The Dead Letter Office

Chapter 53: The Guest List

The invitation list lived on Nora's kitchen wall, taped over the cabinet where she kept the good coffee, and by Wednesday morning it had three columns.

Column one: press. Simone Adjei, obviously, with a slot for a second Cut reporter and a photographer. Dev had argued for a broadcast pool. Nora had argued back for nobody who worked for a company Cross Media had ever acquired, settled with, or advertised against, which eliminated two of the four networks and one very apologetic podcast host from Tribeca.

Column two: institutions. She wrote *AG — Consumer Frauds Bureau* at the top and underlined it twice. Priya had found the intake email address and a deputy attorney general named Hollis Ferrer who had signed a 2021 enforcement action against a fitness app for reselling heart-rate data. Nora read the complaint at two in the morning and recognized the shape of it: clickwrap consent, buried disclosures, a class of users who never knew.

At the bottom of column two she wrote *J. Sokolov — FTC, personal capacity*, and then, because she couldn't stop herself, *+1?* Dev had told her one credible federal observer in the room changed the tone of a livestream.

"Two is better than ten," Julian said from the couch. His shirt was wrinkled in a way that suggested he'd slept there and not in the bedroom, which he had, because the bedroom was Nora's and the couch was the boundary they'd agreed on after the third night of this. "If the room looks like a hearing, he won't come."

"If the room looks like a party, nobody covers it."

"It's not a party. Marcus is putting the camera on documents." He turned a page in the legal pad he'd been filling since Monday. "He's going to ask again today whether Cross is invited."

"I know."

"You haven't sent it."

"I know."

Nora picked up her phone. She'd drafted the invitation to Cross Media's counsel twenty times, and each draft came out sounding like a subpoena, like a taunt, like a girl who wanted a boy to see her at the dance. She deleted all of them and wrote four lines: date, address, livestream URL, and one sentence. *You are welcome to attend and to respond on camera to the documents displayed.*

She sent it to *legal@crossmedia.com*, cc *sdwyer@crossmedia.com*, and stared at the screen until it went from black text to something less bearable.

"That's the stupidest thing you've ever done," Julian said, reading her face. "Or the smartest. I can't tell yet."

"He built the trap. I'm just sending the map."

Column three was the one that took her all day, because column three was people.

Priya had pulled the LetterLoop registry export from a 2018 Parchment onboarding spreadsheet — not the sale itself, not yet, but a name list, twenty-two hundred rows, with columns for *username*, *signup date*, *referral source*. The usernames were mid-2000s poetry. *moth_and_lamp. saltonsea. exlibris7.* Nora scrolled and felt like a woman walking through her own high school hallway.

"How do we find them?" she asked.

"Alumni forums," Priya said over speakerphone. "Class notes, reunion groups, that LinkedIn thing where people list every job since birth. I've got forty so far. Most are in New York, Boston, Philly. A dozen are within driving distance."

"Invite all of them."

"Nora." Priya's voice flattened. "They're not parties to anything. If they show up on a livestream holding their letters, they expose themselves to the exact same thing you're exposing yourself to. And they haven't had six weeks to decide."

"They don't have to read. They don't have to speak. They can sit in the back with a hood on."

"That's not consent, that's a costume."

Nora sat down on the kitchen floor, which was where she did her thinking now, back against the dishwasher, knees up.

"Then I'll call them," she said. "Every one. No group email. No mass invite. I call them and I tell them exactly what Thursday is and what it could cost them, and I tell them they can say no and I'll still fight for them, and then I move on to the next number."

The pause on the other end was long enough that Nora checked the connection.

"Forty calls," Priya said finally.

"Forty calls."

"You have two days."

"I'll start with the ones who kept their old usernames."

She made eleven calls before she lost her voice.

Six people said yes. Two said no and asked her to keep the no silent — *I have a job, I have kids, my husband doesn't know about those letters* — and Nora wrote their names on a sticky note marked *DO NOT DISPLAY* and taped it inside the cabinet door. One woman in Queens said she'd been getting strange spam for years, offers for *legacy social accounts*, and Nora wrote that down and circled it. One man in Philadelphia said *I always wondered where my letters went* and then said nothing for a full thirty seconds, and Nora listened to him breathe.

The last call was a woman named Bethany who had signed up in 2004 as *candleinthemirror* and now ran a bakery in Beacon.

"You're the one in the news," Bethany said. "The editor."

"I'm the one in the news."

"I read the piece. The Cut one." A pause, the clatter of metal pans. "I met my husband on that site."

Nora's throat closed.

"He died in 2019," Bethany said. "I still have everything. His letters are in a shoebox in the closet with the wedding pictures. When you said on the record that it was stolen — I sat down on the floor of my kitchen."

"Are you all right?"

"No." A long, clear breath. "I'll be there Thursday. I'll bring the shoebox. You can put it on the camera."

Julian found her at seven, still on the floor, phone dead, notebook open to a list of nineteen names.

"You didn't eat," he said.

"I talked to a widow."

He sat down across from her, back against the oven, so they were two idiots on a kitchen floor facing each other, and he didn't say anything for a while, which was one of the things she had recently come to depend on.

"You're not making a case anymore," he said finally. "You're making a funeral."

"A wake."

"A wake." He tipped his head back against the oven door. "He'll come."

"Cross."

"He'll come because he can't not. If he skips it, the story is that he's hiding. If he sends a lawyer, the story is that he's scared. If he shows up and says nothing—"

"—the story is the video of him saying nothing, which is worse than a denial."

Julian's mouth moved, not quite a smile. "You've been thinking about this all day."

"I've been thinking about it since the Strand canceled."

He reached over and took her hand. Just that. His thumb moved once across her knuckles and stopped. They hadn't touched since Monday and the kitchen tile was cold and the radiator was doing its winter knocking and she held on longer than she needed to.

"Whatever he says," Julian said, "the letters are on the feed first. His face is a reply."

Marcus called at nine, as promised, demanding the guest list. Nora read it to him.

"Press, institutions, nineteen LetterLoop users, one bakery widow, and you're inviting the defendant's parent company."

"I'm inviting Cross Media's counsel."

"You're inviting David Cross."

The phone was warm against her ear. "Is there a difference?"

Marcus laughed, briefly and not warmly. "There's a difference. Counsel is a shield. Cross is a man who likes to be in the room when things break." He paused. "You know what the subpoena said? They're not suing me. They're *preserving* me. Records preservation order. Which means they plan to sue somebody, and they want my cameras as evidence for their side."

Nora looked at the guest list on the wall.

"Then let's give them something worth preserving," she said.

The email came at 11:42 p.m.

She was brushing her teeth, phone face-up on the sink, and she saw the notification banner and stopped with the toothbrush still in her mouth.

*From: David Cross*

*Subject: Thursday*

One line, no signature.

*I'll be there. I'd like five minutes at the end.*

She stood in the doorway of the living room holding her phone out to Julian like a summons. He read it once, then again, and something went out of his face — not fear, exactly. Recognition.

"He said yes," Nora said.

"He said yes *and asked for time*." Julian handed the phone back. "Five minutes on a live feed, after the documents, after the widows, after us. That's not an appearance. That's a rebuttal slot."

"We don't have to give it to him."

"Of course we do. If we refuse, we're censors, and he's in the studio before we've said a word." Julian sat forward, elbows on his knees, and for the first time in days he looked like the man she'd met in a conference room in April — the immaculate one, the dangerous one. "Nora. He's walking into a trap he built. He knows it's a trap. He built the registry, he sold the letters, he kept the contracts. He's coming anyway."

"Why?"

Julian looked at her the way he had looked at her across the backlist desk on the third floor, in the first week, when neither of them knew a thing about the other except that they were opponents.

"Because men like that believe the trap is always for somebody else," he said. "And because in five minutes of live air, he thinks he can make you the defendant."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 53: The Guest List · The Dead Letter Office · Lumen Reads