The Dead Letter Office

Chapter 63: The Answer

The deli on Ninth had two tables and a radiator that knocked. Julian took the one facing the door, which told her something about the last two weeks.

Nora sat down across from him without taking off her coat. "You said you wanted to talk."

"I said I owed you a conversation." He turned his cup a quarter turn, then back. "I've been rehearsing it for eleven days. It's worse out loud."

"Try it anyway."

He nodded at the window. A man in a puffer jacket walked past, glanced in, kept going. Julian waited until he was gone.

"In 2015 I was twenty-two and I had one hundred and forty dollars in my checking account," he said. "And I had LetterLoop. Which, for about three years, was the only thing in my life that wasn't a disappointment to somebody."

"I know what it was."

"I need to say it in order or I'll skip the part that makes me look bad." He breathed out. "March 2015. LetterLoop sent an email to every user. System migration, new servers, re-register your account, click the link. I clicked the link. Nothing happened. I clicked it four more times over two days. Nothing happened."

Nora didn't move.

"I wrote to support. I got an autoresponder. I wrote again. On March 19th the site went dark for six days and came back with a different logo and no archives. My account didn't exist. Yours didn't exist. Every letter I'd ever sent or saved was gone, and there was no 'contact us' link anymore, and I was a temp at a trade magazine making eleven dollars an hour, so I did the thing I actually did, which was nothing."

"Julian."

"I'm not finished." His voice stayed level, which cost him. "I assumed you'd gotten the same email. I assumed you'd clicked the same dead link. I assumed the reason there was no letter from you on the tenth of April or the tenth of May or the tenth of anything was that you'd decided a twenty-two-year-old who worked at a trade magazine and lived with two roommates in Bushwick wasn't worth the trouble of finding a new way to write. And that was—I want to be clear—the generous interpretation. The other one was that you'd never been real at all."

Nora put both hands flat on the table. "I wrote you on the tenth of April."

"I know that now."

"I wrote you on the tenth of every month for a year. Fourteen letters. I have the drafts."

Julian reached down beside his chair and came up with a manila envelope, soft at the corners, thick as a sandwich. He set it between them and slid it across. Her name was on it in handwriting she recognized the way you recognize your own face in a photograph taken by someone else.

"Open it," he said.

She did.

The top page was dated April 11, 2015. Handwritten. *Nora — the site's gone, I've tried everything, if you're reading this it means I found you, which means I haven't yet, which is a stupid thing to write. I'm going to keep these. If LetterLoop ever comes back I'll send them all at once and you can laugh at me.*

The next was May 9. *Still nothing. I checked every week. I'm starting to think the internet just ate three years of my life and nobody's going to file a report.*

June 12. *I looked you up. There are forty-one Nora Ellerys. None of them are you. I don't even know if Ellery is your real name.*

That one stopped her. She looked up.

"It was," she said. "It still is. I just never told you where I lived."

"Which was the point." He turned the cup again. "Keep going."

July, August. In September the tone changed — shorter, colder, more like a man writing to prove to himself he could still write. October's was four lines. November's was a paragraph about a girl named Priya he'd taken to a movie and hadn't called again, and he'd written that down for Nora, in a letter he had no way to send.

December 2015: *Last one of the year. I'm going to stop after this. I don't think you'd want me to be the guy who keeps writing letters to an empty mailbox. If you ever find this — it wasn't nothing. It was the best thing I had.*

The rest of the envelope was 2016 through 2019. Thirty-nine letters. Some of them angry. One of them, dated the night before his mother's surgery, that Nora had to stop reading halfway because her eyes had gone hot.

She closed the envelope.

"Why didn't you send them to my publisher? I was at Harlow by then. I had a public email."

"Because in 2016 I was working for a company that would later be owned by Cross Media, and I knew what a paper trail looked like, and I was a coward, and because—" he stopped, recalibrated. "Because if I sent them and you didn't answer, I'd have to know you'd read them."

"And you'd rather not know."

"I'd rather not know. Yes."

Nora sat with that. The radiator knocked twice. Outside, somebody's phone alarm went off and got shut off.

"So the breach," she said. "Was it a breach?"

"Officially it was a migration error. Twenty-two thousand accounts lost. I spent six months in 2019 trying to get the incident report out of LetterLoop's successor company and got stonewalled until a lawyer told me the statute had run. Parchment bought the asset in 2021. They bought the wreckage and they bought the letters that were still sitting in the backup servers because nobody ever deleted them. Which means—"

"—which means the breach is how they got mine." She said it almost flatly, testing it. "Not a scrape. Not a leak. The migration error. I got locked out on March 16th and I assumed it was my fault, I assumed I'd typed the password wrong, and then the site was gone and the letters were gone and I decided it was a sign that I should stop writing to a stranger and be an adult."

"You were twenty-four."

"So were you."

They looked at each other. Neither of them said the obvious thing, which was that a server migration in 2015 had cost them nine years and the file that put four thousand seven hundred and twelve names on a docket.

"Say the rest," Nora said.

"There isn't a rest."

"There's a rest. You've been on Cross Media's payroll for three years. You confessed that on camera and promised to answer for it and you haven't. So answer."

Julian pushed the cup away. "In 2021 a recruiter offered me a director's title and a number that made my hands shake. I took it because I wanted the money and because the company had bought a data asset and I thought if I got inside I could find out what happened to LetterLoop. That was the story I told myself. The truth is I wanted the money first and the answer second, and by the time I figured out what Parchment actually did with the letters, I was the guy whose name was on the internal deck that proposed monetizing them."

Nora went still.

"Not the plagiarism," he said quickly. "Never the plagiarism. I proposed licensing the archive for a *podcast* — nostalgic, opt-in, revenue share with the writers. It died in committee. But I wrote it. I signed it. I sat in the room."

"You told the AG?"

"Tuesday. Three hours. I offered them the deck and the emails and my resignation letter, and they told me the resignation would look like an admission and asked me to hold it." He looked at her. "That's the rest."

Nora took the envelope and put it in her own bag, which was not the same as accepting it but was close, and both of them knew it. She looked at him for a long moment, at the tension in his jaw that she'd spent nine years reading in handwriting, and she made a decision she had no intention of defending to anyone.

"I believe you," she said.

Julian blinked. Whatever he'd rehearsed, it hadn't included that.

"Don't," she said, "make me regret it. There's a hearing Monday and the AG is going to ask me under oath whether I trust anyone from that company, and I'm going to say one name, and I want to be sure I'm not lying."

"You're not lying."

"Good." She stood. "Because I'm not done with the folder. Cross walked out with it and we still don't know what's in it, and if it's the migration report — if he had the incident report the whole time — then the breach isn't a defense, it's a confession, and eleven days isn't going to be enough time to find out."

Julian got up. "Then we start tonight."

Nora was already pulling out her phone. "Mira texted me an hour ago," she said, reading. "She found something in the February packet. A shipping label. It came from a Parchment warehouse in Dayton that's not on any corporate filing."

She turned the screen so he could see it.

"So we don't start with the folder," she said. "We start in Ohio."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 63: The Answer · The Dead Letter Office · Lumen Reads