The Ethical Clause

Chapter 66: Anonymous Donor

The email from the Fallow Trust landed at 8:41 a.m., and by 9:15 the money was in the case account.

Emily found out from Nadia, who came through the door with her coat still on and her phone held out like a warrant. "It's there. Forty-five thousand, on the nose. Same-day CHAPS, reference 'FT-CASE-266.'"

Emily took the phone. The banking page was plain, grey and green, and there it was: incoming, cleared funds, balance that had been £45,112.80 the night before now reading £90,112.80. She had spent three weeks keeping that number under a hundred thousand in her head so it would not look like progress.

"CHAPS," she said.

"Nobody sends CHAPS for a charity gift unless they want it to land this morning," Nadia said. "And look at the sender field."

Emily looked. *Fallow Trust — Client Account.*

"Client account," she said.

"Client account," Nadia agreed. "So it isn't a trust at all. It's a solicitor holding money."

David came out of the back room with his tea and read over Emily's shoulder without asking, which he had earned. "That's a conveyancing pattern," he said. "That's how money moves when someone doesn't want their name on it."

Emily put the phone down on the desk, next to the box from her father's flat, which she still had not moved. "Get me the register entry."

It took Nadia eleven minutes. The Fallow Trust was registered at Companies House two years ago, charitable purpose declared as "the relief of poverty and the advancement of education," one trustee, no website, no accounts filed yet because it was young enough not to have to. The registered office was 14 Bedford Row.

Emily knew 14 Bedford Row the way she knew her own office: it was the London address of Price, Grieve & Co., the firm that had drawn up Oliver's deed of renunciation, and whose senior partner had been quoted in the Gazette piece on the deed saying that Mr Wren had acted, in his view, "out of a plain and decent sense of what he owed."

She sat down.

"Say it," Nadia said.

"That's Oliver's solicitor's address."

"Then it's his money."

"It's his money," Emily said.

David set his tea down with more care than usual. "He was asked not to come to the fundraiser. He didn't come. He sent the drinks round anonymously and then he sent the rest of it the same way, which is—" He stopped.

"Which is exactly what someone does when they've been told to stay out of it and can't bear to," Nadia said.

Emily picked up her phone. There were still four missed calls from Wren & Cattermole, which she had not returned because returning them would make her Ollie's lawyer's counterpart, and there were still two from Celia, which she had not returned because she did not yet know what she was going to say. There was a message from Oliver from nine days ago that said *I'd like to tell you something in person* and nothing since, because she had not answered it, and he had stopped, which she had noted and not examined.

"Don't call him," David said.

"I'm not going to call him."

"You were looking at the phone in the way that means you're going to call someone."

"I'm going to write," Emily said. "Not to him. To the trust. And to Price, Grieve."

She opened a document and typed for twenty minutes while Nadia watched and David went back to the bundle. The letter was two paragraphs and she read it three times before she sent it, which was more than she did with the trustees.

*Dear Sirs,*

*We acknowledge receipt of £45,000 into the case account held for the above matter, from you as agent for the Fallow Trust. We are not able to accept it. The donor's identity and the source of the funds cannot be verified on the information provided, and the timing and the vehicle used — a client account at a firm that acts in a matter connected to the claim — create a real risk that the money is not a gift to the claim but a payment to the claimant personally. We cannot run a case funded by a party against whose interest we are litigating.*

*Please confirm by return how the funds should be returned and we will transmit them today. We will treat the receipt as an administrative error on both sides and will not refer to it further.*

She signed it, sent it to the trust at the address on the register, copied Price, Grieve & Co., and did not copy anyone else, though it occurred to her that copying Oliver was the thing she most wanted to do and therefore the thing she must not.

"You should probably tell the insurers," David said. "There's a notification clause. If money came in and went out of the case account, they'll want it on the file."

"They'll want it on the file anyway. Hallam will have it by Friday."

"Hallam?"

"Hallam will have known about the fundraiser before we did," Emily said. "And Hallam will notice if a case that was ninety thousand short on Monday is fifty short on Tuesday. He'll assume a donor. He'll ask who, in open court, in front of a judge, which is the point of him." She pulled the whiteboard towards her. There were three things on it now: *Carn Brea*, *5th trustee*, and *£14,000 / Nov 2016*, and under them the hearing date, the 29th, five days off. She wrote, in the corner, in small letters, *Fallow/14 Bedford Row*, and looked at it.

"Frankly," she said, "the money is not the dangerous part. The dangerous part is that he can make a gift this size out of a client account overnight, and that his solicitor will do it for him, and that neither of them thinks it is a problem."

"It's not a problem for him. He's renounced forty-one million."

"He's renounced the trust," Emily said. "He hasn't renounced the money. Nobody has forty-one million lying about without ever having had it. If he can move forty-five thousand in a morning, he's been living on something else this whole time, and it isn't the trust, because the trust is what we're suing."

Nadia stopped typing. "You're saying the money under the sofa isn't the money we're fighting over."

"I'm saying I've been assuming the trust is where the Wren money is," Emily said. "Every pleading, every schedule, every disclosure request, assumes it. And the one thing that keeps arriving — the one thing Hallam keeps putting in front of me — is fourteen thousand pounds that went sideways in November 2016 to a firm in Truro for an audit of a company that isn't in any of our documents. A fifth trustee approved it. Five trustees, one of them off the books, and the off-books one is the one who signed for an audit nobody has ever seen." She tapped the board. "That isn't a trust that hides money. That's a structure that hides a *person*."

The return came at 4:52 p.m. Price, Grieve & Co., one paragraph, no courtesy, no phone call: *We confirm the instruction. Please remit to the account from which the funds were received. Our client will not be pursuing the matter.*

*Our client.*

Emily read the two words four times, then forwarded the email to Nadia and David with no comment, then went out onto the balcony with her phone because the office had no air and her chest had gone tight.

Oliver's message from nine days ago was still sitting there. *I'd like to tell you something in person.* She had read it as an apology and left it. She had read it as him wanting to be forgiven for the foundation and left it. She had not, until this moment, read it as what it actually was, which was a man offering, unprompted, nine days before she knew she needed it, to tell her something.

She went back inside and put the return confirmation in the bundle file, and then, because she was a lawyer and not a fool, she pulled the 2016 trustees' minute book from the box and turned to the pages she had read a hundred times, and read them again from the last entry backwards.

Celia. Wren. Baynard. Fyfe.

Four names on the trust deed. Four signatures on every minute for nine years. And nowhere, not once, an initial, a proxy, a *present by leave* — nothing that would ever put a fifth name on paper, in a book that Hallam's side has had every opportunity to amend and has not.

The money had gone back out of the account within the business day. She sent a one-line note to the organisers of the Peckham night — *declined a large donation, full details to follow, we're still £45,000 short* — and watched the replies come in like weather. Some people asked who the donor was. She did not answer.

At seven, the email she had been waiting for arrived: the Rolls Building, court listing, fourteen days, opening on the 29th.

Fourteen days of cross-examination on her ethics, with a case half-funded and a man who could move forty-five thousand pounds in an hour waiting to be called about the fourth name that wasn't in the book.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.