to make sure she never found it.

She pulled out her phone and took a photo of the folder path, the timestamp, the access log. Then she added one more line to her private file:

They know I'm looking.

She saved it, locked her phone, and went home.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 9: The Missing Data · The Algorithm of Us · Lumen Reads