The Ethical Clause

Chapter 54: The Regulator's Hearing, Day One

The hearing room at the Charity Commission's Bloomsbury office had been built for utility, not drama: grey carpet tiles, a strip light with one tube flickering, a conference table long enough to seat fourteen and a smaller one for the panel. Emily had been in worse rooms. She had given evidence in a Victorian courtroom with a radiator that clanked like a dying man. This was just colder.

She was sworn in at 9:41 and did not leave the chair until twenty past twelve.

The panel was three: a lead commissioner named Brazier, a lawyer from the register side called Delahunty, and a specialist member, Ms. Okoro, who said almost nothing and wrote constantly. The foundation's counsel was a barrister named Fitzherbert-Smythe, sixty, silver, courteous in the way of a man who had learned that courtesy wounds more cleanly than sarcasm.

Brazier took her through the foundations of it first. The office in Southwark. The twenty-two tenants of Bellhaven Court. The care home in Croydon where the heating had failed for eleven weeks and the manager had written the same letter to the foundation four times. Emily answered in the flat register she used for tribunals, dates and document numbers and no adjectives, and Ms. Okoro's pen moved steadily.

At 10:50 they reached the consultancy payments.

"Ms. Hartwell," Brazier said, "you've prepared a schedule at tab eleven of your bundle. Could you take the panel through it."

She had it memorised. "There are nineteen payments across seven years, totalling four hundred and twelve thousand pounds, from Fairview Community Partnerships to a company called Ridgeway Advisory. They're not spread evenly. They cluster. Eight of the nineteen fall in the eleven weeks before a grant decision, and each of those grants went to a project that Ridgeway had been engaged to 'scope.'" She turned a page though she did not need to. "The pattern is the timing. Consultancy is invoiced before the decision, not after. That isn't how consultancy works. That's how a fee works."

"Did you find a written contract for any of these payments?"

"One. For eleven thousand pounds, in 2010. The other eighteen were paid on invoice against a purchase order number that doesn't exist in the foundation's own system."

Fitzherbert-Smythe rose at 11:15 and did not waste the first ten minutes.

He took her through her own funding, which she had expected. The legal charity that underwrote her salary, the crowd fund for the Bellhaven case, the two journalists who had written about her. He read out a headline. *The Lawyer Who Wants To Be Somebody.* He let the words sit.

"You've given a number of interviews, Ms. Hartwell."

"I've given three."

"Four, if we count the podcast."

"Three interviews and one podcast."

"You're comfortable in front of a camera."

"I'm comfortable in front of a tribunal. The camera is a consequence."

"Would it be fair to say your case has attracted more attention than the underlying litigation would ordinarily attract?"

"Would it be fair to say the foundation's transfer of forty-one million pounds to a Guernsey vehicle attracted more attention than it ordinarily would?"

Brazier's mouth did something that was almost a smile. Fitzherbert-Smythe moved on without acknowledging it.

He took her through her contact with the Commission, the timing of her disclosure, the fact that she had not, until this year, brought a civil claim. He suggested the regulatory route had been chosen because it was louder. She said the civil route had been chosen first, in 2022, and had been stayed pending the Commission's inquiry, which was a matter of record, and he could check tab two.

At 11:52 he changed tack, and she felt it before she saw it.

"Ms. Hartwell, you've had contact with a witness in this matter."

"I've had contact with a number of witnesses."

"With Mr. Oliver Aldridge."

The room got very slightly quieter, in the way rooms do.

"Yes."

"Fourteen days ago you received an email from him containing a substantial disclosure."

"Yes."

"In the intervening period you've exchanged further messages."

"We've exchanged messages about the disclosure."

"You've also submitted a witness statement describing your contact with him as 'personal.'" He said the word as if holding it with tongs. "Ms. Hartwell, let me ask you directly. Were you romantically involved with Mr. Aldridge at the time he made this disclosure?"

Ms. Okoro's pen stopped. It was the first time it had stopped.

Emily had known the question was coming. She had known since Hallam's call, since the photograph, since the eleven o'clock news described her as his "companion." She had been asked it by Rachel, gently, in the kitchen, and had said *it's contracted*, which was true and also not an answer. She had prepared a version of this answer for three days. The version was careful. The version said the relationship was a matter of public record and not relevant to the substance of the disclosure.

She looked at Brazier. She looked at Fitzherbert-Smythe, who was waiting with the small, patient expectancy of a man who intends to make her deny it and then produce the car in the photograph, the restaurant, the two of them on the pavement outside her flat at half past eleven at night, and build a whole afternoon out of it.

She thought about Priya, who would sign on Monday but wanted her caveat recorded. She thought about item fifteen, which Oliver did not know had been withheld, and about how a woman who is caught lying about something small is not believed about something large.

"Yes," she said.

Fitzherbert-Smythe's pen paused, fractionally. It was the only tell he gave.

"I'm sorry?"

"Yes, I was. We are. It's not a secret and I'm not going to pretend it is." She kept her hands flat on the table. "The relationship began under a written agreement, which I can produce. It was entered into in bad faith by me, and I've said so to Mr. Aldridge, and I'll say so to you. It has no bearing on the sixteen hundred documents in tab fourteen, which came from the foundation's own servers and which Mr. Aldridge disclosed to the Commission without privilege and without redaction. He put his own name on them. He didn't have to. I would have got them eventually and he knew I would, and he chose to be the source rather than the obstruction." She paused. "You can make whatever you like of why. The documents say what they say."

Silence. Brazier looked down at his papers. Ms. Okoro wrote something and underlined it twice.

"Nothing further," Fitzherbert-Smythe said, and sat down, and for the first time all morning he looked like a man recalculating.

They broke at 12:20. Emily came out into the corridor with her hands shaking slightly and Rachel pressed a paper cup of tea into them without a word. Hallam was at the far end by the lifts, standing very straight with a folder under his arm, and when he saw her he didn't come over. He looked at the folder. Then at her. Then he turned and got into the lift.

Brazier put his head round the door. "Ms. Hartwell. We'll resume at two, but the panel would like the schedule at tab eleven expanded before then. Specifically the three payments in 2010 that predate the Ridgeway engagement letter."

"Of course."

"And Ms. Hartwell." He glanced back into the room, then at her. "The answer you gave. It was the right one. It's also now on the record, and the register publishes this afternoon." He left.

Rachel had gone white. "Emily. The register."

"I know."

"Oliver's name—"

"I know." She found her phone. Two journalists, then three, then a missed call from a number she didn't recognise and an email from the *Times* with the subject line *urgent — Aldridge statement — 2pm*. And beneath it, from a sender she had not heard from in fourteen days in anything but logistics: a message from Oliver, two lines, sent eleven minutes ago.

*They're publishing my name at two. I'm not going to comment. Whatever they ask you, name me. I'd rather it was you than Fitzherbert-Smythe.*

She stood in the corridor with the tea going cold in her hand, and understood that in forty minutes his name would be on a public register with hers in the same paragraph, that counsel would have it by lunch, and that there was no version of the afternoon — of the week — in which the two of them could be separated in anyone's account, including her own.

Her phone rang again. This time it was Celia.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 54: The Regulator's Hearing, Day One · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads