The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 44: The Lie Repaid

The restaurant was on Laurier, small and warm, with a chalkboard menu and candles in chipped saucers. Gabriel had chosen it because it was nothing like a gallery and nothing like a boardroom. Sophie had worn the green dress she wore to court when she wanted to feel invincible.

They had been talking for an hour about nothing—her sister's terrible taste in men, the way he'd once slept in a supply closet during a Berlin install—and it had started to feel like the easiest thing in the world. She had caught herself laughing twice. That was the tell.

"So," she said, setting down her glass, "we're doing this."

"I think we're doing this," he said.

"Against all advice."

"All of it," he agreed. "Terrible idea. My lawyer—"

"Your lawyer—"

"—told me the last time she saw me this happy was at a seizure."

Sophie laughed, and he watched her laugh, and she felt the specific warmth of being looked at by someone who wanted to keep looking. She reached across the table and put her hand over his, and that was when it changed.

He didn't take his hand back. But something closed behind his face. She had cross-examined enough people to see a door shut.

"You've been sitting on something all night," she said.

"I have."

She kept her hand where it was. "Say it."

Gabriel looked down at the tablecloth, then at her.

"The envelope," he said.

She knew immediately. There was only ever one envelope. Anh's prints, the six frames of the boy with the hockey stick, the ones he hadn't known existed until he held them.

"The gallery had it months before you knew," he said. "You asked me once how I found it, and I told you it was in the files by accident. It wasn't."

Her hand came back to her side of the table. Slowly.

"Henri told me to open it," he said. "That's the truth. He called me into his office and he said there was material we hadn't catalogued, and he asked me to go through it. He didn't tell me what was in it. He didn't have to. I opened it because he told me to, and I catalogued it, and I put it back, and when I found out later whose prints those were I did not tell you where the envelope came from."

The room did not stop. Other people were eating. A waiter was telling the specials to a table by the window.

"So when you told me," Sophie said, and her voice came out flat and professional, the voice she used for depositions, "it was a lie."

"Yes."

"Not an omission. You told me it was misfiled. You told me you just found it."

"Yes."

"Why."

"Because I was afraid you'd stop."

She set her napkin on the table. Folding it, squaring it, lining up the edges.

"You had six frames of a child you never knew you had," she said. "You had proof your mother was in that apartment. And you handed it to me as an accident so I'd help you keep it."

"No. That's—no. I wanted the boy to have them. That part was never a lie. It's why I ever told you anything."

"But you made me your alibi."

"I made you someone who could fix it. There's a difference."

"Is there?"

He was quiet. She could see him deciding whether to argue, and deciding not to, which was worse, because it meant he knew she was right.

"And now?" she said. "Why now?"

He looked at her steadily.

"Because of the exhibit."

"The exhibit isn't hanging. Half of it's in a bailiff's storage and the other half needs forty-one signatures."

"I know."

"Then what does the exhibit have to do with anything?"

"If it ever hangs," Gabriel said, "it's supposed to be about people telling the truth about how they got broken. Whose picture goes up, and whose doesn't, and what everybody consented to. If we ask these families to sign a form and tell them it's honest—and the man running it lied to the person helping him—"

"You're the man."

"I'm the man."

She looked at him. His hands were flat on the table. There was no performance in him, and there hadn't been all night, and that was the thing she couldn't make fit: he had chosen tonight. He could have said it in the gallery, or in a text, or never. He had ordered wine, and he had told her about the supply closet in Berlin, and he had let her put her hand on his, and then he had told her.

That meant something. She just didn't know if it was the right thing, and she was too angry to care.

"There's something you don't know," she said.

"Tell me."

"There's been a black sedan outside my building since before the seizure. Twice a week. Sometimes more. I've been photographing the plate. I didn't tell you because I assumed it was Henri and I assumed you'd panic and I wanted to handle it myself."

Gabriel's face changed. "Sophie—"

"And now I don't know what to do with it," she said. "Because I don't know what else you've decided for me."

"I never decided anything for you."

"You decided what I didn't need to know. For months. That's the same thing."

He started to speak. She raised a hand.

"You should have told me about the envelope the day you met me," she said. "Not the day you wanted to hang an exhibition."

"That's not—"

"It's the same sentence," she said. "Every time. You told me the truth when the truth became useful to you. First you lied so I'd stay. Then you told the truth so the show could open. Neither of those is about me."

She reached for her bag.

"Sophie."

"Please don't."

"I'm telling you now because I—"

The waiter appeared at the edge of the table with two plates. Sophie lifted a hand.

"Just the check, please."

The waiter looked from her to Gabriel and back, and read the table correctly, and left.

Gabriel didn't move. He was looking at her the way he had looked at her in the emptied gallery, on the floor beneath the bare rectangle where the photograph used to hang, and she felt that floor under her again, and the hand she had let him hold there, and she hated him a little for making her remember it here.

"I don't know if this is the end of something," she said, "or a very expensive false start. I'll decide later. But not tonight."

The check came. She took it before he could, put cash down, and stood.

She walked out past the window, and she did not look back at the table. On the sidewalk, the cold hit her face and steadied her. Behind her, through the glass, Gabriel sat where she had left him, hands flat on the cloth, the two plates untouched, and she let the door swing shut between them.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 44: The Lie Repaid · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads