The flowers were already on the windowsill when Emily came down the stairs from the upstairs meeting room, and Nadia was standing over them with her arms folded like a woman guarding a crime scene.
"These came for you at eight-forty. No card. Delivery slip only." Nadia stepped back so Emily could see them properly. "White roses. Twelve of them. Guess."
"Not a guessing morning." Emily dropped her files on the corner of the desk that had become the only clear surface in the office and looked at the bouquet. It was expensive. That was the first thing: not the sort of thing you picked up at the garage on the way in. Long stems, tight buds, cellophane and a ribbon that had been tied by someone who did it for a living.
"Oliver," Nadia said. "Obviously Oliver."
"Obviously nothing. He's sent four messages I haven't read. A man who can't get a reply doesn't spend sixty quid on roses."
"Men do exactly that, actually. That's practically the whole business model." Nadia picked up the delivery slip from where she'd propped it against the kettle and handed it over. "Anyway, it's not anonymous. It's got a name on the account."
Emily looked at the slip. The florist's logo, an order number, and then, in the small print under the delivery address — her address, the Southwark office, not the flat, which meant whoever sent them had done the sensible thing and looked up the firm rather than her home — a name.
Her thumb stopped on the paper.
Geoffrey Voss.
She read it twice.
"You've gone a funny colour," Nadia said. "Is that an Oliver colour or a different colour?"
"It's not Oliver." Emily set the slip down carefully, as if the paper itself were fragile. "Geoffrey Voss. He was the foundation's internal auditor. Nineteen ninety-eight to twenty nineteen. It's his signature on the audit certificates for the years we couldn't get past."
Nadia's face changed. The joking went out of it the way it went out of her when a case turned a corner. "The dead end. The one Priya couldn't trace."
"He retired in 2019. Nobody could find a phone number that worked, and the foundation's records just said 'resigned, personal reasons.'" Emily pulled her chair out and sat down. "I had him down as either dead or bought."
"Maybe he is bought. Maybe this is a message." Nadia nodded at the roses. "Twelve white ones. That's got a smell to it."
"It's a gesture." Emily turned it over in her hands — not the flowers, the fact. "He could have emailed. He could have rung the office. Instead he went to a florist and paid for a name to be printed on a docket that comes through a shop assistant to a receptionist to me." She looked up. "That's a man who wants me to be able to prove he made contact. And who wants whoever delivers his post to think he's sending flowers to a woman."
"Because he's frightened."
"Because he's watched." Emily was already getting up, files forgotten. "Get me Priya. Not on the office line. Her mobile."
It took Nadia four minutes and the price of a coffee next door, because Priya Raman's new office at the foundation had a switchboard and Priya had made it clear from her first week that some conversations were not going near the switchboard.
"Emily." Priya's voice was brisk, the voice of a woman who was discovering how much of a finance director's job was saying no to people who used to be friends. "It's Wednesday. The board agenda doesn't go out until—"
"I'm not calling about the agenda. Geoffrey Voss. Internal auditor. The name on the audit certificates for 2016 through 2019. I need everything the foundation has on him, and I need it in a way that doesn't leave a trail on your system."
There was a pause. Emily could hear Priya's chair creak.
"Why?"
"Because he just sent me flowers."
"That's a sentence I'm going to need unpacked."
"He sent flowers to the office with his name on the delivery slip. No note. Twelve white roses. He's the only person in the whole chain of that audit I have never been able to speak to, and he has just told me, in the only way he can be sure reaches me, that he's alive and that he knows I'm looking." Emily kept her voice level. "Priya, is there any route by which a retired employee's file gets flagged when someone asks about the audit?"
"Only if someone looks." Another pause. "Emily, I've been in the building three weeks. I don't know who's been phoning who. But there are three people on the old admin staff who never left, and one of them is the woman who keeps the personnel archive. She was Geoffrey's assistant in the late nineties."
"Does she like you?"
"She calls me 'the new girl,' so, slowly."
"Be nice to her."
"I'm always nice. I'm famously nice." Priya's tone turned. "What are you going to do?"
"Wait for the second move." Emily looked at the slip again. "He's given me his name. He hasn't given me a way back."
The second move came at ten past four, and it did not come through the florist.
It came through the post, in a brown envelope with a Bristol postmark, addressed by hand to Miss E. Hartwell, and it had been pushed through the letterbox along with two court listings and a leaflet about a tenants' meeting, so that Nadia nearly binned it.
Inside there was a single sheet of paper, typed, with a date at the top that was eleven days old.
Dear Miss Hartwell,
You do not know me. I know you. I have followed the case in the papers, and I read Mr Justice Whitlock's judgment in full, which I believe almost no one else has done.
I was the foundation's internal auditor from 1998 until I left in 2019. I signed the certificates for the years in question. I did not write the certificates for the years in question — that is to say, the figures that appear above my name in the published accounts for 2016, 2017 and 2018 do not reflect the draft audit report I prepared in each of those years. I raised this internally at the time, in writing, and I was told it would be dealt with. It was dealt with. I was retired early with a settlement and a confidentiality clause that a solicitor drew up and that I am advised is unenforceable against criminal disclosure, which is the only reason this letter exists.
I am eighty-one years old. I have cancer of the pancreas and the consultant has given me between four and eight months. I have no children and my wife died in 2021. There is no one left for me to protect, and I find, sitting in a flat in Bristol with a view of a car park, that I have less appetite for protecting a trust than I expected.
The envelope that came with the flowers contained a delivery slip. I instructed the florist to put my name on it. I did that so that you would know this letter came from a real person and not from someone's invented witness. You will understand that I did not put my own name on the envelope.
I am willing to make a statement concerning the drafting of the 2016 audit and the internal correspondence that followed. I would prefer to do it before a commissioner for oaths or a solicitor, and I would prefer it done properly, because I do not intend to be cross-examined by anyone after I am dead and I want what I say on the record in a form that survives me.
I remember your father. He came to us in 2017 about a client of his, a Mrs Achebe, whose bequest had been absorbed into general funds. He wrote to the trustees twice. I was instructed not to reply. I am sorry to tell you that the instructions came from a partner at Sable & Kerr.
If you wish to take my statement, I can travel to London on the eleventh or the twelfth. I do not wish to come to your office.
Yours sincerely,
G. Voss
Emily read it twice, and then a third time, sitting very still, while Nadia stood in the doorway with the leaflet in her hand and watched her face do things Nadia did not like.
"Sable and Kerr," Nadia said, when Emily finally put the letter down. "That's where he came from."
"No." Emily's voice was very quiet. "That's where the instructions came from. There's a difference, and the difference is the whole case." She turned the sheet over, as if there were more on the back, and there wasn't. "The eleventh."
"Emily, we're at sixty days on the donor scheme."
"Which will still be sixty days on the twelfth." Emily stood up and went to the window and looked down at the yard behind the offices, where a man was loading cardboard into a van. "He's eighty-one. He has four months, on his own account, which means God knows how long it actually is. He's going to stand up in a room and put his name on paper about an altered audit and a letter my father wrote and got no answer to, and then he's going to go home to Bristol and wait."
"You think he wants to be deposed before he dies."
"He wants it done before he can change his mind." Emily turned back. "Ring the set. Get me a witness room in Holborn. And Nadia —"
"Don't tell anyone."
"Don't tell anyone, don't put it in the diary under his name, and don't send anything to the foundation. Priya's on the inside but Priya's also on a new board that's already deferred one referral for legal advice, and if word gets back to Sable and Kerr's insurers before we have his signature on a page, that's the end of it."
Nadia nodded slowly. Then she looked at the flowers on the windowsill.
"What do I do with those?"
Emily looked at them for a moment — twelve white roses, no card, a name on a slip — and thought about a man in a flat in Bristol, writing out an address in his own hand and being careful not to put his name on the envelope.
"Water them," she said. "He went to trouble."