The Ethical Clause

Chapter 82: The Phone Call

The call came at ten past eleven, when Emily was on her kitchen floor with the Marsh application spread around her in four piles and a mug of tea gone cold at her elbow.

Unknown number. Peckham prefix.

She had spent the afternoon in Priya's office being asked, pleasantly and precisely, whether her half-rate fee arrangement ought to be disclosed to the board as a relationship rather than a transaction, and had answered that it ought, and had watched Priya write "volunteered by adviser" in the margin in green ink. Then she had gone back to the office and told Nadia herself, before Priya could, and Nadia had said, "I know. I worked it out in April," and gone back to redrafting the witness bundle without looking up, which was somehow worse.

She answered the phone because unknown numbers in Peckham were usually clients.

"Emily." A pause. Traffic behind him, the wet swish of tyres. "It's Oliver."

She sat up against the radiator. The flat was cold; she hadn't put the heating on.

"Where are you?"

"Peckham. By the station. There's a phone box outside the barber's that still takes coins, which I've discovered is quite a commitment to a bit." A breath, almost a laugh, and then not one. "I'm not asking you for anything."

"I didn't say you were."

"I know. I'm saying it first, because everything I've said to you for eight months has been a request of some kind, and I'd like one conversation where it isn't."

She looked at the piles on the floor. Marsh's claim, four hundred and twelve pages. Voss's deposition, twelve. The stay application, listed for Thursday.

"All right," she said. "Then talk."

He was quiet long enough that she heard a bus go past, the hydraulic wheeze of it.

"I've been at the Fairview Centre since the freezing order," he said. "The one in March. Fourteen weeks now. Saturdays, mostly, and Wednesdays when they'll have me. I peel potatoes. I do the washing up. I carry things for Mrs Achebe because she won't let anyone else carry the flour and she won't carry it herself."

"Eleven weeks," Emily said. "You told me eleven."

"Eleven Saturdays. Fourteen weeks. I started on the Wednesday, three days after the injunction came down, and I've never told anyone there who I am. There's a woman called Bridget who thinks I'm in insurance. I've let her think it. She asked me to look at her boiler once and I said I didn't know anything about boilers and she said, 'Well, you're in insurance, aren't you,' and I said yes."

"Why are you telling me?"

"Because you've seen me there. Because you'll find out anyway, and I'd rather it came from me standing in a phone box in the rain than from a journalist."

"You could have used your mobile."

"I threw it in the canal."

She did not say anything to that.

"Not literally. I gave it to Sarah and asked her to keep it in a drawer until Monday. I wanted to be somewhere nobody could reach me. It's a very expensive way to prove a point, phone boxes. Eighty pence and it keeps eating it." The sound of coins. "Emily, the reason I've kept going back isn't the photographs. There haven't been photographs. Nobody at that centre has any idea and nobody there wants anything from me. Bridget doesn't want me to be a patron. Mrs Achebe doesn't want me to be my father's son, or not his son, or reformed, or unforgiven. She wants the flour carried to the back kitchen. That's the whole of it. It is the only place in London where nobody wants me to be someone else."

She stood up. Walked to the window. The street below was empty except for a fox working a bin bag with real determination.

"I know," she said.

"You don't have to say that."

"I do know. I watched you for forty minutes through the serving hatch before I came round. You were doing the tureens and your hands were going red and you didn't once look at the door." She pressed her forehead against the glass. "I've been a lawyer for eleven years. I know what someone looks like when they're working for the room and when they're working for the room's opinion of them. You were doing the tureens."

Another silence. The coins went again.

"I opened it," she said. "The fourth message. This morning, before the committee meeting."

"Ah."

"It said, 'I'll be in the kitchen on Saturday either way.'"

"That's right."

"Were you going to say anything about why?"

"No."

"Why not?"

"Because if I'd explained it to you, then it becomes something I'm doing to be seen doing it. And the point — the entire point — is that it isn't." He took a breath. "My father's lawyers asked me in June to list my charitable activities for the purposes of the probate correspondence. I gave them eleven weeks of a kitchen rota and they wrote back asking me to confirm there had been no error, because they couldn't find a single press release."

Emily laughed, once, badly.

"Emily, the defamation claim. Marsh."

"I'm aware of it."

"She's named you personally and she's named Nadia. She's asking the court to stay the foundation engagement on conflict grounds, and she's put in a fourteen-page witness statement about your fee. Priya's told me. Priya's furious, but not at you. She says the wording of the application suggests someone on the committee gave Marsh the Voss timeline."

"I know that too."

"Do you know who?"

"Not yet."

"It was my aunt. Susan. She sits on the fundraising committee and she has lunch with Marsh's sister at least twice a month, and she asked me in April whether I thought you were 'suitable,' and I said I did, and I should have known what she meant by asking." He stopped. "I'm telling you because you'd find out on discovery in six weeks and lose the time. Not because it gets me anything."

"I believe you."

"Then that's — " The line clicked. "That's two minutes. I've got sixty pence."

"Oliver."

"Yes."

"When you said you weren't asking for anything. That was true, and I'm answering it anyway. You should come on Sunday as well. They do a roast and they're short."

"I can't. Priya would have to know, and then the committee would have to know, and the moment they know, someone photographs it, and then Bridget knows I'm not in insurance, and the kitchen stops being the one place." A pause. "That's the whole problem with my name. I can't give it away. I can only keep it out of the room."

"Then keep it out of the room," Emily said. "Sunday's not a shift. Sunday's just lunch. Nobody's counting on Sunday."

The line clicked again. Three pence, two pence.

"Emily — Marsh filed at nine this morning because someone told her Voss agreed to talk on Thursday. Only four people knew on Thursday. You, Nadia, Voss, and me. I haven't said it to anyone. I'm not asking you to trust that. I'm just putting it in the record."

"I've already put it in the record," she said. "Nadia's had it since Monday."

"Good," he said. "Good."

The phone went dead.

She stood at the window for a while with the handset of her own phone still in her hand and the fox gone and the piles of Marsh's application behind her on the floor, and then she did what she always did, which was work.

She wrote, in the notes app, with the flat dark and the radiator ticking:

(1) Susan Aldridge — lunch with Marsh's sister — check committee minutes for April.

(2) Voss email bounced twice. Needs a working address. He has a daughter in Croydon. Alastair Carter delivered for a supermarket in Croydon. One journey, two purposes.

(3) Sunday. Fairview. Non-rota. Ask Nadia to come too. Ask nobody else.

She stopped. Read it back. Added a fourth line and did not delete it:

(4) The only reason Aldridge portraits left the lobby is because I forced it. Marsh is going to argue I am the conflict. She is going to argue a lawyer with a personal history of fighting this family cannot advise a board that has just removed it. She will put my father in the papers by Friday.

On Thursday the stay application was listed. On Thursday, Marsh would have to stand up in front of a judge and explain, on the record, why the names on the 2016 qualification had been altered.

Which meant that on Thursday, the altered opinion would either be in evidence — or it would be gone.

She rang Voss's number. It rang out. She rang the daughter in Croydon, whose number Nadia had found on a 2019 probate filing, and got a voicemail, and left four words.

"It's Emily Hartwell. Thursday."

Then she sat down on the kitchen floor among the four piles, in the cold, and began to read Marsh's application from page one, looking for what she was going to have to do.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 82: The Phone Call · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads