The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 8: The Hotelier

The Hotel St-Laurent kept its lobby at a precise seventeen degrees, a fact Sophie knew because M. Bélanger had mentioned it twice, the way men of a certain age mention the things they own instead of the things they feel.

She arrived at nine sharp. He was already seated in the corner banquette of the hotel's bar, which was empty at that hour except for a server polishing glasses with the focused resentment of someone paid to be invisible.

"You're punctual," Bélanger said, not standing. He was silver at the temples, tanned, wearing a navy blazer over a white shirt unbuttoned one button past where most lawyers would advise. "My wife says nobody's punctual anymore. I tell her that's why I keep you."

Sophie sat. Her phone showed two missed calls from the office and a voicemail icon that had been there since the night before, three minutes of her client talking to her machine. She had not listened to it. She had been staring at a blurry photograph of a kitchen and a handwritten mark on a coffee cup, and the voicemail had felt like a door she could leave closed a little longer.

"I listened to your message," she said, which was a lie of omission, the kind she billed at six hundred an hour. "You sounded concerned."

"Concerned." He turned the word over, unimpressed. "There's a photograph in that gallery on Notre-Dame. My wedding. First wedding. It's torn down the middle. You can see my ex-wife's shoulder on one half and my hand on the other, and in between there's nothing, just the tear, like the picture got divorced too." He smiled without warmth. "I don't want the public looking at the inside of my marriage. Either of them."

"It's one image in a group show about family rupture."

"It's my face. My suit. That was my mother's tablecloth." He set down his espresso hard enough to make the cup ring. "You know what they called it in the press release? 'Untitled (Union).' Untitled. I paid forty thousand dollars for that tablecloth."

Sophie let a beat pass. "The gallery's position is that the work was acquired lawfully and the loan agreement doesn't contain a morals clause. We've asked for a signed release from the photographer's estate, which would—"

"Which would make me the man who agreed to be in a show about divorce." He said the word with a small, rehearsed disgust, as though divorce were a smell. "No."

"You asked me here to tell me something," Sophie said. "So tell me."

Bélanger looked past her, at the empty lobby, at the revolving door turning with no one in it. "I own three hotels. I have a legal budget that would make your firm's eyes water. Wills, acquisitions, two developments in Griffintown, and a dispute over the marina rights at the Sainte-Marguerite property that will bill for at least eighteen months." He turned his espresso spoon over. "Every year, my general counsel asks me whether we should put the work out to tender. Every year, I say no. Sophie Marchand handles us."

"You're telling me you'd take that away over a photograph."

"I'm telling you what I'd rather not have to do." He finally looked at her, and there was nothing angry in it, which was worse. "You've been divorced yourself. So you know. You know how people keep the paperwork."

The bar was very quiet. The server had stopped polishing.

"I know," Sophie said.

"Then get me the print. Not a promise about the print. The print, in my hands, before anyone hangs it." He stood, smoothing his blazer. "You have until the opening. If the show goes up with my face in it, I'll assume you chose it. That's fair, isn't it? People should know what their lawyers choose."

He left. He did not pay for the espresso.

Sophie sat alone in the banquette for a full minute, which cost her firm ten dollars, and did the thing she was good at: she took the fear and folded it into a plan, flattened it, filed it where it wouldn't show.

The problem was structural. Bélanger wanted the print. The gallery could not surrender the print without defaulting on the loan covenant, which would let Groupe Vachon seize the entire collection, which would deliver the torn wedding photograph directly into the hands of the very man who wanted it. Every road led to the same house. The only exit was Marisol Vaz's signature on a release that, if it existed, would gut her client's claim that the photograph invaded his privacy, because the photograph would turn out to have been authorized all along, by a woman who had stood on the other side of the tear.

And Sophie had told Gabriel, in the middle of the night, by text, that the amended loan agreement was sitting in her files under "incidental."

She took out her phone. No new messages from him. The last one was hers, unanswered: *Ask Linh whether the sealed envelope contains a photograph of Marisol.* He had read it. She knew he had read it because the little blue checkmarks had appeared, and then nothing, for eleven hours.

She called Linh.

"Bonjour?"

"Linh, it's Sophie Marchand. From yesterday."

"Ah." A pause with a television behind it. "You found the negatives. They're all there, I checked. Nobody took anything."

"I need to ask you about the sealed envelope. The one that said 'for the show.'"

Nothing. The television kept going, some game show, applause.

"I opened it," Linh said finally. "The night you and the young man left. I sat on my kitchen floor for a long time."

"What was in it?"

"A photo." Linh's voice did something Sophie couldn't name. "It's a woman in a chair, in a room with a window. She's not looking at the camera. She's looking at somebody behind it. You can't see who. Her name is on the back, in Anh's hand. Marisol."

Sophie's pen stopped. "You have it."

"I put it back. I sealed it again with tape, so I could say I never opened it. My sister left that envelope for the show, not for me." A small, dry laugh. "In my family, we're very good at keeping documents that prove things. My father left us a house and a ledger of every debt. You know what I did with the ledger? I burned it. I didn't look at one page."

"Linh. I'm going to ask you a lawyer's question and then I'm going to ask you a human question. The lawyer's: can I photograph the back of that print, the name, just the name? For the file."

"And the human question?"

"Do you think your sister would have wanted a woman named Marisol to be hunted down over something that happened thirty years ago, or would she have wanted the picture shown?"

Silence. Applause. Another game show.

"Come Thursday at two," Linh said. "Bring the young man. Not alone."

She hung up. Sophie sat with the phone against her ear for a moment, and then she did what she had been dreading and played the voicemail from Bélanger.

Three minutes. It began with a rustle and a restaurant clatter, then his voice, close to the phone, too loud, that particular warmth of a man three drinks in: "Me again. I'm at the Maison Verte, you should come, I'm buying. Listen—here's the thing I didn't say in the lobby the last time, and I'll say it now because the waiter's not listening. The tear in the photo isn't even the real problem. The real problem is the other half. My ex-wife has one half. I have the other. Thirty years we've kept them apart and now a gallery wants to put them back together on a wall and call it art." A long exhale. "My daughter's graduating in June. Do you know what she thinks of me? She thinks I'm the man in the photograph. That's all she's ever seen of her father's first marriage—half a picture." Another rustle, a chair scraping. "Get me the print, Sophie. I'm not asking as your client. I'm asking as a man who paid you a lot of money to ever only have to be one person in public."

The message ended. Sophie looked at the time: three minutes and eleven seconds, which was longer than Bélanger had spoken to her in the bar.

She wrote two notes on the back of a hotel coaster. First: *Linh has Marisol. Thursday, 2 p.m., bring Gabriel.* Second: *Do not tell Rousseau. Do not let the envelope leave the Plateau.*

Then she looked at the coaster again and crossed out the second line. Because she had already done the thing she did with facts she couldn't afford to lose and promises she couldn't afford to keep—she had folded this one too, and put it somewhere only she could see.

Her phone lit up. Gabriel, finally, three words and nothing else: *I'm not giving it up.*

She didn't know yet if he meant the print or her.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 8: The Hotelier · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads