The Ethical Clause

Chapter 12: The Woman At The Back

The Dorchester's ballroom had been dressed for the Orchard Foundation's winter auction with the particular restraint of old money pretending not to try: white lilies, no logos, a string quartet wedged behind a screen so the music arrived as though the building itself were humming. Emily stood at the edge of the reception with a glass of wine she had no intention of drinking and counted the exits out of habit.

"You're the lawyer."

She turned. A woman in her eighties, silver hair pinned with a tortoiseshell comb, was holding a programme she'd folded into quarters. Her name tag said *Mrs V. Okonjo, Guest*.

"I'm sorry?"

"Emily Hartwell." The woman said it the way you'd say a diagnosis you'd waited years to hear. "You're the one did the Ridgeway Care Homes case. Four years back. Camberwell."

Emily's hand tightened on the glass. "I was on that team, yes."

"You were the one." Mrs Okonjo lifted a finger, precise as a conductor. "The one who came to the home. Sat in my room. Three hours, you sat there, and I told you about the water. The tank they never cleaned. The water in the basement was brown, and they told us it was the pipes, and you wrote all of it down and you didn't once look at your phone."

"Your evidence was what won it," Emily said. "The judgment—"

"The judgment gave me eleven thousand pounds and a new place in Peckham." Mrs Okonjo's chin came up. "What you gave me is that someone wrote it down."

The room, which had been a low hubbub of champagne and bidding paddles, had gone quiet in patches, the way a room does when one voice cuts through and everyone pretends not to listen. Emily felt the shift on her skin. A woman two tables over turned, then a man, then a knot of them near the bar. Somewhere behind her left shoulder a camera shutter clicked — the foundation's house photographer, working the room, and now working her.

"Mrs Okonjo." Oliver was there, so smoothly Emily hadn't seen him arrive. He took the old woman's hand in both of his. "You're in table nine. They've put you next to a barrister who will bore you senseless about wine, so I've moved you. You're with the Ackroyds now, and they're deaf in one ear each, which is more restful."

Mrs Okonjo laughed, delighted, and let him steer her. Then she stopped and turned back.

"I read the papers," she said to Emily, still loud enough. "I know what they say about you. About why you're here tonight." She looked at Oliver, then at Emily, and something dry and knowing moved across her face. "I don't care what your reasons are. You did the work."

She was gone into the crowd with Oliver's hand at her elbow. The quartet scraped through something by Elgar.

Emily set the wine down.

Cameras. She counted three now — the house photographer, a man with a phone held too casually at chest height, and the tall young woman from the *Standard* whose name Emily could never remember and who had been hovering near the entrance since the third lot. The arrangement with Oliver was six public appearances, and every appearance logged and invoiced at market rate, and that clause was doing nothing at all to protect her from the fact that the story the room wanted was not the auction.

Oliver was back within ninety seconds. He didn't touch her, didn't stand too close — he was good at that, she'd give him that — but he angled his body so that his shoulder blocked the *Standard* woman's sightline.

"How long have you been awake at night about her?" he said, low.

"I'm not."

"The water in the basement. You remember the year."

"Nineteen ninety-eight conversion, tank not replaced since." She heard her own voice, flat and fast, the case file coming up out of her like a reflex. "I sat with her for three hours because she kept apologising for taking up my time. I billed the firm six hours for it. My supervisor told me off for padding."

"Did you?"

"No." She looked at him. "I billed three and let the rest go."

He nodded slowly, as though she'd confirmed something on the hundred-page file he'd already read. Then he straightened. The auctioneer was climbing toward the lectern, and the room's attention was beginning to drag back toward the front, but not all of it. Not the *Standard*, and not the man with the phone.

Oliver turned to her.

"Lot fourteen," he said. "When they open it, I need you to look at me."

"Why?"

"Because it's a weekend in a villa in Puglia, and it will go for forty thousand, and they'll photograph the bidder, and I've arranged for the bidder to be the woman who owns the shipping company, who has wanted her photograph in this room for eleven years and never once got it." He checked his cuff. "Two hundred quid says the *Standard* takes the shot."

"You're buying press for a shipping heiress."

"I'm buying press *off* you." He said it plainly, without warmth, as though reading out a clause. "You asked for anonymity. This is what it costs to manufacture it. Look at me when the lot opens, and they'll caption you as my guest, and by Monday you'll be a footnote in a photograph of somebody else entirely."

The auctioneer began. Lot eleven. Twelve.

Emily stood with her arms crossed and watched him watch the room, and understood with a small cold click that he had planned this before he arrived — that the seating chart had been redrawn, that the photographer had been briefed or the shipping heiress primed, that the whole evening was a machine for moving light off her and onto a woman in a green dress. She had signed a contract about appearances. She had not signed anything about being managed.

Lot fourteen.

"Forty-two thousand," the auctioneer said, and the room applauded, and the shipping heiress rose to her feet in a blaze of flashbulbs, and the *Standard* woman's lens swung left like a gun on a rail — toward the villa, toward the green dress, toward the woman with her chin up and her husband's hand in hers.

And Oliver turned to Emily, and lifted his glass to her, an inch, nothing anyone would photograph, and said, quietly, "Thank you."

"For the case?"

"For looking at me."

She looked at him. She had been looking at him anyway. That was the trouble — that she'd been looking at him for a fortnight, and not as evidence.

"Mrs Okonjo," Emily said. "You moved her because she was about to say my name again."

"I moved her because table nine had a draught."

"You moved her because you'd read her file along with mine."

He didn't deny it. He drank.

The auctioneer moved to lot fifteen, a private dinner for eight with a chef, and the room relaxed back into noise. Emily took out her phone, because that was what people did at the edge of rooms, and because she had spent the walk over here rehearsing whether she would tell him about the text messages — the unknown number, the demand to ask David Marsh first, the seven o'clock meeting that was now fifty minutes away and which she had not once mentioned to him, though the contract said *every appearance logged*, though she had promised to publish anything she found.

Her own clause. Her own unrestricted right.

She put the phone away.

"They'll still write you," she said. "The photograph runs Monday. *Public-interest lawyer attends charity auction on arm of Orchard heir.* It's the only story here."

"Then they'll have to write it about a shipping heiress." He set his glass on a passing tray. "I've been the story since birth, Emily. It's a crowded field. You'd hate it."

"And Peter? Did you ask him?"

The pause was a half-beat, no more, but she caught it.

"I'll ask him Monday," Oliver said. "He's in Edinburgh until then."

Peter had told her office assistant two days ago that he was in Edinburgh until Thursday. She had not told Oliver that she'd checked. There it sat between them, small as a comma.

Then Oliver's phone buzzed in his hand, and he glanced at it, and something in his face rearranged itself — not shock, not quite, but the particular blankness of a man filing something away for later.

"Something wrong?"

"Peter," he said. "Wants to move our call to Sunday morning. Very eager." He pocketed the phone and smiled at her with his boardroom smile, the one that had made her want to throw her coffee at him six weeks ago. "Nothing to concern you. Come — the last lot's a boat, and I'd like to watch the shipping woman lose to the man from the telecoms."

He offered his arm, formal as a coat check, and she took it, because they were in a room full of cameras and because both of them knew the clause.

Halfway across the ballroom she felt her phone pulse against her ribs. One message. The unknown number.

*Ask him about the Edinburgh trip. Ask him why he moved it. You have 48 hours.*

She didn't answer it. She walked the length of the room on Oliver Aldridge's arm with her hand steady and her blood loud, and she did not know — and this was the thing she could not get comfortable with — which of them the message was warning her about.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 12: The Woman At The Back · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads