The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 32: Disclosure

The elevator doors closed on the ninth floor and Sophie let herself breathe for the first time since the kitchen. Gabriel’s recording sat in her phone like a live coal. Eleven minutes. His voice clear on it, Henri’s, the clink of a glass, the boast about making the Bélanger family fold. She had listened to it twice in the parking garage and once more at a red light on Sherbrooke. It was not ambiguous and it was not going to disappear.

Julie’s office door was open. Through the glass, Sophie saw Bélanger in the chair across from the desk, his back to the hallway, his shoulders square. Julie was mid-sentence, and when she saw Sophie she stopped.

“Two minutes,” Sophie said from the doorway. Her voice came out steadier than she expected.

Julie rolled her wrist toward the clock. “Nine was an hour ago. This is the conversation I told you you didn’t want to have, Sophie.”

“I need the room, and I need it closed.”

Bélanger turned. He was a large man, sixty-one, with the specific pallor of someone who has not slept and is choosing to be angry about it. “You promised me a strategy. For three weeks every meeting has ended in a new problem. Now you want the door closed.”

“Yes.” Sophie came in and shut it herself.

She sat. She set her phone on the desk, face down, and left her hand on top of it.

“I met with Henri Vachon,” she said.

Julie’s face didn’t move. She had known, or half-known; she had given the ultimatum.

“I told him nothing,” Sophie said. “He talked. Before that, my client’s son gave me what he had. Last night he gave me this.” She lifted her hand from the phone. “Eleven minutes. Henri says the exhibition is designed to make the Bélanger family fold. His words. He says the photograph of the opening is the pressure point. And he tells my client’s son that the gallery’s operating funding depends on his loyalty.”

Bélanger was very still. Then he said, “Play it.”

Sophie played it.

Henri’s voice, magnified by the small speaker, filled the room with the particular intimacy of someone who does not believe he is being recorded. *They’ll fold, and they should fold. The photograph was never about art. You know that. I know that. It’s about the little temple of self-regard they’ve built…* A pause. A laugh. *Your gallery runs on my money until March, Gabriel. Don’t make me ask myself whether you’re mine.*

Julie’s pen had stopped moving. She had not, Sophie noticed, written anything down at all.

When the recording ended, Bélanger put both hands on his knees and looked at the floor. He looked, for a moment, like a man doing arithmetic he had avoided for twenty years.

“So,” he said. “It’s not a mistake. It’s not a misunderstanding. It’s a plan.”

“It’s a plan,” Sophie said. “And it’s evidence.”

“Evidence of what?” Julie said. “He’s a man being ugly to his son in a room. Nothing in that recording says he touched your client’s livelihood.”

“He names the family. He names the exhibit’s purpose. He ties funding to silence.” Sophie kept her voice level. “In a custody file, Julie, that’s a motive. In a defamation claim it’s closer to a confession. I don’t need you to like it. I need to preserve it and log it.”

“It’s hearsay,” Julie said, standing now, walking to the window and back. “You have a client who intends to destroy a photograph he didn’t take, who has lied about the circumstances of its making, whose son has already lied to you once, and your plan is to put a phone on the table and call that a case.”

“I called it evidence,” Sophie said. “Not a case. Yet.” She looked at her client. “Monsieur Bélanger. I need you to hear one thing before you decide anything. If you destroy the photograph now, it isn’t a bad decision you regret. It’s an admission, and Henri has been waiting for you to make it since before I met you. He wants you to destroy it. He told my client’s son the photo was the pressure point because he knows what kind of man you are when you’re cornered.”

Bélanger’s jaw worked. “That’s a fine thing to say to a client.”

“I’m not flattering you. I’m telling you what the other side is counting on.”

He sat with it. The clock on the wall ticked into the silence. Then, unexpectedly, his shoulders dropped, and he let out a breath that had the shape of a laugh without the sound. “God. You know, Ms. Marchand, I’ve been sleeping four hours a night waiting for someone to tell me this is survivable. That—” He waved at the phone. “That is more than I’ve had from anyone in a month.”

“Then here’s what we do,” Sophie said. “You do not touch the photograph. It stays where it is. We file a preservation notice and we log the recording with a timestamp and a hash, today. If Henri so much as glances at that print, the record shows we documented the threat first. Whatever happens to the exhibition after that is his problem, not yours.”

“And the exhibition?”

“Runs,” she said. “You attend it. You say nothing. You let people wonder why you’re not embarrassed.”

Bélanger looked at her for a long beat, then at Julie. “She’s good,” he said, and it wasn’t a compliment to Julie, exactly. He stood, gathered his coat, and at the door turned back. “I don’t care what it costs. Preserve it. Log it. Do whatever it is you people do.”

The door closed behind him.

Julie waited until his footsteps reached the elevator, then turned on Sophie with something closer to fatigue than anger. “You’ve boxed us both.”

“I’ve boxed him. That was the job.”

“No.” Julie came around the desk and stood directly in front of her, close enough that Sophie could smell the coffee she had reheated three times. “You’ve boxed *me*. Because now I know about the recording, and I have to account for it, and the only version of the story where this doesn’t sink us is the one where you disclosed it the moment you had it. Which is what I told you to do this morning, and when I told you, you were already in the car driving somewhere that wasn’t here.”

“I was going to the gallery.”

“I know.” Julie’s voice went quiet. “That’s the part that worries me. Not the evidence. Not Bélanger. The part where my best associate hears a recording that could end a man’s case and her first instinct is to go find the curator.”

Sophie said nothing. There was no version of the truth that helped.

“Henri Vachon is going to know within forty-eight hours,” Julie said. “He’ll know the recording exists, he’ll know who produced it, and he’ll know who took it. You have a client with a nine-figure business and a man who has spent a very long time arranging this room so that every exit is his exit. When this goes badly—and it is going to go badly, because he doesn’t know another way to go—it isn’t going to land on Raphaël Bélanger. It’s going to land on you.”

“I know,” Sophie said.

“Do you? Because your face says you’ve made a decision about something, and I want to hear you say it out loud before you leave this office.”

Sophie picked up her phone. The recording sat in its folder, timestamped, already copied to the firm’s secure drive from her car. She looked at the screen, then at Julie.

“I know he’ll retaliate,” she said. “I’m counting on it.”

Julie’s expression flickered—surprise, then the beginning of respect, then the sharper thing underneath it. “That’s not strategy. That’s a dare.”

“It’s both,” Sophie said, and stood to go.

Her phone buzzed against her palm before she reached the door. She looked down. An unknown Montreal number, no name, no voicemail. It had already called twice while the door was shut.

Julie saw her face. “Who is it?”

Sophie unlocked the screen. On the other side of the glass, the office had gone quiet, the way rooms go quiet when everyone inside them understands that something has just started. She held the phone up so Julie could see the number.

“I don’t know yet,” she said. “But I’d bet the exhibition it isn’t a wrong number.”

The phone rang a third time.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 32: Disclosure · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads