The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 70: The Car Repaid

Claire was already in the driveway when Sophie pulled up, arms folded, watching the Civic roll to a stop like it was returning from a war.

"You're early," Sophie said, getting out.

"You said four. It's four." Claire looked past her at the car. "Maman's baby. Does she know you're giving it back?"

"She knows I'm dropping it off so she can lend it to Marie-Claude for the summer." Sophie handed over the keys. "Which is what she wanted all along. She only gave it to me because she thought I'd need it after the divorce."

"And you did need it."

"For a while." Sophie looked at the car—the coffee ring on the console she'd never cleaned, the ten-year-old air freshener, the passenger seat where Gabriel had sat twice, both times without commenting on the smell. "I don't anymore."

Claire weighed this. "So what are you going to do?"

"Buy something."

"With what money?"

"With my money." Sophie opened her own trunk, took out the box of things she'd been meaning to bring back—a casserole dish, a blanket, a book her mother had lent her in 2019 and mentioned every Christmas since. "I'm a lawyer with a corner office. I can buy a used Corolla."

Claire took the box without arguing, which was how Sophie knew she'd landed something. They carried everything inside. Their mother was on the couch with her feet up, watching a game show at volume, and she waved the remote at Sophie the way she had at sixteen, at twenty-five, at thirty-eight—the same wave, meaning *there you are*.

"Aïe, the car goes," she said. "Fine. It was too big for the street anyway."

"Thank you for the loan."

"Loan, loan." Her mother sniffed. "It was a leash. You know what a leash is good for? A dog. You are not a dog, Sophie."

"Okay, Maman."

"Come eat something."

"I can't. I have to go look at a car before the guy sells it to someone else."

Her mother's eyebrows went up, then settled, and she turned back to the game show with the unmistakable air of a woman who had just won a long argument she'd never admitted to having.

The car was on the far side of Villeray, on a residential street of triplexes with swags of clotheslines in the back. A 2013 Corolla, 180,000 kilometers, body honest, one dent in the rear quarter panel the seller described—with real pride, as though it were a war wound—as "parking."

The seller was a man in his sixties named Réjean who had bought it new off the lot the year his son started university and was now selling because the son had moved to Vancouver and the car had sat under a tarp for two winters.

"Take it around the block," Réjean said, tossing her the key. "Boulevard, then the small streets. Nothing rattles. If it rattles, you come back and tell me. I want to know."

It rattled at a stoplight, faintly, somewhere in the dash. Sophie decided she liked it.

She bought it for four thousand and change, cash and bank draft, and Réjean insisted on washing it before she took it, which took forty minutes, during which she sat on his front steps and answered two emails from opposing counsel and one from the gallery's lawyer about Thursday's deposition. When she drove away, the car smelled like dish soap and the inside of Réjean's garage, which was a smell she'd known her whole life from her father's own garage and which she did not examine too closely.

She drove it to her own street for the first time and parked it in her spot, and turned the engine off, and sat there.

Nobody had lent her this. Nobody was going to ask for it back.

Her phone buzzed. Gabriel: *How was the thing with your mother.*

*Fine,* she typed. *Réjean sends his regards.*

*Who's Réjean.*

*New car. 2013. Doesn't rattle much.*

A pause. Then: *You bought a car today.*

*I did.*

*I'm trying to figure out why that makes me happy.*

*It doesn't have anything to do with you.*

*I know,* he wrote. *That's why.*

She sat there a while longer, doing the math on insurance, on the parking permit, on the tiny satisfaction of a thing that was only hers. When she went up, Claire was standing in her kitchen, which meant Claire had her own key, which meant Sophie should have cared more than she did.

"So," Claire said, leaning on the counter, "you bought the car."

"I bought the car."

"With Réjean."

"With Réjean."

Claire looked at her for a long moment—the way she looked at witnesses at trial, which was a thing Sophie had taught her and was now periodically finding turned on her.

"Good," Claire said.

That was all. She picked up her bag, kissed Sophie on the cheek without ceremony, and was gone, and Sophie stood in her kitchen and understood that a woman who said "good" about a used Corolla was a woman who had just watched her sister stop borrowing.

She had three hours before the workshop. She hated to use them the way she used them.

She sat at the kitchen table with the case file—Anh's pages, her own notes, Inés's caption card still on the nightstand where it had been for two days, face down since yesterday because she'd turned it over without reading it and hadn't turned it back. She opened her laptop and did not open the deposition outline. She opened the gallery's timeline instead, and read Inés's email trail again, and made a list of every date on which a piece had been hung without a signed release.

One entry kept surfacing: the hands piece had gone up on a Tuesday. Anh's new photograph had gone up on a Thursday, and Anh had hung it herself.

Sophie looked at her phone. The voicemail she'd left Anh had been three days unreturned. That was a message too.

She considered calling Gabriel. She considered texting him *the hands are Inés's parents* and watching what it did. She considered a lot of things, and then she did what she did, which was write it down, cleanly, in the order in which she would need it, and close the file.

Not yet. Saturday. She'd told him Saturday. She was beginning to understand that she'd told him that because she needed the workshop to be its own thing first—not another exhibit, not another negotiation, just the thing itself, working or not working, with the two of them in the room as themselves and nobody's case on the table.

She showered and changed into the same blazer she wore to mediations. She considered that she was dressing for battle and then considered that maybe she was dressing for a room full of strangers who'd signed up to talk about consent, and that those were not the same thing.

The gallery was lit from inside like a lantern against the early dark. Rows of chairs had been set up in the central room past the entrance, maybe forty seats, plastic folding ones from a rental place, and at the front near the Anh Trinh photograph there was a table with water glasses and a stack of printed handouts. Anh was there, in jeans, taping a sign to the wall that read, in English and French, *This Is a Workshop, Not a Panel. Speak from Where You Are.*

Gabriel came out of the back office with an armload of chairs, saw Sophie, and stopped.

"New car," he said.

"That's the exciting part of my day."

"I doubt it," he said, and set down the chairs, and didn't ask her anything else, which she noticed the way she noticed everything—and filed it.

Anh caught Sophie's eye across the room and gave her a small nod, the kind of nod that conceded nothing and acknowledged everything. Beside the sign, taped at eye level, was a printed page. Sophie walked over.

It was the wall-text line. The one admitting the revoked release. Anh must have printed it that afternoon and hung it herself, because Gabriel was still folding chairs.

Sophie read it twice. It was four sentences long, and it did not name the artist, and it said the release had been revoked and the piece left on view with the artist's knowledge, and it was, technically, accurate.

It was also not enough. And the hands piece was still on the wall.

Gabriel appeared at her shoulder, close, careful. "It's up," he said quietly. "I did it this morning, actually. Before you got here."

"You did it after Anh got here, you mean."

He didn't answer that. "Does it change anything?"

Sophie looked at the empty chairs, at the water glasses, at the door, where the first person had just walked in carrying a folded jacket and looking around for a seat.

"Ask me after," she said.

She didn't say after what. She took a seat at the front table next to Anh, laid her pen and her notebook down like they were somebody else's, and watched Gabriel turn toward the door to greet the room.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 70: The Car Repaid · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads