The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 42: The Motion

The motion arrived by courier at 4:10 on a Friday afternoon, which was itself a message. Nobody serves papers at four on a Friday unless they want the weekend to do the wounding.

Viola carried the envelope into the kitchen because the kitchen had the best light and because she had learned, in six weeks, that bad news read better standing up. Sebastian was at the counter with the ledger open in front of him, making a list of entries in his small tight hand, a pen between his teeth. He'd been doing that since the suspension—copying the ledger onto paper as if the paper were the only thing Prejean couldn't get to.

"What is it?" he said, around the pen.

She slit the envelope with her thumbnail. "Court."

He took the pen out of his mouth and stood.

She read it standing at the window, and the light coming through the palm fronds flickered over the page like the words were underwater. It took her two passes to understand, and a third to believe.

*Motion to Declare Codicil Invalid and to Enjoin Enforcement.*

The trust—the Fontaine trust, Charline Fontaine as trustee, represented by a firm out of Baton Rouge that Viola had never heard of—was asking the court to find that the codicil to Camille Marchand's will was a forgery. Not merely irregular. Not merely the product of a confused woman in her last months. Forged. Fabricated. And signed, the motion alleged, by one Marguerite Delacroix, who had lived in the house for nine years as Camille's companion and who—here Viola had to sit down on the edge of the table—*lacked standing to dispose of the estate of Camille Marchand for the simple reason that she was not Camille Marchand.*

"They're saying the codicil isn't Mom's."

Sebastian had come around the table. He read over her shoulder, close enough that she could smell the rain still in his coat. He didn't touch the paper. He'd stopped touching things in front of her, she'd noticed, as if the suspension had made him careful about what he put his hands on.

"They're not saying it's a bad instrument," he said slowly. "They're not attacking the terms. They're attacking the signature."

"Because if the signature isn't hers, there's no ninety days. There's no condition. The house passes to the trust outright." Her voice came out flat and strange. "They never wanted the ninety days to fail. They wanted to erase the ninety days entirely, and the failure was just the backup plan."

"That's right."

"Who's Marguerite Delacroix?"

Sebastian was quiet long enough that she looked up. His face had the particular shuttered quality it got when he was deciding how much to tell her—and she'd learned to read that, too, over these weeks, which was a thing she hadn't expected to acquire.

"Your mother's companion," he said. "For the last nine years."

"I know that. I read the codicil. I mean who was she. Why would they name *her*?"

"Because she's the one who witnessed it, presumably. She's the one whose name is on the notary block." He pulled the copy of the codicil from the file he'd been keeping, and there it was, a clean loop of a signature beneath her mother's: *M. Delacroix, witness.* Viola had read that page a hundred times and never once looked at the second name.

"So to prove the codicil is real, I have to put her on the stand."

"If she's alive. If she can be found." He said it gently, which was worse than the words. "Or—"

"Or produce my mother."

"Yes."

The refrigerator cycled on. Somewhere in the walls, the old house ticked and settled, and Viola thought of the reel-to-reel sealed in the east parlor, running its thirty-eight years of tape, listening to everyone who ever walked through the foyer. It had never heard Camille leave. That was the thing she kept coming back to. There was no exit in the ledger for the night her mother disappeared—only entries coming in.

"She never left," Viola said. "Out the front, anyway. There's no door in that machine that she ever used."

"You've been thinking that a while."

"Since the west wall." She stood, and the motion fluttered to the floor, and neither of them picked it up. "Prejean told Crane to search it by hand. Twice. Not the parlor, not the attic, not the safe. The west wall. If my mother is somewhere in this house, that's where the house wants me to look."

"Viola." Sebastian's voice had gone lawyer-flat, which meant he was about to say something he didn't want to. "You understand what you're saying. If she's alive—"

"Then she left me here for three years by herself." The words came out harsher than she meant. "I know."

"That's not what I was going to say. I was going to say: if she's alive, and someone besides you has known it, then the ninety days isn't about grief. It's a clock, and we don't know what it's counting down to."

She hadn't thought of that. She had, in fact, very deliberately not thought of it, and now it sat in the kitchen with them, a third person.

"What about you?" she said. "What can you even do? They took your license."

"Prejean took my license. The bar suspended me pending review." He picked the motion off the floor and folded it, once, twice, with an exactness that told her how angry he was. "I can't practice law. I can investigate. Nobody needs a license to knock on a door and ask a question. I can find Delacroix. I can find out who signed the notary block and where the original codicil is filed. I can do the work, Viola. I just can't sign my name to any of it."

"Then do it as a private citizen."

"I intend to." He hesitated. "But there's a problem, and you should hear it from me and not from Prejean. I have a personal stake in this case. My mother was one of theirs—one of the houses. That's why Prejean knew about her. I never disclosed it, because I didn't know it mattered, and then I found out and I still didn't, and that's the part the bar is going to hang me with. Anything I've done on this estate, they can use."

"I know about your mother."

"You know what I told you."

She looked at him then—really looked, the way she looked at a chair with a replaced leg, hunting the seam. He was standing very still, the way people do when they've decided to stop hiding and are still afraid of what it will cost.

"Stay," she said.

"I—"

"Not as my lawyer. You can't be my lawyer." She reached past him and took the motion out of his hand, and smoothed it flat on the table, and set her palm on it, right over the name *Fontaine*. "I have a witness problem. I need someone who saw what's happened in this house. The plate. The tape. Crane in the parlor at one in the morning. Prejean's voice on the reel. I need a person who can stand up and say it, and it can't be me, because it's my house and my mother and my word is worth exactly as much as the trust says it's worth."

"A suspended attorney testifying as a fact witness—"

"Can't be disqualified as my lawyer, because you won't be my lawyer. You'll be my witness. And a witness can say anything." She was making it up as she said it, and it sounded true, and she watched it land on him. "You said you'd lie to your own supervisor and asked me whether I still wanted you. I don't want you for that. I want you for this: you live here. You sleep on that couch. You've heard what I've heard and you're the only other person alive who has. That's not representation. That's testimony."

Sebastian was quiet. In the hall, the entry board creaked—settling, or the night's damp, or thirty-eight years of habit—and they both turned toward the sound the way they always did now.

"There's one more thing," he said finally. "If you're going to search the west wall, and I'm the witness, then whatever's behind it, I see it when you see it. On the record. From now on."

"From now on," she agreed.

He held out his hand, not like a lawyer. She took it, and his palm was warm and dry and steady, and she didn't let go for a beat longer than the deal required, and neither did he.

Then the phone rang.

The house phone—the old one in the hall, the one that had been Camille's number for forty years and that no one had called since the day Viola arrived. It rang four times while they stood in the kitchen looking at each other. On the fifth ring she walked out and picked it up and said nothing at all.

"Well," said Diane Prejean. "You've read the motion. Let's talk about money."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 42: The Motion · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads