The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 37: Sophie's Suspension

The ethics committee at the Barreau du Québec did not summon her. They sent an email at 8:14 a.m., cc’ing the managing partner, the managing partner’s assistant, and a woman named Carole in records whom Sophie had never met. The subject line read: MARCHAND — RE: BARRE DT-4431. The same case number from the email that had arrived the night before, the one she still hadn’t opened, the one sitting unread in her inbox like a stone in her shoe.

She read it standing up, coat still on, coffee going cold in her hand.

Pending review, the notice said, the firm had elected to suspend her from all matters connected to Bélanger v. Groupe Vachon et al., effective immediately. She was to transfer her file materials by end of day to Julie Chen-Lavoie, counsel of record. She was to make no contact with the client, witnesses, or opposing counsel. Her access to the matter’s document repository had been revoked at 7:50 a.m.

She looked at the timestamp. They had cut her access twenty-four minutes before they told her.

By nine she was in Julie’s office with two banker’s boxes and a USB key, and Julie was standing behind her desk with her arms crossed, not sitting, which Sophie recognized as a deliberate choice. Julie never stood for meetings. Standing meant she did not intend this to be a meeting.

“I’m not going to pretend I’m happy about it,” Julie said.

“I didn’t ask you to.”

“You filed an ethics complaint two days ago. Against opposing counsel, which was right. And now you’re suspended, which is also right, and I get to sit in the middle and look like the one who let it happen.” Julie’s jaw worked. “They asked me if I wanted the file. Do you know what I said? I said yes. Because if I said no, they’d give it to Pomerleau and he’d settle it in a week and Bélanger would never see a courtroom.”

Sophie set the first box on the credenza. “Good.”

“Don’t ‘good’ me.”

“It is good. It’s the right answer.” Sophie slid the box across. “Everything’s labeled. Privilege log’s in the red folder. The medical records are indexed by date, not by provider, because the provider index was wrong for six weeks and I never fixed it, and I apologize.”

Julie looked into the box, then at her, and something in her face shifted toward the thing they had been circling for weeks. “You know what I keep coming back to,” she said. “You didn’t call me. When the recording came in, you went to the client. You went to the curator. You built the whole thing and handed it to me at the end.”

“I called you.”

“After.”

“I was trying to keep you clean.”

“You were trying to keep me out.” Julie sat down. That was worse than the standing. “There’s a difference, Sophie, and you know the difference, and you did it anyway, and now I’m the one who has the file and you’re the one with the boxes and I don’t get to be angry at you without feeling like a monster. So I’m going to be angry anyway. Quietly. And you’re going to take it.”

Sophie took it. She picked up the second box.

“Julie.” She stopped at the door. “If Henri comes at you through the firm — and he will — tell me. Not for the file. Just tell me.”

Julie didn’t answer. Sophie left anyway, which was the answer.

Clearing her office took forty minutes, which was less than she had budgeted for a career.

Most of it was paper that went into recycling. Six years of continuing education binders, an arbitration award she’d been proud of, a photo of her and Élise at a conference in Toronto that she looked at for a long moment before dropping it face-down in the shred pile. She had no plants. No framed certificates. The office had always looked like a hotel room on purpose, so that anyone walking in would understand she was there to work and nothing else.

The bottom drawer was the last to go. Files from the early years, before the firm digitized. She pulled them out one at a time and fed them into the shredder, and near the back, under a folder of 2019 custody pleadings, she found the releases.

Three pages, unsigned. Green corner tabs. Gabriel’s handwriting in the margin.

Her own drafting, from the first week of the engagement — the consents for the permanent collection, authorizing the gallery to use the donors’ names in the exhibition catalog and promotional materials. She had prepared them, sent them to him, and he had never used them, which was the whole point. The donors had never signed. He had kept their names out of the exhibition because they had never formally agreed to be in it, and the whole thing had nearly cost him his funding, and when she’d asked him about it at the kitchen table he had said, *My grandfather would have called that the whole question*, and she had not fully understood him then. She understood him now.

She should have put them in the box.

She stood there over the shredder with the pages in her hand and did the arithmetic — a document prepared by her on a suspended matter, now outside her file, in her coat pocket, not logged, not transferred, technically in limbo — and put them in her bag.

She did not know why. That was the part she noted, with the flat clinical attention she used on other people’s deceptions. She did not know why, and she did it anyway, and she filed the fact away the way she filed everything: as evidence of something she was not yet ready to name.

Ridha was waiting by the elevators with his scarf wound like an argument. He had brought her coffee. She had worked with him for eleven years and he had never once brought her coffee.

“You don’t have to say anything,” he said.

“Then I won’t.”

“They’re going to make it about judgment.” He said the word the way one might hold up something found in food. “It won’t matter what you did right. Carole has the complaint and Carole has the file and Carole has a view about women who make things difficult without a reason a partner can explain in a meeting.”

“I know.”

“Do you want me to tell you it’ll blow over?”

“No.”

“Good, because it might not.” He pressed the coffee at her. “The partners met this morning. Six of them. They’re calling it a stability question. Which is what they call it when they don’t want to say whose billings are at risk.”

“Mine.”

“Marguerite’s,” he said. “Yours are down two hundred hours and she is the one who has to explain a lateral hire who got herself suspended. You are not the one who pays for this, Sophie. That’s what I came down to tell you.”

She took the coffee. Her throat was tight, which annoyed her more than the suspension had.

“Thank you,” she said, and the elevator came, and she rode it down alone.

She had walked four blocks toward the office when the phone rang.

The same number. The unknown Montreal one. Fourth time in three days, third time in twelve hours, and now — she looked at the phone in her palm, at the coffee cooling in her other hand, at the angled snow coming off the building across the street — now she was a woman with two banker’s boxes in her trunk and a set of unsigned consents in her bag and no file and no client and no privilege and no reason left to answer as anyone’s lawyer.

A pedestrian went around her. She stood in the middle of the sidewalk with the phone ringing and watched the number and thought about the phrase she had said to the voice on the shop line, *someone asking the same question*, and how it had felt less like a lie than like a door she was still deciding to open.

She answered.

There was a pause on the other end, the particular pause of someone who had made several calls already and had stopped expecting the fifth to be picked up.

Then a man’s voice, careful, not young: “Ms. Marchand. My name is Olivier Vachon. I’m Henri’s son, and I’m calling about my father — before the newspaper does.”

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 37: Sophie's Suspension · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads