The letter from the insurers was one page. Emily had read it three times on the walk back from the Tube and once more at her desk with the lamp angled over it, as though the wording might renegotiate itself under better light.
"We refer to your notification of 14 March. Having reviewed the claim in light of the matters disclosed in open court on 21 March, we are not satisfied that the circumstances fall within the scope of cover. The policy excludes liability arising from proceedings commenced where the insured knew or ought reasonably to have known of a material conflict."
"There's no conflict," Emily said aloud. The office was empty; saying it to the yellowing ceiling felt marginally better than saying it to nobody.
The settlement figure sat on the bottom line like a stone: ninety thousand pounds to run the case to judgment. Not the sum they'd budgeted. The sum after Wren & Cattermole's costs schedule had arrived that morning and the expert's fee for the tracing exercise had been revised upward, which was its own small betrayal.
She had already known. Somewhere she'd known since Okaro had said *find whoever knows why he refused to sign* and she had stood up in her father's name — that the case had stopped being free the moment it became a story.
The door banged. David came in sideways with two coffees and a bag of pastries, saw her face, and put both cups down without comment.
"Don't," she said.
"I haven't said anything."
"You're doing the face."
"It's my resting face." He pulled a chair round and sat, and she slid the letter across. He read it slowly, which was one of his worst qualities, and set it down with the flat care of a man putting something breakable where a child can't reach.
"Right," he said. "So we appeal the declination. Their own exclusion is ambiguous — *ought reasonably to have known* is a mess, we argue it. That's four to six weeks."
"And if we lose the appeal?"
"Then we sell the lease."
"David."
"I'm being practical, Emily."
"It's a leasehold on a converted printworks with a leaking roof and a stairwell the fire officer described as *a matter of time*. Nobody is going to pay ninety thousand pounds for it."
"I've had an offer," he said. "Sixty-two. From the accountants on the second floor."
She looked at the room she was sitting in. Two desks, four chairs, a filing cabinet that had belonged to her father's office and had the scratched corner to prove it. A kettle that took six minutes. The whiteboard with *FIFTH TRUSTEE* in red, and beneath it, smaller, *Carn Brea*. On the windowsill, the box.
"You took an offer without asking me."
"I told them I'd think about it." He turned the cup round on the desk. "There's no version of this where we run the case and keep the building. I ran the numbers eleven times. I'd like to be wrong."
The kettle clicked off in the corner, unregarded. It took a certain skill to let silence do work like that.
The stairwell clattered. Nadia came up with her coat over her arm and a bank slip in her hand, and Emily knew before she spoke, the way you know weather.
"Forty-one thousand," Nadia said. "My savings. It's not ninety, but it stops the bleeding on the disclosure until the appeal finishes, and by then—"
"Put it away."
"I haven't finished."
"Nadia. Put it away."
Nadia looked at her — properly, the tenant-lawyer look, the one that had stared down landlords and letting agents and an entire housing association's counsel — and put the slip back in her pocket, folded in half.
"You'd want me to take it if it were yours," she said.
"I wouldn't take it. That's the point."
"Mrs. Adem sold her stairlift to pay for the expert report on the windows," Nadia said. "You didn't stop her."
"Mrs. Adem is the client."
"And I'm the staff, is that it?"
She was. She was twenty-six and she'd turned down two commercial firms to work out of this room and she was the only person on the team who could find a claimant in a tower block after four visits.
"You're the staff," Emily said, "and you're the one who stays when this gets worse, and if the case loses you go back to your flat and you've still got forty-one thousand pounds, and if I take it and we lose, you don't. I'm not spending your future on my father."
Nadia's jaw worked. Then she said, quite quietly, "It isn't only your father's case."
"I know."
"Say you know."
"I know."
David started to say something and thought better of it. Which was, on balance, an improvement in his character.
They sat there in the six-minutes-to-boil dusk while Emily did the arithmetic she'd been avoiding.
Ninety thousand. The appeal would take weeks. The insurers might come back at forty, at thirty, at nothing. Wren & Cattermole had four calls outstanding and a partner who was, Emily suspected, waiting for her to be desperate enough to accept their terms before he disclosed whatever it was he had. And there were eleven days until the twenty-ninth, and Hallam had thrown her the Truro payment like a bone at a dog, and she still didn't know what he wanted from her.
"Then we ask for it," she said.
"Ask who?"
"Everyone. The coalitions. The housing charities. Anyone who's ever had a case of mine thrown out of their column inches. If the case is public, so is the cost." She stood. "We publish the number. If we run out, we run out in the open."
David looked at the whiteboard. "That's a hostage to fortune."
"Everything we've done for four months is a hostage to fortune. At least this way it's honest."
Nadia had her phone out already, thumbing something with the energy of a person who'd been waiting to be given a task instead of a refusal. "There's a woman at Shelter who's been emailing me non-stop since the 21st. Actually —" she scrolled, "— she's been emailing me about a *fundraiser*. She mentioned a pub. Peckham. I said I'd ask."
Emily allowed herself, briefly, one clean breath.
"Ask," she said. "And Nadia — the forty-one stays in your account."
"Fine."
"Say it."
"I will not say it."
The door went again, and all three of them stopped, because nobody knocked on that landing except the fire officer and the two accountants, and there in the doorway stood a man in late middle age, small, in a zip-up fleece, with the apologetic carriage of someone who had spent a career in institutions and had learned to occupy as little room as possible.
"You're Emily Hartwell," he said. "I'm Timothy Aldous. I had your office down for tomorrow, but I was passing." He glanced at the box on the windowsill, at the whiteboard, at the three of them unmoving, and had the grace to look embarrassed. "I closed the file," he said. "The 2011 one. I closed it, and I've never been able to explain why, and I would rather do it while I still can."
David looked at Emily. Nadia looked at Emily. The number on the letterhead on the desk said ninety thousand pounds and no insurer in England would pay it.
"Tea's six minutes," Emily said, and pulled out the spare chair.