The Ethical Clause

Chapter 44: Priya

The café was called Fig & Bean and it was the kind of place that had been a greengrocer once, then a phone shop, and was now exposing its brickwork on purpose. Emily got there forty minutes early and took the table in the window, which meant she could watch the door and the street at the same time.

Priya Raman arrived at eleven precisely. She was smaller than Emily had built her up to be over eleven days of silence — a compact woman in her sixties with reading glasses pushed up into grey hair and a canvas bag held across her body like a shield.

"I nearly didn't come," she said, sitting down without offering a hand. "I've been parked around the corner for twenty minutes deciding."

"I've been here forty."

"That's why I said nearly." Priya looked at the window, the door, the street. "The number you called. It's a pay-as-you-go. I bought it in the Covered Market. I don't use my own phone for anything to do with that place."

"That's sensible."

"I've been sensible for eleven years," Priya said. "It hasn't helped me sleep."

Emily had rehearsed a dozen openings. She used none of them. "You posted the sheet."

Priya didn't answer. She unwound a scarf that didn't need unwinding, folded it, put it on the chair beside her.

"You matched the coding to Larchwell internal prefixes," Emily said. "My colleague Nadia did that in a morning. You could have sent it to anyone — the Commission, a journalist, the police. You sent it to me."

"I read about you. The car park." Priya's mouth did something that wasn't a smile. "Everyone said you were doing it for the attention."

"And you thought the reverse."

"I thought, there's a woman who's already annoying them." She looked directly at Emily for the first time. "I was a finance officer at Larchwell for nine years. Assistant accountant from 2008, then finance officer to 2015. I sat in the third office on the second floor. I had the subcommittee minute files routed to me for reconciliation."

"Did you sign anything?"

"Everything. That was my job. I reconciled the Ridgeway payments against the vote references. Every quarter." Priya's hands were flat on the table, pressing down. "For three years I reconciled figures I knew didn't add up, and every quarter I was told the same thing: the Chair's Office approves the treatment. Present it as instructed."

"Who told you?"

"An email, mostly. Sometimes a call. Never the same person twice, which I thought about later." She paused. "And I copied them."

"The originals."

"Photocopies first. Then photographs, when the phones got good. Then — after the audit." Priya stopped.

Emily kept her voice level. "The unsigned audit."

"I was asked to release the physical file for destruction. It came to me as an instruction from the finance director's office, citing a retention policy. There was no policy. There has never been a retention policy for audit papers." Priya's voice had moved down into something quieter. "I made a copy of every page before it went. I annotated the copy. I'm not a lawyer. I don't know what makes a document count. But I made the copy."

"Nadia was right, then," Emily said. "You kept the originals."

"I kept what I made. The originals went where they went." Priya looked away. "Don't ask me where."

Emily took out her notebook and put it on the table, closed.

"There's a problem," she said. "Your sheet has thirty-one entries. Six of them don't match anything in the public filings. That's not a flaw, that's a lever — it means someone has to reconcile them, and reconciliation forces the internal records open. But the sheet has no provenance. I can't submit it as proof. I can use it to ask questions. I can't stand up and say a stranger sent it to me."

"I know."

"Do you want it to count?"

Priya was silent for a while. A waiter came over and she ordered tea, and Emily ordered another coffee she didn't want.

"I want it to count," Priya said finally. "I've been paying council tax in Wapping under the same name for six years. I didn't disappear. I wanted someone to find me. I just didn't want to be the first one through the door."

"Then the way it counts is you."

"That's a big door."

"I know."

They sat with that. Priya's tea came. She wrapped both hands around it and didn't drink.

"The Commission has opened a statutory inquiry," Emily said. "I'm giving evidence on the twenty-eighth of April. Six weeks. If you came, it wouldn't be in a courtroom. It would be a statement and a hearing and a lot of correspondence, and it would take a year, and at some point somebody in a suit will suggest your figures were mistaken or that you were disgruntled or that you left under a cloud. Which you didn't. You resigned clean in 2015."

"I resigned clean in 2015," Priya said. "With a reference. Because a woman in the Chair's Office said it would be best for everyone if I moved on somewhere with less . . . complexity."

"That's on the record somewhere."

"It's a sentence in a file."

"Then we put a name on you. That's what changes it."

Priya set the cup down. "I have a daughter in Bristol. A grandson. I'm not important enough to be worth lying about, and that's exactly why it will be my name and my signature they put in the correspondence. I've seen how these things go. I'll be the finance officer who couldn't read a policy. They won't say the letters went to the Chair's Office. They'll say I misinterpreted the letters."

"That's why you don't give them a first statement they can file and forget," Emily said. "You give them one with dates and references and copies attached, so the only way to dismiss you is to dismiss the documents. And if they dismiss the documents, the Commission has to say so in writing, and then they've made a finding we can appeal."

"You sound like you've done this before."

"I have. Not with this much at stake."

Priya almost smiled at that. It went as quickly as it came. "Are you going to ask me to testify?"

"I'm asking you to think about it."

"That's not the same thing."

"No."

"Ask me properly."

Emily leaned forward and kept her hands where Priya could see them.

"Will you give a witness statement to the Charity Commission and appear at the hearing?"

Priya was quiet for a long moment. Then: "I'll think about it."

It wasn't no. Emily knew better than to push at a door that had just opened a crack.

"One more thing, then, and it's not for the file," Emily said. "The sheet — you wrote a 2013 entry with a name on it. Oliver Aldridge. Chair's Office. Was that naming him, or was that the paper naming him?"

"Both," Priya said. "The subcommittee minutes used to route through the Chair's Office for approval. His initials were on the routing sheet, that's all. That's how the file worked. He was a name on a track-and-trace sheet for two years, and I never once met him."

"And what did you think he was?"

"I thought he was the reason I couldn't refuse." Priya looked at her tea. "Or I thought he was a twenty-five-year-old who signed what he was handed, like I did. I never found out which. That's part of why I sent you the sheet, if I'm honest. You'd know how to look."

Emily said nothing.

"Something else I should tell you," Priya said. "The routing sheets never came with a signature. They came with a reference number. The reference numbers — some of them don't correspond to any subcommittee I ever minuted. There's a parallel series. That was the thing that made me start copying in the first place. There's a series of votes that weren't minuted, with references that only exist in the payments." She pulled the canvas bag toward her. "I don't have those in the tin. But I know where each of them falls in the ledger."

Emily's pencil was on the table and her hand wasn't moving toward it, because if she wrote, Priya would stop.

"Then there's one thing I need you to understand before you decide anything," Emily said. "The first copy of your sheet is with counsel, not with the Commission. It stays with counsel until you tell me otherwise. Nothing you've said today can be quoted, prompted or covered by anyone but me. If you walk out of here and never call me back, the sheet goes no further and nobody learns where it came from."

Priya studied her for a long moment. Then she let go of the café's atmosphere the way you let go of a held breath, and reached for her bag.

"There's a small box under my kitchen sink," she said. "Do you want to see it?"

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 44: Priya · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads