The Ethical Clause

Chapter 62: The Settlement Offer

The letter arrived by courier at 8:41, which was itself a message: not posted, not emailed, not handed to her in the corridor outside court, but sent by a man on a motorbike who needed a signature and a name and left with both.

Nadia slit the envelope with the office letter-opener, which was a blunt butter knife, because they had never bought anything better.

“Wren & Cattermole,” she said. “Third page is the interesting one.”

Emily read it standing up, coat still on. Then she read it again, sitting down, and then she read it a third time out loud, because that was the only way she trusted any document that came from a firm with a Cresta Run print on the wall and a partner who had called her four times in five days.

“Without admission of liability,” she read, “and on a purely commercial basis, the foundation will (a) return the sum of one million two hundred thousand pounds to the relevant commissioning bodies, (b) pay your costs to date on the standard basis, and (c) make a donation of one hundred thousand pounds to a charity of your nomination, in exchange for (i) discontinuance of the claim against the foundation and all its trustees, and (ii) a joint statement in which the parties acknowledge that at all times the trustees acted in good faith and in the honest belief that their conduct was proper.”

She set the pages on the corner of the desk, on top of the exhibit list, and looked at the room.

They were all there. That was the thing about the office now: there were always people in it. Priya had come straight from a night shift at the hospital and was eating toast out of a paper bag. Two of the Ridgeway tenants had come up from the coach station with their bags still between their feet. Donal, who was eighty-one and had been in the building since before the lease changed hands, sat in the good chair because Nadia had given it to him and would not take it back. There were eleven of them in a room built for six.

“Right,” Emily said. “So that’s where they are.”

“That’s not where they are,” Nadia said. “That’s where their insurers are. Wren & Cattermole don’t write letters like that unless someone has run the numbers and decided that the freeze costs them more than the money does.”

Donal set his cup down. “Read it again,” he said. “The last bit.”

She read it again. *The trustees acted in good faith.*

“That’s the price,” Donal said.

“That’s the price,” Emily agreed.

Priya swallowed her toast. “Explain it to me like I’m not a lawyer.”

“They give back the money that was taken from the care budgets, they cover what this has cost us, and in exchange I sign a piece of paper saying the people who took it believed they were doing the right thing. Not that they *were* doing the right thing. That they believed it.” She turned the page over, though there was nothing on the back. “And then the claim against them ends. Against all of them. Maurice Fell included.”

“And if you sign it,” one of the tenants said — the older sister, the one with the folder of damp photographs — “we get our money back anyway.”

“Yes.”

“So why are we sitting here?”

Nobody answered her, which was an answer.

It took forty minutes. It would have taken ten if Emily had simply told them what she thought, and she did not, because the whole case had been built on the principle that no one was going to decide these things in a room they were not in. She said what the offer was worth. She said what the freeze was worth. She said, plainly, that if they took the deal the money was certain and fast and nobody would ever again have to hear the word *proceedings* on a Tuesday night in a church hall. She said that if they refused, Hallam would go for her provenance argument, and the fact that her father had written the annotations on the 2010 audit would be used to make the whole thing look like a family quarrel dressed up as a fraud.

“He’ll say I found a reason to sue people who once told my dad his work wasn’t good enough,” she said. “He won’t have to prove it. He’ll just have to say it.”

Donal looked at her over the top of his glasses. “Did he?”

“Did who what?”

“Your dad. Did they say that to him?”

Emily thought about the sealed envelope, and the sentence in it: *I kept the originals with the young accountant.* Six years of her father quietly keeping a copy of what he had refused to sign, and never telling her, and dying with it in a box. “Something like that,” she said.

The tenants voted in the old way, hands up, which was what they had done at the first meeting in a community hall in Bermondsey with a broken fire door and forty people who had never met a lawyer before. Eleven to nil.

“No statement,” said the older sister, who had spent two years being told she was mistaken about her own damp.

“No immunity,” said the man next to her, who had never once asked Emily what she was getting out of it.

Nadia wrote it on the whiteboard in the corner, under *Carn Brea — where is it*, because there was no other paper big enough. *No statement. No immunity.*

Emily drafted the reply at her desk with her coat still on and the toast smell still in the room. It was eleven lines. It took her longer than the letter deserved.

*Dear Sirs,*

*We have considered your clients’ proposal of 14th instant. Our clients are grateful for the promptness with which it was made and are unmoved by it.*

*We accept paragraph (a) and paragraph (b) as set out, and we decline paragraph (c). We will not join any statement characterising the trustees’ belief as honest, and we will not discontinue the claim against any trustee.*

*If your clients wish to return the misdirected funds without admission, they may do so on Monday and we will say so in open court. If they wish to purchase a narrative, they will have to buy it from a judge.*

*Yours faithfully,*

*E. Hartwell*

She read it back once for the grammar and once for the pleasure of it, and sent it at 10:06.

The reply came in twenty-nine minutes, which was faster than anyone in that building had ever been answered by anyone with a Cresta Run print on the wall, and it was not from the partner. It was from Hallam himself, two paragraphs, no salutation.

*Ms Hartwell,*

*I am instructed to record that your refusal has been noted and that my clients reserve the entirety of their position on the provenance of Exhibit J-14 and upon your personal connection to it.*

*My clients will also expect your answer to the following before the hearing on the 29th. In November 2016 the foundation paid £14,000 to a firm of accountants in Truro in respect of an audit of a subsidiary whose name does not appear in any of your schedules, and the sum was approved by a trustee who is not named on any of your pleadings because you have not discovered who he was. My clients do not accept your characterisation of their conduct, but they are content for you to spend the next eleven days discovering what else they have not told you.*

*Your offer of Monday is declined.*

*L. Hallam*

Emily read it twice, then walked to the whiteboard with the marker still in her hand from the good news.

Truro. She had never located Carn Brea, because she had been looking for a company, and it was a place. A hill on the coast, in Cornwall, fifteen miles from the town whose accountants had been paid in November 2016 to audit a subsidiary called — she did not know what it was called — and the fee approved by a trustee she had never been able to name, because there had never been a trustee in the schedules who signed nothing.

She thought of the notebook in her bag with *Things he did not sign* at the top of the first page. Beneath her father’s name she had written her childhood address. She had not known why.

Now she stood in front of the whiteboard, under *No statement. No immunity.*, and wrote:

*There was a fifth trustee.*

And underneath it, slowly, so that the marker squeaked:

*22nd November 2016 — Truro — subsidiary — who approved £14,000?*

Behind her Priya said, quietly, “He just told you exactly where to dig.”

“Yes,” Emily said.

“Why would he do that?”

Nadia answered from the other desk, without looking up. “Because he wants to know what’s down there first.”

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 62: The Settlement Offer · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads