The Ethical Clause

Chapter 29: Exit Clause Invoked

Emily didn't sleep. She sat at her kitchen table with the case file open and the photograph of the 2009 form on her laptop screen, and she read Annex E eleven times. At six she showered. At seven she was on the 344 bus, and at seven-forty she was standing in the corridor outside the office with the key in the lock, and her hands were steady, which she took as a mercy.

David arrived at ten past eight with two coffees and a paper bag of pastries, because David always arrived with something. He stopped in the doorway of her office when he saw her face.

"Right," he said. "What."

"Call Sian. Conference room. Ten minutes."

"Emily—"

"Ten minutes, David."

He put the coffees down and went.

Sian came in at eight twenty-five, in from a night shift on the Pemberton file, coat still on. Priya was on speaker from a taxi, the driver's radio talking underneath her. Emily stood at the head of the table because if she sat down she wasn't sure what her voice would do.

"The arrangement is over," she said. "The personal one. I need it out of every document we file, and I need my name off anything joint."

Sian sat down slowly. "Say that again."

"Oliver Ashworth and I are not in a relationship and never were. It was a contract. It was drafted, it was signed, it had a term. It's ended early. I want no reference to him in any submission I'm a party to, and I don't want our names joined in any press line we put out."

David was looking at the table. Priya said, quietly, "Right."

"There's more," Emily said, "and I'm going to say it once so nobody has to ask me later. The 2009 form is real. His signature is on it. I photographed it in Acton and I'm keeping the photograph in the file and I am going to use it if the injunction needs it."

Sian's pen stopped. "You've had it since Thursday."

"Since Wednesday night."

"And you didn't tell me."

"I'm telling you now."

"That's not—" Sian started, and then stopped, and then said, more carefully, "Why."

"Because I needed to confront him before I used it. Because if I'd handed it over first, the first thing he'd have heard about it would have been from your office, and I needed him to hear it from me. And because I was the one who'd been photographed standing next to him in a car park, which means I get to say when my own evidence goes in."

Sian looked at her for a long moment. "You've been carrying this alone for a week."

"Yes."

"That's not the job."

"No," Emily said. "It's not."

The silence went on long enough that Priya said, from the phone, "I can hear everyone not talking."

David exhaled. "Okay. Practical. What do we put out?"

"Nothing today," Emily said. "The Mail already has the photograph and they'll have a second story by the weekend, because somebody at the foundation is feeding them. When it lands, I want a line already written, and I want it written by me, and I want you all to know what it says so none of you are caught out."

She had it in her bag, actually. She'd written it at four in the morning on the back of a Post-it and then typed it properly because the handwriting was a mess.

"Read it," Sian said.

Emily read it.

"'Emily Hartwell is not in a relationship with Oliver Ashworth. Any suggestion that her work for the Fairview residents has been influenced by a personal connection is false. Ms Hartwell has asked that her name be removed from all joint statements relating to the Ashworth Foundation. She will not be commenting further.'"

David frowned. "That reads like you got dumped."

"I know what it reads like."

"It reads like you got dumped and you're being very dignified about it," David said. "Which is—sorry—exactly the frame the Mail has already put you in. 'Found a rich boyfriend and a bigger story.' This confirms it and adds a heartbreak."

"It confirms nothing," Emily said. "It says the relationship isn't happening. Which is true."

"It says 'she has asked that her name be removed'," Sian said slowly. "That's the sentence that does the work. That's you taking yourself off his letterhead. It's a good sentence." She looked up. "It also makes you look like you lost him."

"Yes."

"Why would you do that on purpose."

Emily put the paper down. "Because when the second story lands, the foundation's going to say the lawyer had a vendetta against a man who'd wronged her personally. Jealous ex, axe to grind, case dismissed, residents back to a landlord who'll fight them for another three years. I'd rather be the woman who got left than the woman with a grudge. Getting left is boring. Nobody investigates a person who got left."

Priya said, "That's a very expensive sentence."

"It's the cheapest one in the room."

Sian was quiet, then nodded once. "Fine. But we keep the photograph's chain of custody clean. Who else has seen it?"

"Only you, me, and Oliver."

"He's seen it."

"I showed him the screen," Emily said. "He didn't touch it. Priya, the deed—"

"Deed's with my clerk," Priya said. "I've logged it. He doesn't get a copy until we serve."

"He doesn't get a copy at all unless we need it," Emily said. "Which we might."

"He is my client's residual beneficiary," Priya said. "There are duties."

"Then do your duties. I'm not asking you to sit on it. I'm asking you not to hand it to him."

A pause. Then Priya, dry: "Noted."

David's phone buzzed and he turned it face down. "Sian, are you all right with Friday's list? Because I need to file the amended schedule with the court and if we're pulling the joint bits out—"

"Pull them. File by four."

They worked for two hours. It was the most ordinary two hours of Emily's week: names, dates, exhibit numbers, the landlord's agent's second witness statement and how many days they had to answer it. David printed, Sian annotated, Priya sent three emails from a moving car and one of them had a typo. Nobody mentioned Oliver again. That was its own kind of kindness, and Emily noticed it and filed it away with everything else she was going to feel later.

At eleven Sian had to go to court. David went to buy sandwiches and came back without them. At half past eleven Emily walked out to the kitchen to refill the kettle and found Nadia there, their paralegal, twenty-three and doing a law conversion at night school, standing at the sink with her back to the door and her shoulders going.

Emily stopped.

"Sorry," Nadia said, without turning round. "Sorry. I'm fine."

Emily filled the kettle and set it down and leaned against the counter, not looking at her, giving her the side of her face. "Take your time."

"It's stupid."

"It's not."

Nadia wiped her eyes with the heel of her hand and turned round. She looked furious with herself. "It's just—I told my mum. About you and him. I told her back in—when the photo ran, I told her, oh, my boss is going out with Oliver Ashworth, and she was so pleased, she told her whole church group, she said finally, someone's getting something nice—"

Emily felt it land, low and dull, like something dropped on a foot.

"—and now I've got to ring her tonight and tell her I was wrong, and it's going to sound like I made it up." Nadia's face was wet again. "And that's not the worst bit. The worst bit is I've been in this office since March and I know how you work and I still said it. I still thought it. I didn't ask you once. I just—the way the photo looked, and everyone was saying it—"

"Nadia."

"—and you've been here since six every morning this week, and I let myself believe a boyfriend was why."

Emily was quiet for a second. Then she said, "Come here."

Nadia said, "I'm not hugging you, you're my boss."

"Sit down, then." Emily pulled out a chair and sat down opposite her, elbows on the table. "Right. Two things. First, you're not wrong that there was something. There was an arrangement. It's finished. When people ask you, say you don't know anything and it's not your business, which has the virtue of being both true and unanswerable."

Nadia sniffed. "Second?"

"Second, if I hear that you think a boyfriend is why this case moves, I'll put you on the Pemberton disclosure for a month." Emily said it flat, and something in Nadia's face changed, straightened up. "The case moves because Mrs Oduya walked up four flights with a folder of photographs and because David sat in a council reading room for two days. Not because of who I'm standing next to in a car park. Understood?"

"Understood."

"Good." Emily stood. "The kettle's boiled. Make the tea. I take mine with nothing in it, and Nadia—"

"Yes?"

"There's nothing to be sorry about. It looked how it looked. That was the point of it."

Nadia looked at her. "That's a horrible thing to say."

"Yes."

By five the office was empty except for Emily. She had the public line saved as a draft and unsent. She went through her inbox: forty-one unread, four from journalists, all polite, all identical in shape. She replied to none of them.

She opened the file and put the photograph of the 2009 form where it belonged, in the exhibits folder, tab twelve, with a note of where and when it had been taken. Then she saved it and closed the laptop.

On the kitchen table at her flat, she knew, the index card was still lying face up. She hadn't been home to move it. She thought about that on the bus: the card, the kettle, the chair pushed in. She'd go home and make something to eat and move the card into a drawer, and it would keep, and so would everything else, because there was a hearing on Friday and after Friday there was the County Court list in October and after that there would still be Mrs Oduya and the four flights of stairs, whatever the papers wrote about her between now and then.

At Elephant and Castle the driver announced the stop and Emily got off and walked the last bit, past the lit windows, in the cold, with her collar up, unhurried.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 29: Exit Clause Invoked · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads