The Ethical Clause

Chapter 4: The Photograph On The Steps

The story ran at seven. Emily read it standing up in the café on Bell Yard, one hand flat on the counter because she'd walked from Southwark in the rain and hadn't bothered with a cab.

**THE TENANT'S CHAMPION — OR THE CHARITY CELEBRITY?**

It was Sian's byline, and it was good. It was better than good. Sian had gone through the seven invoices Emily had given her like a scalpel through a paper bag, and by the fourth paragraph she'd put the words *Orchard Foundation* and *Ridgeway Solutions* in the same sentence, and by the sixth she'd named the education access grant, the 1.2 million, the fact that the consultancy's registered address was a mailbox in Reading and its only named director had resigned four days before the grant was awarded.

By the seventh paragraph, Emily was the story.

*Hartwell, who has spent a decade building cases for tenants and care-home residents that larger firms will not touch, has been accused by foundation sources of "monetising outrage" — the phrase was used twice, unattributed — and of "positioning herself" for a libel claim she cannot afford to bring.*

The café had the radio on low, some phone-in about bus routes. A woman at the next table glanced at Emily's screen, then at Emily, then away too fast. Emily paid for the coffee she hadn't drunk and went out into the wet.

She'd meant to go straight to the office. Instead she walked down to the Royal Courts of Justice and stood at the foot of the steps.

She wasn't sure why. She'd taken a case here once, the first year of her own practice, and lost it in an hour, and she'd stood on the same spot afterwards and told herself that losing at the High Court still counted as being at the High Court. That had been ten years ago. She'd been here on the steps in the photograph. Not these steps. The Southwark ones, broader, uglier, with Denise's hand on the rail and the photographer crouched low so the sky came out grey and enormous behind them.

The picture was in the piece. Bottom of the page, cut-out, the two of them mid-stride, Emily's coat open, her jaw set. She'd been saying something to Denise. She couldn't remember what. She looked, in the shot, like a woman who was about to say something at a rally.

Her phone had been going since six. Her mother: *darling that is a lovely picture.* David Marsh: *Read it twice. Come in at nine not eight, we need to talk about the sentence about the libel claim.* And then, underneath all of it, the same unknown number from yesterday, one line:

*You have twenty minutes. I'll tell you where.*

She typed *who is this* again and got nothing back. She typed *I never agreed to twenty* and got nothing back. She put the phone in her pocket and looked up at the courts, at the wet stone and the brass lettering, at a man in a gown hurrying down with his wig in a tin.

A black car sat idling on the far side of the Strand, hazard lights off, engine running. Dark windows. She noticed it the way you notice a car when you're standing still and it isn't. She noticed, too, that it had been there when she arrived — that it hadn't been there for the photograph, that there was no photograph now, no lens, no one crouched on the pavement. Just the car.

She watched it for a full minute. The light on the Strand changed twice. Nobody got out.

That was the thing about being written about. You started seeing cars.

Her train home was late. She stood under the board at Waterloo and read the comment section because she hated herself. *Half of these "public interest" lawyers are on the make.* *She was on the news last year, wasn't she? The care home thing. Likes the cameras.* *If she's got proof why's she giving it to a paper and not the police.*

That last one was fair enough to hurt.

She got in at ten past nine, hung her coat on the door of the airing cupboard because the hook by the front door had come off in the spring and she'd never fixed it, and put the kettle on. One bedroom in Kennington, a rent she could explain to no one. The fridge hummed. Next door's television came through the wall at a murmur.

Under the bed was the box.

She'd looked at it four times since her father died. Twice she'd taken it out. Once she'd got as far as the lid, and found the padlock, and found that the padlock was not locked — it was old and stiff and she could have pulled it open with two fingers — and had put the whole thing back under the bed and gone to work.

*Emily — when you're ready to be angry.*

Her father had written that on the lid in biro, in the handwriting he used for shopping lists. He'd been a solicitor for a council in the north, twenty-eight years, a man who came home grey with other people's housing. He had not been an angry man. He had been a tired one. Emily had spent her twenties deciding that tired was the same as useless and her thirties discovering it wasn't.

She sat cross-legged on the floor with the box in front of her and opened it.

She'd taken the Orchard invoices out of it on Tuesday. Three-quarters of it still held what she'd left there years ago: her school reports, a photograph of the two of them on a pier, a savings book in her name she'd never used. And under that, a folder. Manilla, labelled *Correspondence — misc.*

She opened it on the floor.

It wasn't misc. It was forty pages of letters and memos, and they weren't about her father's council at all. They were about the Orchard Foundation. Her father's name was on the top of several of them — not as a signatory, as an object. *Re: R. Hartwell — query re: disclosure.* *R. Hartwell (Southwark) — advised to withdraw.* Dates from eleven years ago. Letters that had been addressed to him, and letters that hadn't, and a photocopy of a page of minutes with a paragraph bracketed in his biro and a single word in the margin: *why.*

Emily sat on the floor with her back against the bed and read them twice.

She had always believed she'd found the Orchard Foundation by herself. That it had come to her the way things came to her — through a tenant, through a care home, through somebody at a coffee morning with a folder of receipts. That the box was her father's grief and this was her work and the two were separate rooms.

She went through the folder again, page by page, slower. The last sheet wasn't a letter. It was a single photocopied invoice, badly reproduced, the top edge cut off. She knew the format the way you know a face across a room.

Ridgeway Solutions Ltd. Education access. £1.2m.

The signature block was in shadow — the photocopy had been made badly, the bottom third faded to grey, the ink too thin to resolve. But the name above the line was set in type, not handwriting.

*O. Aldridge.*

She sat with it until the fridge clicked off and the flat went quiet. The television next door had stopped. Her tea was cold on the counter where she'd left it.

Her phone lit the floor beside her.

*Ten minutes. Tomorrow. I'll come to you. — O.*

Then, a second later:

*I know what's in the box.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 4: The Photograph On The Steps · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads