The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 56: After the Debt

She took the day off. The first one in nine months that didn't have a deposition or a client in it.

Sophie left her phone on the kitchen counter, screen down, and walked out the door of the Plateau apartment without a coat decision, because April in Montreal decides for you and she'd stopped arguing with it years ago. She took the orange line to Mont-Royal and started up the stairs where they cut through the hillside, the wooden treads still damp from the morning rain. People passed her going down — a man with a stroller, two teenagers in matching school jackets, a woman in running tights who smiled at the hill like it owed her money.

She wasn't good at this. A personal day. Bertrand had said the words like they were a prescription he didn't entirely believe in. *Take the day, Sophie. You've been running on fumes since February and you're going to bill somebody the wrong advice.*

So here she was, climbing a mountain in the middle of a workday, wearing the boots that were wrong for it, thinking about a man who wasn't her client, wasn't her husband, wasn't anything the law had a clean word for.

The path leveled out above the cemetery and she stopped at the first lookout with a view down the escarpment. The city lay under a flat silver sky — the mountain's shoulder, the university roofs, the river somewhere past everything, thin and pale as the back of a hand. Somewhere down there was her office, the consent-and-permissions folder, the six-month trial that might never get a budget. Somewhere down there was a community space in Villeray with a filing cabinet and a co-op board that had just signed five years of payments to save a show. Somewhere down there was Gabriel.

She kept walking.

Here was the thing she'd been circling since the rain, since his voice on the phone from a street corner: *I'm at Saint-Laurent and Rachel.* He'd said it like a man reporting his own coordinates, as if she might need to find him in a wilderness. It had done something to her, that small flat sentence. Or undone something.

The other thing was what Julie had said. Three months ago in a Moroccan restaurant, over a glass of wine Sophie hadn't finished: *You keep telling me what you're afraid of. Tell him what you want. Out loud. Thursday, when you walk the wall.*

She hadn't. Thursday had come and gone and she'd walked the wall with him and said nothing that mattered, and then there was Henri and the settlement and the signatures and the opening date and always, always a good reason to be busy being reasonable.

But then Danielle Fournier's complaint died; the panel had written her a formal reprimand and taxed her costs. The bar had vindicated the part of Sophie that believed in the machinery. And oddly it hadn't been the win she wanted. The win she wanted had been smaller and more dangerous: a Sunday when nobody was sanctioning anyone, when a man who'd lost his father and half his work sat across from her and asked her nothing.

She stopped at the chalet lookout. A man was selling coffee from a cart, and she bought one because her hands were cold. She leaned on the railing and drank it and let herself think the whole thought through, no billing increments, no ethics review.

What she wanted: Gabriel. Not the idea of him, not the flattering counter-evidence to every woman in her building who thought forty-two was a shelf you got taken off. Him. His hands at a canvas. His bad joke about the accordion. The way he said *Sophie* like it was the whole sentence.

What she was afraid of: being a phase. Being a door he walked through on his way to the rest of his life. Being the older woman a son dates to get back at a father — except his father was gone and disowned him, so that fear had evaporated, and here was the residue. If it wasn't rebellion, what was it? What if there was nothing on his side of it but momentum?

She'd married the wrong man at twenty-eight because he'd been certain and certainty looked like love. She was good at reading contracts. Not so good at reading men who never put anything in writing.

So write the terms, she told herself. You're a lawyer. You don't have to know the ending. You have to know what you're willing to sign up to hear.

The terms: She wasn't his mother. She wouldn't be furniture for him to lean on and then resent — she wasn't feeding him, financing him, or fighting his fights for him. She'd done the settlement because it was the right result, not because he needed rescuing.

She wasn't his lawyer. Which meant he had to talk to her like a person and not hand her the problems. And she wasn't his rebellion, either. If he wanted to shock people, he'd have to do it with somebody else.

What she was willing to be: his partner in something slow. A man and a woman with different hours and separate bank accounts and a generational gap that strangers would comment on. Someone who came home. Someone whose terms were plain and could be said out loud in a room with no exit sign.

The coffee was gone. The wind came up off the flank of the mountain and turned the underpass of bare trees raw and wet-smelling. Sophie pulled out her phone. Four percent battery. She'd been out three hours. Fine.

She called Anh first.

"Hey. Sorry it's taken me a couple of days."

"Ah, the lawyer surfaces." Anh's voice was light but pressed thin underneath. "You got my note?"

"I got your note. *Show the one I chose.*"

"You know which one."

"I do." Sophie watched a jogger struggle up the last switchback. "I'm going to tell you the same thing I'd tell a client: you made a smart, brave, entirely insane decision, and I'm proud of you."

The pause on the line was a whole breath long. "That's it? No lecture?"

"No lecture. I'll save it for the ones who need it. I'm taking the day off."

"Off from what? You're the only person I know whose day off still includes a hearing."

"There's no hearing today. There's a mountain and a bad cup of coffee. So." Sophie closed her eyes against the wind. "The releases. Do we know if Vachon's motion to add the co-op is still crawling along?"

"They filed. Wednesday. So your Friday filing—"

"It went in Friday, and it names the community space, so we're the interested party now, not just the witnesses. I need to tell Gabriel." She said his name and felt the ground hold under it. "I'm not calling you on his behalf, Anh. I'm calling you because I'm walking down this hill and I want to know what I'm signing him up for. As a client."

Anh exhaled. Long. "You're asking me as his neighbor."

"I'm asking you as the person who kept him upright while I was busy being sued."

"Then here's the truth," Anh said. "He's sleeping on Trân's sofa. He's got a show hanging in six weeks that he can't legally guarantee the light bill on. He hasn't spoken to his father since the settlement. But he asked me Wednesday if the framing budget could stretch to one more piece of yours."

"Of mine?"

"The hands. The piece you sat for."

Sophie put her hand on the end of the railing. The metal was cold and made a noise like a struck bell, low and ordinary. "Okay. I'll call you tomorrow. I'll have an answer about the motion."

"You'll have an answer or *he* will?"

"I'll have the answer and I'll share it with him." She hung up before she could revise herself. "I—" she said, to no one, into the battery warning. Then she sat on a bench and called Gabriel.

It rang twice.

"Sophie." Just the one word, like he was checking a line on a map.

"Hey." Wind. Children shrieking somewhere above the chalet. "Listen. I'm on Mount Royal. I took the day off, which is practically a parish announcement, so I want to use it well."

"Are you okay? You never—"

"I'm fine. I'm a little cold and I'm very tired of thinking. Can you meet me at the gallery?"

A pause. "The gallery."

"Yes."

"They closed off my access since the settlement. Inés still has a key. I can—"

"I'll meet you out front in forty minutes and we'll get in one way or another. If we can't get in, we walk around the block and talk on a bench. Either way, I'm not asking you to come to Villeray, Gabriel. I want the empty room."

"Why?"

She looked at the river, thin and pale under the silver sky, at the whole city where she had built a life with a good lock on the front door of it. "Because if you and I are going to do this in a building that once belonged to your father, I want to draw the terms somewhere he can't reach them. And because I have something to say that's mine. Not the case. Not the exhibit. Mine to say. And it shouldn't be at the community space, where everyone who ever took our picture is going to hear it secondhand."

"You sound like you're drafting something."

"I am," she said. "The first honest thing I've drafted in about a year. Bring an extra sweater; I don't want to be cold when I say it."

There was a long sound on the other end, half laugh, half breath — the sound of a man in a transit-station stairwell, somewhere in the city, trying to fit himself into a room she had just opened. "Forty minutes," he said. "Get inside somewhere warm. I'll be there."

Sophie stood up. The wind went through her jacket like it had business to do, and she let it. Ten years ago she would have called this a strategy. Today she knew the word for it — she just wasn't ready to say it out loud in the street. She started down the hill, phone at nine percent, boots wrong for the path, and took the stairs two at a time because there was somewhere she finally wanted to be.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 56: After the Debt · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads