The Ethical Clause

Chapter 75: The Costs

The costs order came through on a Tuesday, three weeks after judgment, buried in a schedule of interest calculations Nadia had been chasing since six in the morning.

Emily read it standing up, coat still on, the kettle clicking itself off behind her.

"Nine point two," she said. "Plus interest. Plus costs on the indemnity basis."

Nadia looked up from the second desk. "Indemnity?"

"They asked for it. They got it." Emily put the papers down. "Which means we don't wait for a taxing master to argue about whether we overspent on photocopying. They pay what we spent."

"That's—" Nadia did the arithmetic in the air with one hand. "That's the whole thing, Emily. That's the office. That's the lease and the box and the two of us."

"That's the case," Emily said. "It's not the office."

She took her coat off and hung it on the back of the door, which was where coats went because there was no hook, only a nail David Russell had put in before he left, and it had held his anorak for six years and now held hers.

The distinction took Nadia about ninety seconds to work out. Emily watched her get there: the tightening around the mouth, the way she went back to the interest schedule without seeing it.

"The costs come to the firm," Nadia said. "The firm pays me. The firm pays the rent."

"The costs pay the firm," Emily said. "Then the firm pays you. Then the firm pays the rent. In that order, and the order's the problem."

She did the numbers twice that night, once with the calendar open and once with it closed, hoping the closed version would be kinder. It wasn't.

Costs on an indemnity basis would land in the firm's account, which was also Emily's account, which was also the account the Southwark lease drew from on the first of every month. Three years at the current rate, with the review clause the landlord had inserted in 2019 and never invoked. Business rates. The service charge, which had gone up eleven per cent and would go up again. Two salaries, one of them Nadia's, one of them Emily's, the second drawn irregularly since March because the case had eaten the year.

If she took the full costs figure and paid everything properly, she could keep the office for eighteen months, maybe twenty. Then the lease review, then the rates, then the thing that always happened, which was that a case like the one just won generated no new work for a year because everyone who might have hired her was waiting to see whether she'd turn out to be radioactive.

If she gave up the lease and moved, she could make the money last five years. Five years was long enough to build the next case. Five years was a real thing.

But there was no smaller office in Southwark that would take a two-person firm with no deposit history and a public profile like a scar. She'd looked. Nadia had looked. Everywhere they looked was either three times the rate or a serviced unit above a phone shop where you couldn't have a client in a wheelchair, and half Emily's clients were in wheelchairs, and one of them had already told her, at the Christmas thing they did with sandwiches from the deli on the corner, that the lift was the reason she came.

She wrote the two columns on the whiteboard, wiped off a photograph of the Winslow care home sign to do it, and looked at them until the marker smell made her head ache.

Keep the office: eighteen months of safety, then nothing.

Give up the office: five years of runway, and the clients who needed a lift went somewhere worse.

She stood there so long that Nadia, arriving at eight with two coffees, found her still in yesterday's shirt.

"You haven't chosen," Nadia said.

"I've chosen," Emily said. "I just don't like it."

The landlord's agent was called Mr Bhandari and he had a way of not sitting down that made the room feel like his even when it was hers.

"Three years," he said. "The same terms. Review at the second anniversary."

"The review clause has never been invoked."

"It's never been a market like this." He looked around the office, at the box of indexed documents under the window, at the whiteboard with its two columns, neither of which he could read from where he stood. "You've had a good year, Ms Hartwell. It's in the papers."

"Being in the papers isn't income."

"No," he agreed, pleasantly. "It isn't. But it's a guarantee of a sort. If I have to re-let this floor, I'll have three tenants who want it for a gym. I don't want a gym. I want rent."

"Then give me a five-year term at the current rate and no review."

"Three years, current rate, review at two. And a personal guarantee."

There it was. She'd known it would be there; she'd told herself in the lift that it wouldn't.

"A personal guarantee," she repeated.

"The firm's two years old in its current form. You've got costs coming in and no line of work coming after. I'm not stupid, Ms Hartwell, and I don't think you are either. I'll take the firm's covenant and yours."

"My flat is rented."

"Your name is worth something now. That's what a guarantee is for." He smiled again. "Take the weekend. It's a good floor. I'd rather you kept it."

She didn't take the weekend. She sat on the floor of the office that evening with the lease draft on her knees and the bank's draft guarantee in her bag, and she read both documents properly, in order, the way she read everything, marking nothing, just reading, because the only defence she had ever had against a document was to have read it before the other side assumed she hadn't.

The guarantee meant that if the firm failed, the debt attached to Emily Hartwell personally. Which meant the flat in Bermondsey, such as it was. Which meant, in the worst case, that the case she had won would be the thing that took her home, slowly, over three years, one quarter-day at a time.

She thought about Nadia's face when she'd said *the order's the problem*. She thought about the client with the wheelchair and the lift. She thought about the £45,000 she hadn't put in the submissions, and how she'd told herself that keeping her own exposure off the record was strategy when it had mostly been shame.

Then she thought about the alternative, which was a serviced office in Elephant and Castle with a shared meeting room and a receptionist who would ask her clients to sign in, and she knew, with the same flat certainty she'd felt when she'd taken Daniel Whitlock's case at the start, that she would rather be poor in Southwark than solvent in Elephant and Castle.

She signed the lease on Thursday. Alone, at the table by the window, with Mr Bhandari opposite her and a witness he'd brought himself, a woman from the floor below who ran a nail bar and who signed her name like she was signing a card. Emily signed the guarantee in the same sitting, both copies, and initialled eleven places, and when it was done Mr Bhandari shook her hand and said, "Good luck with it," and meant it, and she believed him, and it didn't help.

Nadia came back from the post room at noon and found her still at the table.

"Done?"

"Done." Emily pushed the copy across. "Three years. Review at two. I guaranteed it personally."

Nadia didn't say anything for a moment. Then she said, "Why didn't you tell me you were going to guarantee it."

"Because you'd have told me not to."

"Yes."

"Which is why."

Nadia sat down at the second desk, which was also the meeting room and also the place the biscuits lived, and put both hands flat on the table like someone steadying a boat.

"For the record," she said, "I think it's reckless."

"Noted."

"And I'm not going anywhere."

"I know."

"I'm serious. Don't do the thing where you decide I'd be better off at a bigger firm and start leaving job adverts near my keyboard."

Emily laughed, which she hadn't done in the office since February. "I've never done that."

"You did it in November."

"That was a housing lawyer role. It was relevant to your interests."

"You circled it in red."

"It was a good job." Emily got up and put the kettle on, because the kettle was the only appliance large enough to hold a conversation around. "It was. It paid sixty-five."

"I don't want sixty-five," Nadia said. "I want to finish the donor scheme."

The donor identification scheme. Ninety days. They had sixty-eight left, and Emily had been avoiding it, because building it properly meant going back into the foundation's records, back into the same paper that had named the name she didn't want to see again.

"Em," Nadia said. "There's something in the file. From the trial bundle. The index card."

"It's in the box."

"It's in your coat."

Emily looked at her. Nadia looked back, steadily, the way she looked at everything, which was why she was still here.

"You've been carrying it since the judgment," Nadia said. "I've seen it. You take it out of the pocket with your train ticket. It's how I know you've been on a train."

Emily went to the back of the door and put her hand in the coat and took it out. The card was soft at the corner now, the way paper goes when a thumb has been over it too many times. Clause 7.2. Termination on written notice from either party, no reason required. Fell's KC had read it aloud to a packed court and asked whether that was how she treated clients, and she had answered the question, and the answer was on the record, and the card was still in her pocket because she had never been able to work out where else it should go.

"Throw it away," Nadia said.

"It's evidence."

"It's been adjudicated. It's not evidence any more. It's a thing you keep."

Emily held it a moment longer. Then she tore it in half, and in half again, and put the pieces in the bin under the second desk, and did not make a ceremony of it, because there was nothing ceremonious in it. It was a card. It had done what cards do.

Then she went back to the table and pulled the box towards her and opened the lid.

"Right," she said. "Sixty-eight days. Donor scheme. Start at the beginning."

Nadia brought the biscuits over and sat down beside her, and outside the window the light went off the buildings on the other side of the street the way it did every afternoon around four, and the two of them worked until it was dark, and the rent was paid, for now, for three years, and the pieces of the card sat in the bin and nobody looked at them again.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 75: The Costs · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads