Her office smelled like toner and cold coffee. Sophie sat in the dark with the blinds open, downtown Montreal glittering on the other side of the glass, and replayed the last ninety seconds of her evening like a litigator reviewing a hostile witness.
*Go home. We're on opposite sides.*
The way he'd said it—flat, done, no heat in it. Not angry. Worse than angry. He'd already made the decision by the time he spoke, and the decision had nothing to do with the protocol or the committee or Marisol Vaz's Friday release. He'd opened that envelope alone, in his apartment, and whatever he'd seen in it had moved him onto ground where she couldn't stand.
A photograph of his own kitchen. Rue Boyer. What was he, twelve? Ten? There would have been dishes in the sink, a table they ate at. And his mother absent—not absent because she was in the other room, absent in a way that the frame itself had arranged, a gap in the room that only a son would notice.
He'd noticed. Of course he'd noticed. That was the part that kept turning over in her chest.
Sophie reached for her phone. Not to call him—she deleted his thread without opening it, a small ceremony, no witness—and dialed Linh instead.
It rang four times. Then: "Sophie?" Linh sounded far away, or underwater, or possibly asleep. "What time is it."
"Late. I know. I'm sorry."
A rustle of sheets on the other end. "Is this about Friday?"
"Partly." Sophie got up and closed the blinds, as if someone on Sherbrooke could see her. "I need to ask you something and I need you to answer it straight, without deciding first whether I'll like it."
"Those are never good sentences."
"Did Anh ever talk about anyone named Henri Vachon?"
The line went quiet. Not a pause—a silence with weight to it, the kind Sophie heard in conference rooms before a witness decided which version of events to hand over.
"Linh."
"She said." Linh stopped. Started again. "She said there was a man with money. Rich. The kind of rich where you don't even argue, you just understand the rules. That's what she said—*you just understand the rules.* She never gave me a name."
"Was she afraid of him?"
Another silence. Shorter, but deeper.
"She was afraid of him," Linh said. "Yes."
"Did she say why? Anything specific—a building, a lawyer, a phone call?"
"She said he came to an opening she was working. Back—" A rustle, Linh sitting up. "Back before she got sick. He looked at her like he already knew her. That's the phrase she used, Sophie. *Like he already knew her.* She said it twice. It stuck with me because Anh didn't say things twice."
Sophie sat down again. On the desk under her hand: a yellow sticky note pad, half-used, the corner curled. She pulled one free and wrote, in block capitals, VACHON.
"What did she mean by that?" she asked. "That he knew her."
"I asked her. She said it didn't matter, it was a long time ago, and she wasn't going to be the one who opened it." Linh's voice had gone careful, picking its way. "Sophie. Why are you asking this now?"
"Because the photograph in that envelope is of the Vachon family kitchen. Anh kept it. She sealed it. And Gabriel—" She stopped, because there were three ways to finish the sentence and none of them belonged to Linh.
"Gabriel what."
"Gabriel knew what it was before he opened it. Or he guessed." Sophie pressed the sticky note flat against the edge of her monitor, where it stuck and stayed. "He won't show it to me."
"Then how do you know what's in it?"
"He told me." A beat. "Mostly."
Linh was quiet for a long time—long enough that Sophie heard her exhale, slow and deliberate, the sound of someone deciding to keep going anyway.
"I gave him the key to that drawer," Linh said. "Three years ago. Because the work needed a home and I couldn't afford one. I told him the sealed things were sealed. I told him that in *those* words."
"I know."
"But if the thing inside is about him—" Linh stopped. "Doesn't that make it his?"
"Maybe. Legally? No. Ethically?" Sophie looked at the sticky note. VACHON, in caps, three inches of yellow on a black monitor. "That's the question, isn't it."
"I need to go back to sleep," Linh said, and she sounded like she meant *I need to stop having this conversation.* "Tell me before you do anything with my name on it."
"I will."
Sophie set the phone face down. The office hummed its late-night hum—ventilation, the photocopier in sleep mode, the humped shadow of the Devereux file on the credenza where she'd left it, incidentals tucked inside the loan agreement, signed protocol paper-clipped to the back like an afterthought.
Anh Nguyễn. Died of what, exactly? Sophie didn't know. The foundation's programming notes said only *in memoriam* and a date. A curator with no institutional home, who told a friend about a rich man who looked at her like he already knew her, and then kept a photograph of that man's family kitchen in a sealed envelope for years and told no one why.
Or told exactly one person, badly, and let the rest burn off.
Sophie opened her laptop. She didn't run a search—not yet, not at midnight, not on a hunch with her name at the bottom of a conflict-of-interest memo—but she opened it, and she typed *Henri Vachon Montréal* into the browser bar and didn't press enter. The cursor blinking. Forty-two years old and still doing this: writing VACHON on a sticky note, leaving the other thing unasked until morning, because that was how you didn't get disbarred.
She looked at the note for a while.
The thing about being a divorce lawyer, the thing nobody said out loud, was that you learned to see the shape of the truth before you could prove it. Separations were rooms with furniture in them: you walked in, and if the couch was against the wrong wall, you knew before anyone spoke. Sophie had known since the gallery that Henri Vachon was in that room. She'd known when he'd walked past her without seeing her, a man so practiced at omission that a stranger in his son's doorway was simply not there. She'd known when Gabriel said *only money, which is enough.*
And now Linh had just put a body on the other side of the couch: Anh Nguyễn, afraid of a rich man who looked at her like he already knew her.
Sophie picked up her pen and wrote on a second sticky note, smaller, and stuck it under the first. *Ask Linh: opening. which opening. date.* Then, below that: *Gabriel — his mother.*
She sat with that one longer than she wanted to. The empty chair. The kitchen on rue Boyer. There was a story in that frame that Gabriel had spent twenty years not telling, and she had just been handed the corner of it by a dead woman, secondhand, through a friend who'd gone quiet on the phone.
She should give it back. That was the professional answer. That was the answer that kept her calendar full and her name clean and her heart exactly where she'd left it, in the drawer with everything else that didn't bill.
Instead she looked at the monitor.
VACHON. She didn't take it down. She let it sit there, the yellow square catching the glow of the screen, visible from the hallway if anyone walked past, visible to her every time she sat down for the next however-many weeks it took. A name on a sticky note was not evidence. A name on a sticky note was not a conflict. A name on a sticky note was just a word she'd written down while a friend told her a dead woman had once been scared.
Sophie saved her draft, closed the laptop, and stood a minute in the dark with her hand on the back of the chair.
Thursday, he'd said. *After I talk to him.*
Tomorrow was Wednesday. Which meant Gabriel Vachon had about thirty hours before he sat down across from his father, and Sophie had about thirty hours to decide what she was going to do with three inches of yellow stuck to the edge of her screen—whether she was a lawyer who'd been lied to, or the only person who'd noticed, or something worse: a woman who wanted to keep her hand exactly where it was on the back of the chair, in an office that smelled like toner, in a city where a man she'd known for two weeks had already told her there was no side of this she could stand on with him.
She took her coat off the hook. She left the note where it was.