The Dead Letter Office

Chapter 30: The Therapist's Subpoena

Danielle's office had a window that faced a brick wall, which Nora had decided was the point. You could yell in here and no one would hear.

Julian sat in the visitor's chair with his phone face-down on his knee, which he only did when he was about to say something he didn't want to watch her receive.

"The subpoena's real," Danielle said, sliding two pages across the desk. "Filed Friday, Southern District. Parchment Press v. Doe, seeking third-party records from Dr. Marion Feld, licensed clinical social worker, 41 West 12th."

Nora read it twice. The language was boring, which made it worse. *Relevant to the adverse party's state of mind and financial motive in the above-captioned matter.*

"They want to know if I told her I wanted the letters back," Julian said. "And whether I said it in February or said it in June, after Nora found the transaction log. Timing's everything. February makes me a man trying to undo a mistake. June makes me a man covering one."

"February makes you a man with a personal interest in correspondence you had no documented claim to," Danielle said. "They'll use it to argue you approached the broker for acquisition, not restitution. Same words, different ledger."

"I approached him to buy it back and destroy it."

"That's not how Cross will say it."

Julian picked up his phone, put it down again. Nora watched his jaw work and understood, with a clarity that felt almost administrative, that they were being managed. Cross hadn't filed this to win. Cross had filed it to make the two of them expensive to believe.

"He's not trying to get the records," she said.

Both of them looked at her.

"He's trying to make us spend ninety days arguing about them. Every week Feld's name is in a docket, Julian looks like a man with something to hide, and I look like the woman he was hiding it from." She pulled the subpoena toward her. "It's a discrediting motion dressed as discovery. He doesn't care what your therapist wrote. He cares that Publishers Lunch gets to write the sentence 'Parchment subpoenas therapy records of executive in letter dispute.'"

Danielle didn't argue. That was how Nora knew she was right.

"So we move to quash," Danielle said. "I'll file Thursday. Feld's counsel will fight it. We'll win most of it and it'll cost you four months and every dollar of goodwill you have left in this city."

"Can we win faster?"

"There's no fast in federal court, Nora."

"Then let's not be in federal court."

The room went quiet. Outside, a delivery truck idled on the street and someone was having a loud, happy conversation in Spanish.

"Say that again," Julian said.

"I signed with Danielle on Friday because I believed the only way to make Cross answer for this was through a court. But the tape isn't admissible. The transaction queue is Priya's problem to explain and mine to never mention. Danielle told me herself that winning makes me unemployable and Martine sits on the National Book Foundation." Nora leaned forward. "The lawsuit is the thing they're built to survive. They have lawyers. They've always had lawyers. What they don't have is a room full of people."

Danielle set her pen down. "You want to try this in the press."

"I want to try it out loud."

"Libel exposure."

"I'm not accusing anyone of anything. I'm reading letters. Public domain in the sense that they're mine, and mine in the sense that I wrote them when I was seventeen and I can prove it by handwriting and by the fact that nobody else on earth would have written them." Her voice did something on the last clause and she let it. "I read the letters Cross used. I read the misspelling. I read the passage from The Long Patience beside it and let the room hear the same sentence twice."

"That's a hell of a spectacle," Danielle said.

"That's the point. Cross can't subpoena a room."

Julian had gone very still. "It's not just your exposure, though. The minute you stand up and say those letters are yours, you're telling the entire industry what you wrote when you were seventeen. That's the thing you've spent fifteen years not doing."

"I know what I wrote. I've known the whole time. That's the part that's been killing me — not that they took it, that I let them have it because I couldn't stand to say it out loud." She looked at him. "You told your therapist in February you wanted to buy back a stranger's letters. Same disease. Different symptom."

He didn't flinch. That was one of the things she was starting to notice about him.

"Where," he said.

"Housing Works. It's a bookstore, it's nonprofit, it's got the reading room and it's on Crosby. They rent it out. I can book it under a series name so nothing traces to me until the night of."

"How long?"

"Nine days. I'll invite Cross and Martine directly. If they don't come, the empty chairs are a photograph. If they do come, they have to sit in them."

Danielle was already writing. "I want approval on every word you say about the litigation. You don't mention the tape, you don't mention the queue, you don't mention Parchment by name in any context where a lawyer could argue intent to injure. You read letters. You let the audience draw the line to the novel."

"Fine."

"And you should know that if this goes the way you want, Cross will sue you for defamation anyway, and you'll be doing the federal case with a much worse posture."

"Then I'll do it with a worse posture."

Danielle looked between them for a long moment, then tore the top sheet off her pad and handed it to Nora. "I'll draft a statement for you to have ready. Call me the instant you have a venue."

——

They walked out onto Seventh Avenue into a wind that smelled like pretzels and bus exhaust. Julian didn't say anything for a block and a half, which Nora had learned meant he was arguing with himself in an orderly fashion.

"You could do it anonymously," he said finally. "Read them as found documents. No name, no face, the mystery does half the work for you. It's what LetterLoop trained you to do."

"I could."

"And it would protect you from ninety percent of what's coming."

"It would also prove Cross right about the only thing he ever said that landed." She stopped at the corner and turned to face him. "He called me too ashamed. On the tape. He bet money on it. He bet a whole bestseller on it."

Julian put his hands in his pockets. The light changed and neither of them moved.

"If you do this with your name," he said, "you can't be a witness who wants something and a victim who hid. You'll be one person in one room and they'll come at you as one person."

"I know."

"And I'll be there. Which means the room will read it as the two of us together, and so will Cross, and so will whoever writes it up."

"I know that too."

He was quiet. A woman with a stroller cut between them and apologized and kept going. Nora watched his face do the thing it did when he was about to stop hedging.

"Then let me do it too," he said. "Not as a witness. As the man who tried to buy it back. I stand up, I say what I did in February and why, and I let them decide whether I'm a thief or an idiot. It takes the subpoena's teeth out. There's nothing left to discover about my motives if I say them into a microphone."

"Danielle will hate it."

"Danielle will love it and pretend not to."

Nora laughed, once, surprised out of her. Then the actual weight of it arrived — his name and hers, the same stage, the tape's smug assumption about what she'd never do, Martine's forty-eight hours already down to thirty-one.

"Nine days," she said.

"I'll clear my calendar."

"Julian."

"I know." He looked at her, and the wind had made his eyes water and he didn't wipe them. "If we do this, we do it with our real names."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 30: The Therapist's Subpoena · The Dead Letter Office · Lumen Reads