The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 34: The Bar Complaint

The Barre du Barreau occupied the fourth floor of a limestone building on Notre-Dame, and Sophie had been inside it exactly twice in eighteen years of practice: once to be sworn in, once to watch a colleague get disbarred. Both times she'd thought the same thing — the carpet was too new for what happened on it.

She signed in at 9:12. The receptionist gave her a form and a pen attached to a steel coil, the kind of pen that told you the institution didn't trust anyone, which she respected.

"Section four," the receptionist said. "You're filing against counsel?"

"Against counsel's conduct."

"Same desk."

The form wanted dates, names, exhibit numbers. She had them. She had the recording of Henri on the phone offering her a partnership track at a firm he happened to influence, in exchange for losing a piece of evidence. She had typed the transcript herself at her kitchen table with the lights off, because reading the words on the page was easier than hearing his voice again. She had attached it as Exhibit C.

She wrote slowly, printing where the boxes were small. When she got to the section asking whether she had disclosed the conduct to the client, she wrote *yes, verbally, not yet in writing,* and then sat back and looked at that answer for a while, because it was the second lie of omission on the page and she wasn't sure the first one had been a lie at all.

The first one being: she hadn't told the Barre she was the target. Henri hadn't offered her money. He'd offered her a career. That distinction would matter to whoever read this file, and to whoever read the file after that, and she had decided, driving here, that it didn't matter to her.

She handed the form in. The receptionist stamped it. That was it. Eighteen years of clean files, and then a stamp.

Julie was waiting in the corridor outside the managing partner's office when Sophie got back, coat still on.

"He called me," Julie said.

"Who."

"Marchand." Julie's mouth was tight. "Étienne. He got a call from the Barre's intake desk because someone there recognized your name and someone else there knows Étienne. You have been in the building three hours and it's already back to us. That's the speed of this thing, Sophie. That's what you're playing with."

"I filed an ethics complaint against opposing counsel for witness tampering. That's not playing."

"You filed an ethics complaint against a man who sits on the board of the museum and donates to three of our partners' charities—"

"Then they can recuse."

"Nobody recuses, nobody recuses, that's not—" Julie stopped. Pressed two fingers to her own forehead. "He wants to see you. Étienne. Now."

Étienne Marchand was seventy-one and had the build of a man who had rowed competitively and never stopped telling people about it. He kept the office warm and a bowl of hard candies on the desk, and he offered Sophie one before she sat down, and she took it, because refusing would have been a move and she wanted no moves.

"You filed."

"I did."

"Against Maître Ross. Who is, I'll note, counsel of record for a party adverse to our client, which means the complaint goes to the case, not just to the man." He unwrapped a candy himself, a slow operation with his big hands. "Do you know how many complaints the Barre receives per year? Two thousand. Do you know how many result in sanction? Forty. Do you know what happens to the other nineteen hundred and sixty?"

"They sit."

"They sit. And while they sit, they are discoverable. Both sides see them. The judge sees them if there's a motion. And the lawyer who filed them — and here I want you to listen, Sophie, because this is the part people don't expect — the lawyer who filed them spends two years writing responses, attending conciliation, producing documents. Two years. At a hundred and sixty billable hours a month, do you know what that is?"

"I know what it is."

"It's twelve thousand dollars of your time you can't bill and can't sell and can't get back. That's the cheap part. The expensive part is that clients don't like lawyers with open complaints. Not because they think you're dirty. Because they think you're *difficult*. File a complaint and you become the person who files complaints, and then you get the clients who want that, and you lose the clients who don't."

Sophie looked at the candy in her hand and didn't eat it. "Étienne. Henri Ross called me at seven in the morning and offered to buy my silence with a partnership track. He is trying to make a man's wife stay hidden so an exhibition can humiliate a family into settling. I don't know what to tell you."

"You tell me you understand the arithmetic."

"I understand the arithmetic."

"Then tell me you'll withdraw it."

"No."

Étienne set both hands flat on the desk. "Then I'll tell you what happens next, and I want you to hear it from me and not from her." A tilt of his head toward the corridor where Julie had stood. "I can't fire you for filing a complaint. But I can move you. The Bélanger file becomes Julie's file, because an attorney involved in an ethics action has a conflict of interest in the underlying matter. That's not punishment, that's the rule. You keep the office, you keep the title, but your hours go to whatever's left on the small-civil list. That's a four-year step backward for you and we both know it."

"Okay."

"Okay?"

"Give me something to sign."

Étienne studied her for a long moment. "You're surprising me. I've known you eleven years. I didn't think you liked this case that much."

"I don't like it at all." Sophie stood. "That's the thing."

She found Julie in the stairwell, leaning against the rail, phone in hand.

"You're off the file," Julie said, before Sophie could speak.

"I know."

"Étienne called. I'm taking the disclosure. I'm taking the exhibition. I'm taking the client." Julie looked up. "Is that what you wanted? Because you've spent three weeks telling me I was underreacting, and now you've handed the whole thing over."

"I didn't hand it over. The rule took it." Sophie sat down on the step, which was not a thing she did, and Julie noticed, and neither of them said anything about it. "Keep the photograph as evidence the way we agreed. Keep Anh's number in the file. Don't destroy anything. If Henri approaches Bélanger directly, call the Barre intake and reference my complaint number — it's on the stamp, it's the same matter, they'll route it."

"You've thought about this."

"I've had some time at red lights."

Julie put her phone away. "He'll come after you personally. You know that."

"He already did. That's what the complaint is."

"No." Julie shook her head, slowly. "It isn't. The complaint is paper. Paper doesn't make him angry. You declined the offer and recorded the decline and *filed it*, and that means there is now a document in the world that says Henri Ross tried to buy a lawyer and failed. He can survive an allegation. He can't survive the record of an offer he made in his own voice."

Sophie felt the stairwell get very quiet.

"So," Julie said. "What's your plan for when he stops threatening you and starts threatening everyone around you? Because I'm on the file now. Bélanger's on the file. And Gabriel Vachon is—" she stopped herself.

Sophie didn't fill it in.

Julie exhaled. "Okay. Keep your phone on."

Sophie got to the office at ten past eight that evening. Most of the lights were off. She sat at her desk with the small-civil list — two tenant disputes, one defamation, a fence easement from 2019 — and read the file jackets without opening them, and then opened her phone and looked at the number she'd saved under *shop*, no name, thirteen days old.

Nobody was asking her to call it now. That was the point of handing the file over. She could put the phone face down and go home.

She turned it over and dialed.

It rang four times. A woman answered in Vietnamese, then, hearing nothing, tried again in English: "Hello?"

"Hi," Sophie said. "This is not — I don't have a message. I'm calling about the exhibit. About whether you know what's in it."

A pause. Then, quietly, in careful English: "Who is this?"

Sophie opened her mouth. In her inbox, on the other screen, a new email arrived from an address she didn't recognize, subject line: *MARCHAND — RE: BARRE DT-4431*. She put her hand on the mouse.

"Someone who has been asking your husband the same question," she said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: The Bar Complaint · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads