The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 15: Claire's Dinner

Claire Marchand lived on Avenue Querbes in a duplex she'd bought in 1989 for less than the price of a sedan, a fact she mentioned roughly once a year with a satisfaction that never dulled. The front door smelled of rosemary and the wax her mother used on the banister. Sophie arrived at five past six.

"You're late," Claire said, kissing both cheeks and holding Sophie's face a half-second longer than the kiss required. "I said six."

"I'm not late."

"You're five minutes late, which is your father's exact disease."

Sophie hung her coat. On the hall table, between the mirror and a bowl of keys, sat a pile of gallery invitations and postcards, edges fanned like a bad hand of cards. Sophie had walked past that table a hundred times. She looked at it now the way you look at a light switch after the power goes out.

The table was set for three.

"Who else is coming?"

"No one. I put out three because the soup bowls look better in threes." Claire walked back toward the kitchen. "Sit. Pour the wine, it's open."

The apartment smelled of onion and thyme and underneath it, faintly, the ghost of cigarettes Claire had quit fourteen years ago and still missed, Sophie suspected, the way people miss an old country.

Sophie poured. The dining room wall held the same three pieces it had held for a decade — a Leduc, a small ink drawing of a horse by no one famous, and a photograph of a snow-covered lane in Outremont, black and white, taken the winter before Sophie was born.

"So," Claire said, setting down the soup tureen. "How is work."

"Busy."

"Busy how."

Sophie told her about a custody hearing, the father who'd filed for sole custody after his ex-wife took up with a man who owned three motorcycles. It was a good story because it was true and because it had an end. Claire listened with the courteous attention of a woman who had spent forty years as a nurse and knew how to let a person talk until they got to the point.

"The judge gave her the motorcycles," Sophie said. "Everyone was happy except the father."

"And you?"

"I got paid."

Claire ladled soup. "That's not what I asked."

They ate. The soup was squash and apple, sweeter than it should have been.

"Yvette called me," Claire said. "From the bridge club."

Here it came. Sophie kept eating.

"She said she saw you at that gallery on Saint-Laurent. Twice."

"Once, actually. Twice is Yvette's version."

"With a young man."

"With a colleague." Sophie reached for the bread. "There's a deadline. There's a lot of talking."

"Yvette said he has a beard."

"You've never met a man whose beard was relevant."

Claire's mouth did something that wasn't quite a smile. "I'm eighty-one. I have exactly two topics left and you are both of them." She tore a piece of crust. "Is he kind?"

"Mother."

"It's the only question I have. Not rich, not handsome, not your age. Kind."

Sophie put down the bread. The temptation, always, was to give a true answer that functioned like a false one. *He opened a sealed envelope he had no right to open. He told me to go home.* "He's honest in a way that's inconvenient for both of us."

Claire considered this. "Your father was honest in a way that was inconvenient for me. It was the only thing about him I ever admired."

That was a fold in the conversation Sophie didn't want to open. She stood and collected the bowls. In the kitchen, drying her hands on the dish towel, she noticed the stack of mail her mother had put by the phone — hydro, a pharmacy receipt, and under them a square card, stiff, cream-colored, with a photograph on the front: a woman's hands in a sink of dark water.

Sophie turned it over.

*Galerie Bélanger-Lévesque — Vernissage, Thursday the 14th, 18h00. Textes de Denyse Lévesque, photographies de Gabriel Vachon.*

"Thursday the fourteenth," Sophie said, and her voice came out level, which pleased her. "You went."

"I go to everything on this street," Claire said from the doorway. "Odette from the choir has a nephew who shows there. And the wine is free."

"Gabriel Vachon."

"Mm." Claire took the card from Sophie and looked at it the way she looked at everything, as if it were a bill she intended to pay. "The young photographer. Charming. He showed me the picture of the woman at the sink and said something about how he'd photographed the same hands for six years and still didn't know what they were doing. I liked that." She set the card down. "He photographed Odette's nephew's show too. He was very nice to an old woman who asked stupid questions."

Sophie's thumb had gone cold against the dish towel.

"How nice."

"Nice the way you are with clients," Claire said. "Interested and in a hurry."

Sophie understood then — the third bowl, the *kind* question, Yvette's bridge-club reconnaissance — that her mother had been circling this exhibit for weeks, in her own slow orbit, not because she cared about the art but because she had, in one evening at a vernissage, put her hand on the exact surface her daughter had been guarding. Claire had no idea. That was the worst part. Claire had liked him. Claire had liked him genuinely, the way she liked pastry or good weather, and had kept the card, and had set three bowls on the table because she liked the way three bowls looked, and now Sophie was standing in her mother's kitchen doing arithmetic she couldn't finish.

"Are you all right?"

"Fine. Long week."

"You're gray."

"I'm forty-two. I'm gray."

"You don't have to be here if you're tired." Claire's voice had shifted, the nurse in it surfacing, ready with a hand on Sophie's forehead. "I didn't ask you to come and then spring Yvette at you. Tell her to keep her bridge club to herself."

"It's fine. Truly." Sophie picked up her coat. "I have pages due tomorrow. The deadline I told you about."

Claire didn't argue. She never argued; she simply stood in the hall and watched Sophie put on her coat, and the watching was worse than any argument.

"Saturday," Claire said. "Six o'clock. I'm making the lamb and if you're late again I'm giving your portion to Yvette."

"I'll be here."

"Are you sure you don't want to take the soup? There's a jar."

"I don't want the soup."

Claire held the door open. Outside, the street was dark and wet with the cold rain that had been threatening all afternoon, and halfway down the block a car went through a puddle and the sound came up the row of houses like applause.

Sophie sat in the car without starting it for a long time. The card was still in her head, in her mother's handwriting now, because Claire had written *Thursday 14 — 18h, came home by 20h30* across the corner in the fine blue pen she used for everything, and Sophie could see it: Claire in her good coat, holding a plastic cup of bad white wine, talking to Gabriel Vachon, being charming right back, telling him about the daughter in family law — because of course she'd told him, Claire told everyone — and Gabriel, who never mentioned it, because he had known from the vernissage that the woman across from him at the gallery was Claire Marchand's daughter, and he had never once said so.

Her phone sat in the cup holder. She looked at it the way you look at a door you don't want to open.

Claire's lights went off upstairs, then on in the kitchen, then off.

Sophie drove home along Bernard, past the shuttered fruit store and the restaurant with the yellow awning where she'd eaten dinner alone four times in the last year, and she did not think about Saturday, at six, lamb, her mother's chairs, and no third bowl.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 15: Claire's Dinner · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads