The rooftop was six floors above the gallery, a gravel-and-cedar deck with a string of bulbs someone had strung between two vents and a barbecue that had clearly been rescued from a dumpster. Sophie counted eleven people, most of them under thirty-five, most of them holding beers, all of them turning to look when Gabriel pushed the door open and she stepped out behind him.
"Hey," he said. "This is Sophie."
A woman with silver hair in a blunt crop — the ceramicist from the second floor — raised her bottle. "The lawyer?"
"Friend," Gabriel said.
The word landed flat. Sophie felt it land and kept walking, took the beer he handed her, and found a spot by the railing where she could see the mountain and not have to smile.
He'd said *friend*. Fine. That was fine. That was, in fact, precisely the correct word for what they were — two people on opposite sides of a contract negotiation who had once eaten dumplings in a kitchen at midnight and once stood too close in a stairwell. Friend. Sure.
She drank.
The barbecue was good. Someone had marinated the chicken in something with lemon and too much garlic, and a boy who couldn't have been twenty-four was telling a long story about a residency in Berlin, and the city was going purple over the roofs and Sophie was, for eleven minutes, almost relaxed.
Then the ceramicist sat down next to her with a plate. "So how do you two know each other? Because he never brings anyone."
"We're working on a project."
"The family thing. The exhibition." She nodded. "He's been weird about it. Weirder than usual."
Sophie looked across the deck at Gabriel, who was turning chicken with tongs, laughing at something. He looked easy. He looked like a man who had never in his life refused to show someone a photograph.
"He's been tense," Sophie said carefully.
"He gets like this before a thing opens. And there's something with his father."
Sophie's hand tightened on the bottle. "His father."
"Henri. He came by the studio last month, actually, looking for Gabe. Very"—the ceramicist made a face—"very expensive coat."
"Did he say what he wanted?"
"Not to me." She shrugged and stood. "Anyway. You should come by the studio sometime. I'll show you the kiln."
Sophie said she would. She finished her beer. She counted to sixty and then walked over to Gabriel, who was holding a spatula like a man who had never been told to go home.
"I'm going to head out," she said, loud enough for the group.
"I'll walk you down."
"You don't have to."
He set the spatula down.
The stairwell was concrete and echoed. Six flights of it, and after the first landing neither of them had said anything, and Sophie could hear her own heels and his sneakers and the hum of the ventilation shaft.
"So," she said. "Friend."
Gabriel didn't break stride. "Would you have preferred something else?"
"Preferred isn't the word. Accurate is the word."
"Accurate for a barbecue with people I work with." He hit the door bar at the fourth floor, and they stepped onto the landing. "You think I should have told them you're my opponent?"
"I think you should have told them something true."
"I did."
Sophie stopped. The landing smelled of paint and old cigarettes. She turned and looked at him, and he looked back, and for a second neither of them said anything, and the ventilation shaft hummed.
"You told me to go home," she said. "You told me we were on opposite sides. You wouldn't show me the photograph. You won't tell me what happened on Thursday. And then you invite me to a barbecue and call me your friend like it's a demotion."
"It's not a demotion."
"Then what is it?"
Gabriel exhaled and pressed both hands back through his hair. "It's the only word that's mine to say."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the answer I have." He stepped closer. "Sophie. I can't tell a rooftop of people that you're my lawyer—"
"I *am* your lawyer. Sort of. That's what the protocol is."
"—and I can't tell them you're my—" He stopped.
"Your what."
"You know."
"No," she said. "I don't. That's the whole problem. I've spent three weeks trying to figure out whether I'm your counsel, your enemy, or your—something else. And every time I get close, you close the door. You close it, and then the next morning you're outside my office with coffee, and I don't know what I'm supposed to do with that."
"Nothing," he said. "You're not supposed to do anything with it."
"That's not how people work."
"It's how I work."
Sophie laughed, once, without humor. "Then your exhibition is going to be a lie."
Gabriel's face changed. It went very still, the way it went still in the gallery when she'd put the property pages on the table.
"That's not fair."
"Nothing about this is fair." She stepped toward the door. "You told me Anh took a picture of your family's kitchen. You told me your mother had already moved out. And you still won't show me the print. You've been sitting on it for a week and you won't—"
"Because it's not about your protocol," he said, and his voice had risen. "It was never about your protocol. It's about my father. It's about a chair in a kitchen I stood in when I was nine years old, and if I hand it to you then it goes on a wall and Henri sees it and everything—"
"Everything *what*?"
"Everything I've spent twenty years keeping airtight."
The echo of his own voice caught up with him. He stopped. He looked at the door, then at her.
Sophie said, quietly, "Then don't give it to me as a lawyer. Give it to me as a friend."
He looked at her for a long moment.
And then he kissed her.
It wasn't the stairwell by the gallery, and it wasn't a kitchen at midnight. It was landing four, with the ventilation hum and the smell of paint, and his hands came up and framed her jaw, and Sophie — forty-two years old, four hours of billable work still waiting in her bag — kissed him back.
For about four seconds.
Then she put both hands on his chest and pushed.
"No," she said.
"Sophie—"
"No." She wiped her mouth with the back of her wrist, which she regretted immediately, because it looked like disgust and it wasn't. "You don't get to do that. You don't get to tell me to go home, refuse to show me the thing I need, call me your *friend* in front of your friends — and then kiss me on a stairwell and have that be the resolution."
"I wasn't trying to resolve anything."
"You were trying to shut me up."
Gabriel's hands dropped. He didn't deny it.
Sophie heard herself breathing. "I have a vote on Friday. I have a client co-signing a refusal in writing. I have a mother who knows your circle better than I do. And I have you, standing in front of me, holding a photograph of your own father's kitchen like it's a hostage." She pulled the door open with one hand. "Figure out what I am. Then call me."
She took the stairs down fast, heels ringing, all the way to ground level, and she didn't look back.
At street level her phone buzzed. Claire: *Six o'clock Saturday. Don't be late. I've invited the young photographer.*
Sophie read it twice and put the phone in her pocket and stood on the sidewalk for a minute, because the car was her mother's and the keys were somewhere in the bottom of her bag, and because on the fourth-floor landing she had heard Gabriel say her name like a question — and had left anyway.
Then the gallery's side door opened behind her.
Gabriel stepped out. He wasn't looking at her; he was looking at his phone, scrolling, his jaw set. He hadn't seen her yet. He had a folder under his arm — the marbled gray one she recognized, the one with the Van Hoorn pages, the one she had watched him put in the locked drawer for a week.
He was walking, fast, toward a car idling at the curb.
And getting out of the back seat to meet him, in an overcoat that cost more than her laptop, was Henri Vachon.