The Ethical Clause

Chapter 8: The Unsigned Audit

Geoffrey Voss ate lunch at a pub off Gray's Inn Road because it was convenient to the chambers he no longer practised from, and because, Emily suspected, nobody there knew who he was.

He was seventy-one and had the kind of posture that had once been described in a pupil's reference as commanding. It had softened into something more careful. He stood when she came in, which she hadn't expected, and shook her hand for slightly too long.

"You look like him," he said. "Round the eyes."

"I get that a lot this month."

They ordered. He had the pie. She had the soup and didn't eat much of it. For twenty minutes they talked about her father in the way people do when the dead person is the excuse for the meeting rather than the subject of it — the flat in Camberwell, the bicycle, the way he annotated case reports in green ink and then argued with his own annotations. Geoffrey told a story about a tribunal in 1998. Emily laughed in the right place. She was aware of the clock above the bar and the envelope in her bag, which she had decided not to take out unless she had to.

"You didn't ask me here to hear the bicycle story," Geoffrey said, setting down his fork.

"No."

"Your father and I had a falling out. You know that."

"I know you stopped speaking in 2017."

"March." He wiped his mouth. "He asked me to do something I wouldn't do, and I asked him to do something he wouldn't do, and neither of us was wrong, which is the worst kind."

Emily took the envelope out then and laid it flat between the salt and the napkin dispenser. Photocopies of the Ridgeway Solutions invoices, the signature block blacked out with marker where she'd redacted it, the dates and amounts left visible.

Geoffrey looked at them without touching them.

"Special purpose audit," he said. "2016."

"Say more."

"Orchard Foundation. They commissioned it through an intermediary firm so it wouldn't show on the main accounts as an audit at all — it was dressed as a 'programme review'. Six months of work. Your father led it." He picked up his glass and put it down again without drinking. "He got to the end and refused to sign."

"Why?"

"Because the numbers he was given didn't reconcile with the numbers he found, and when he raised it, the difference got explained to him in a way that made the difference disappear on paper but not in reality. That's the polite version."

"The impolite version."

"The impolite version is that a substantial sum had gone out of the foundation in the direction of a supplier that appeared to do very little, and the paper trail for that supplier ran through a holding arrangement that had his name on the engagement letter." He meant her father's name. "They wanted his signature to close it. He wouldn't give it. They found someone else who would."

Emily sat very still. The soup had gone cold and filmed over.

"What was the supplier called?"

"I don't know. He never told me that part. He told me enough to make me complicit and then refused to tell me the rest, which I have always thought was a cruelty dressed as a kindness."

"But you knew the audit existed. You knew it was 2016."

"I knew the shape of it." He looked at the invoices. "Where did you get these?"

"They were sent to me. Unsigned."

"By whom?"

"That's the question, isn't it."

Geoffrey was quiet for a moment. Then he said, "You should understand what you're standing in. The foundation settled your Ridgeway brief before it reached a barrister. That isn't a legal decision, Emily, it's a financial one. Somebody did the arithmetic on what your case would cost them in profile and paid to make it go away, and the payment would have been made at a level where a signature means something."

"Oliver Aldridge."

"Possibly. Or possibly the person who signs on Oliver Aldridge's behalf, which is a different animal and a much older one." He glanced at the door, not theatrically, just once. "The family has a general counsel who has been there since before Oliver was born. If you want to know where the decision came from, you ask who had the authority to settle without asking him."

Emily wrote nothing down, because writing things down in a pub with Geoffrey Voss made him look at the door twice. She memorised it instead: *settle without asking him.*

"Why won't you say more in here?" she asked.

"Because I'm seventy-one and I like my afternoons." It was a joke with no joke in it. He took the napkin from under his glass, borrowed her pen without asking, and wrote an address in small block capitals. A street in Bermondsey, a number, no name.

"What's there?"

"Your father kept a duplicate set. Not the audit itself — he wasn't that stupid — but the correspondence around it. He asked me to hold it. I wouldn't, so he found somewhere else. Somewhere with a landlord who doesn't ask." He pushed the napkin across. "That's the last I know. The flat's been empty since 2019 but nobody's cleared it, which tells you something about who owns it."

"And if I go?"

"Then you go. Don't call me again, Emily. Not from your mobile, not from the office. If you find something, you find it, and I'll read about it in the paper like everybody else and be very surprised."

He said it lightly. His hands were not light. He folded his napkin, set it on the plate, and began the slow business of getting his coat on, and Emily understood that the lunch was over and that whatever he had done to earn this caution had been done a long time ago and was still costing him.

"One more thing," she said. "The auditor who signed instead. Who was it?"

Geoffrey paused with one arm in his sleeve.

"A firm," he said. "Not a person. And I'd be careful how you ask, because a firm doesn't have a memory and it doesn't have a conscience and it will bill you for the time it takes to say so."

At the door he shook her hand again, the same too-long grip, and said, "He was the most honest man I ever worked with and it ruined him. I've never decided whether that's a compliment." Then he was out on the pavement, walking east with his collar up, not looking back, and Emily sat down again with the cold soup and the napkin and the photographs of the invoices.

She turned the napkin over. On the back, in the same block capitals, he had written a date: *14.03.17*. Three days after the falling out. Her father had been dead eighteen months. She had never once, in all that time, known there was correspondence.

Her phone buzzed against the table.

*Tomorrow 7pm confirmed. I'll send the address in the morning.*

No name. She texted back: *Who is this?*

The reply took four minutes.

*You'll want to bring the invoices.*

She stared at the screen until it dimmed. Then she opened her notes app under the table like a teenager and typed the Bermondsey address, the date, and the two sentences Geoffrey had given her, the two that mattered:

*Settled without asking him.*

*A firm signed instead, not a person.*

When she looked up, the barman was clearing Geoffrey's plate. On it, folded neatly under the fork where the napkin had been, was a second piece of paper she hadn't seen him leave — torn from the corner of the pub's menu, with one line in the same small capitals.

*Ask Marsh about the March 2017 meeting. Not the brief. The meeting.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 8: The Unsigned Audit · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads