The Ethical Clause

Chapter 20: The Regulator's Letter

The letter arrived at the foundation's Millbank office at eleven forty-two on Monday morning, and by eleven fifty Celia Aldridge had read it twice, forwarded it to the full board, and summoned everyone to a room Emily had never been allowed inside.

Emily found out because Oliver texted her a photograph of the first page.

*I think you should see this before the meeting decides how to characterise it.*

She was in Southwark, halfway through a call with a housing officer about a damp-walled flat in Peckham, and she read it standing up, one hand flat on the windowsill.

**Charity Commission — Regulatory Compliance Case Opened… concerns raised in the press regarding the intended transfer of restricted funds… the trustees are required to provide a full response within fourteen days…**

Fourteen days. The Guernsey vehicle was scheduled to be signed off in nine.

She called him back. He answered on the second ring, and she could hear a room behind him — chairs, the particular hush of a board that has been holding its temper.

'I can't talk,' he said. 'Tonight. I'll come to you.'

'Oliver —'

'They've already started.' A pause. 'Peter's reading out the piece.'

The piece. Sian Bowen's column had run that morning, and it did not say what Emily had expected it to say. It did not publish her unverified quote at all. It published the memo — not the document itself, but its contents, described with a specificity that could only have come from someone who had read it — under the headline **FOUNDATION TO SHIFT LEGACY MILLIONS OFFSHORE BEFORE WATCHDOG REVIEW**, with Emily named in the second paragraph as *'the public-interest lawyer understood to have raised the initial concerns'* and, in the fourth, as *'a contracted consultant to the Orchard Foundation's current communications strategy.'*

She had read that fourth paragraph six times. It was not untrue. It was just shaped to make everything else she did look like it.

The call came at half past four, and it was not Oliver.

'Miss Hartwell.' Celia Aldridge's voice had the flat courtesy of a woman who had decided in advance not to shout. 'You were at Holland Park on Wednesday.'

'I was.'

'You were in the cloakroom.'

Emily said nothing.

'My son tells me you photographed a document,' Celia said. 'I'm not asking you to confirm it. I'm telling you what it has cost. The Commission has opened a case file. Every grant the foundation has made for eleven years is now going to be read by a civil servant with a checklist, and the ones that don't fit the checklist will be unpicked, and there will be a solicitor's bill that would have paid for two of your tenants' blocks, and the trustees have asked me to find out precisely which of us invited you in.'

'You invited me in,' Emily said.

'I did.' A beat. 'And my son has spent an hour this afternoon arguing that you should not be blamed for behaving exactly as you told us you would behave.'

Emily looked at the window. Outside, a man was carrying a mattress up Camberwell Road in the rain.

'Is that supposed to be a defence of me or of him?'

'It's an observation,' Celia said. 'He has been very foolish, and he is now very exposed, because the Commission will want to know whose initials were missing from the authorising line on the Ridgeway payment, and he has told them he doesn't know. Which they will not believe. Nobody signs forty pages and reads one.' A pause. 'Neither should you.'

The line went dead.

She worked until eight. There was nothing else to do with it. She wrote out the fourteen-day window on the back of an envelope and then wrote out what had to happen inside it, and then she crossed most of it out, because most of it depended on things she could not make happen.

At twenty past eight her phone rang again. Oliver.

'Are you at home?'

'Office.'

'Stay there.'

He arrived in twenty minutes, wet through, no umbrella, and she saw before he said anything that something had gone out of him — not defeat exactly. Subtraction.

'They took the vote at six,' he said. He sat down on the client chair opposite her desk, the one with the split in the vinyl. 'Eight to two.'

'On what?'

'On whether my presence on the finance committee was compatible with an ongoing regulatory case in which I'm a material witness.' He said it evenly, as though reading it off a page he'd already memorised. 'I've stepped off. Effectively I'm off everything that touches the money until the Commission reports. It was that or be formally removed, and if I'd let them remove me it would be on the record, and the record is exactly what the Commission is reading.'

'Who voted for you?'

'My mother. And a woman called Bishop who doesn't like my mother.' He almost smiled. 'So: nepotism and spite. That's my coalition.'

Emily sat down on the edge of her desk.

'You defended me.'

'I pointed out that you are a contracted consultant who was invited to a private dinner, that you disclosed nothing to the press that you didn't first disclose to me, and that if the board wanted to construct a narrative in which you are responsible for a memo that was sitting in a cloakroom for anyone to find, they should be aware that the narrative has a hole in it.' He looked up. 'Peter asked me whether I was sleeping with you.'

'What did you say?'

'I said not yet and moved on.' A beat. 'That was a joke. I said it was a commercially contracted arrangement and that I'd read the contract.'

Emily put her hands on her knees to stop them doing anything.

'Eight to two,' she said. 'Who were the two?'

'Peter and my cousin Rosalind.'

'So Peter voted to keep you.'

'Peter voted against a motion my mother proposed. He always does. He'd vote to keep me if the alternative was her winning, and he'd vote to burn me if it was her losing.' Oliver rubbed his face. 'That's the family. You should stop being surprised by it.'

'I'm not surprised by it. I'm surprised by you.'

'Don't be. I'm exactly what I said I was.' He stood. 'The letter gives us fourteen days. The Guernsey signing is in nine. If it goes through, the Commission's case is about a completed transaction, and the money's where the money is, and everyone says what a pity. If it doesn't go through, the Commission reads a plan that was stopped.' He looked at her. 'You wanted a lever. That's the lever. It's not a document. It's a deadline.'

'And your name's on the payment.'

'My name's on the payment,' he agreed. 'Which is why I'm not the one who should be holding the lever. You are.'

Emily looked at the envelope on her desk with the fourteen crosses on it.

'Oliver.'

'Don't.' He picked his coat up off the chair. 'Whatever it is, don't do it tonight. Tomorrow's the hearing on the Ferris street injunction, and if you're going to be photographed walking into the Royal Courts of Justice, you should at least have slept.'

'How do you know about the Ferris hearing?'

He stopped in the doorway.

'Because I read the cause list,' he said. 'It's public. That's what I do now, apparently. I read things and then I'm off the committee for it.'

He went out. She heard him on the stairs, then the street door.

Her phone buzzed on the desk — a message, not a call.

Unknown number. She looked at it for a long moment before she opened it.

**I read the piece. You need to know Peter Marsh was reconciling the Orchard accounts in 2016 personally. Not through a junior. Ask your contact in Worcester who told her to sign.**

Emily sat very still.

Then she turned the envelope over and, under the fourteen days, wrote three words.

*Priya first. Tomorrow.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 20: The Regulator's Letter · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads