The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 13: The Report

Sebastian filed the report on a Tuesday morning, and the copy he handed Viola was still warm from the printer.

She read it standing in the kitchen house, the smell of solvent and the portrait's exposed canvas on the easel beside her. Two pages. Plain. He had described the sealed room the way a man describes a house he toured: bed, chair, wall, drawer, file. He had written that a locked desk drawer had been opened in the presence of counsel. He had written that documentation appeared to postdate the trust's termination.

He had not written what the documentation said. He had not written RENEE, or Marion A. Toussaint, or 1997.

"You left out the part that matters," she said.

"I left out nothing the court is entitled to." He was standing by the door with his coat still on, as if he had already decided how close to come. "The inventory will speak for itself. If I'd characterized it, it becomes argument. Argument becomes a hearing. A hearing becomes a stranger putting a photograph of your mother's papers into an evidence bag."

"You characterized the drawer."

"I described the drawer."

She set the pages down on the workbench. Outside, the live oak dripped from a night of rain. She had thought she would feel something larger than this—rage, or the clean snap of a line cut. Instead she felt a kind of administrative grief. Like watching a box get sealed.

"You know what you did," she said.

"I know."

"Say it, then."

He looked at the portrait, at the woman's face emerging from its own filth in a quarter-inch band of clean canvas. "I put the file on the record," he said. "If it's destroyed after this, that's not a loss of evidence anymore. That's a crime. That's the only protection I could actually give you."

"That's very good," she said. "You should keep that sentence."

He left without answering. She heard the gate, then his car.

The clerk arrived forty-three hours later.

Her name was Ms. Duvall, and she carried a hard-sided case and a camera with a strap worn pale in the webbing. She was perhaps fifty and she had the flat courtesy of someone who had inventoried a great many rooms that did not want to be inventoried. Sebastian met her at the front door. Viola stood in the hall with her arms crossed and was not introduced, which she understood as a deliberate mercy and resented anyway.

"You'll need to stay back of the threshold," Ms. Duvall told her, pleasantly, at the foot of the attic stairs. "I photograph, I number, I list. I don't move anything I don't have to move."

"I'm the occupant," Viola said.

"You're the occupant." The clerk nodded as if that were one of several things a person could be. "Threshold's still the threshold."

So Viola stood in the doorway of the third-floor nursery for eleven minutes and watched a stranger work.

It was worse than she had prepared for. The clerk's flash went off in even, unhurried intervals, and every time it fired, the wall came out of the dark: forty-one photographs, tape yellowed at the corners, faces going back in decades—bouffants and pin curls and a girl with a scarf and a black eye she'd tried to hide with blush. Viola had stood in front of that wall and felt each of them like a hand pressed flat on her chest. The flash reduced them all to data.

Ms. Duvall photographed the bed. The rocking chair. The desk, open, with the empty drawer. She photographed the drawer itself, the interior, the runner, the scratch where Viola's letter opener had lifted the lock. She put on gloves and lifted the file out of the drawer and laid it on the desk and photographed the cover, then opened it flat and photographed each page with a small stainless scale laid alongside.

Viola counted the pages as they turned. Intake form. Two duplicates. A handwritten note. A second handwritten note. The intake form again—no, the first one had a staple rust mark, and this one didn't. She lost the thread. Flash, flash, flash.

"You'll want a humidity reading on the paper," Viola said from the doorway. She couldn't help it. "Sulfur in that room, from the shuttered window—the foxing on the corners indicates—"

"Ma'am," Ms. Duvall said, without looking up.

Sebastian, in the hall behind her, touched her elbow, once, briefly. She shook him off.

At the end of the eleven minutes the clerk closed the file, taped the drawer shut with evidence tape, hung a paper seal on the nursery door, and walked down the stairs with her case, and Sebastian walked her out, and that was that.

Viola went up alone when the front door had closed.

The room smelled of flash and glove powder now. She knelt at the desk in her own space, under her own seal, and opened the file to check the order of the pages.

The intake form was gone.

Not photographed-and-replaced—gone from the file's own binding. She could see the rust mark, the two punctures where the staple teeth had been pushed back through. The neighboring pages hadn't shifted. Someone had opened the file, worked the staple loose with something thin, pulled the form, closed the file again, and set it back precisely square.

Viola sat down on the floor, hard, the way her knees used to go out when she was a girl and the world did something unspeakable. Then she took out her phone and called Sebastian, and did not shout, which was somehow worse.

"Come back," she said. "Bring a light. Bring the UV light. Someone's been in my file."

He was there in nine minutes. He came up the stairs two at a time, which she had never seen him do. He looked at the two staple holes the way she had looked at them. Then he looked at the evidence tape on the drawer and the paper seal on the door, both intact, both bearing a signature and a time.

"Nothing's broken," he said.

"Nothing's broken."

"Then either the seal was made after the removal, or—"

"Or the person who removed it had a key to the seal," Viola said. "Or was the person who sealed it."

He was quiet for a moment. He had gone very still, and she had learned by now that his stillness was not calm. It was what he did instead of flinching.

"Ms. Duvall," he said.

"I watched her the whole time."

"You watched her from the threshold. She turned her back to you twice. She moved the case onto the desk. She had a coat with pockets."

"I watched her," Viola said, "and I don't know. That's the thing. I was watching the faces on the wall every time the flash went off, because I couldn't make myself look at her. I don't know what her hands did."

Sebastian put the UV light down on the desk without turning it on. He looked at the empty staple holes for a while longer. Then he said, in a voice she hadn't heard from him before, without any of the level courtroom flatness:

"I'm going to say something, and I want you to hear it exactly as I say it."

"Go ahead."

"I'm afraid." He looked up at her. "Not of the court. Not of the certification. I've been afraid of that since the day I signed it and it has never once changed a decision I made. This is different. Someone walked into a sealed room behind a court order and took exactly one page, and left everything else, and knew which page to take. That's not a lawyer's move. That's not a beneficiary's move." He swallowed. "Somebody's still working the house, Viola. And they're not being careful anymore—they're being fast. That's worse."

The house settled. Somewhere below, the old pipes knocked once, the way they did around eight.

"We have to photograph everything that's left," Viola said. Her voice came out steadier than she felt. "Right now. Every page, every face, every inch of that wall, before whoever it is comes back for the rest."

Sebastian was already on his feet, phone out, opening the camera. "The wall takes longer than the file. Which first?"

Viola looked at the two staple holes, then at the forty-one women staring out of the dark.

"The file," she said. "The wall has already survived one of them."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 13: The Report · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads