The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 46: The Contradiction

The kitchen table had become a war room. Viola cleared the morning's coffee cups and spread everything across the scarred cypress: the 1993 baptismal record, the death certificate, the storage-unit ledger, the photographs Sebastian had taken in the archive before the clerk noticed him.

Sebastian pinned the baptismal record flat with two fingers. "Renee Thibodeaux. Baptized June 1993, Saint Anselm's, Baton Rouge. Sponsors: Marguerite Delacroix and—" he turned it toward the window light—"a Father Emile Boudreaux, who I'm guessing is dead."

"Everybody on this paper is dead." Viola pulled the death certificate from the stack. "Renee Thibodeaux died November 1993. Same name, five months apart. Baptized and buried the same year."

"Baptized late," Sebastian said. "She'd have been, what, twenty-something? Adults get baptized, but it's not common."

Viola didn't answer. She was already laying the storage-unit ledger beside the two documents. Her mother's handwriting ran down the pages in a tight, left-slanted script—the same slant she'd seen on the note behind the east parlor wall, the same slant on the 1989 letter to Marguerite. Payments for a unit in Metairie. Twenty years of them, in cash, on the first of every month.

"The ledger's owner isn't Camille Marchand," Viola said. "Look."

She put her finger on the first entry, dated March 1987. The name in the corner of the page, the one she'd read a dozen times without seeing, was *R. Thibodeaux.*

Sebastian took the page and held it under the window. "Your mother kept this ledger under Renee's name."

"From 1987." Viola sat down slowly. "Two years before she sent that letter to Marguerite saying she was going into hiding. She didn't go into hiding in 1989. She went into hiding in 1987 and told Marguerite about it two years later."

Sebastian set the page down. He didn't say anything for a while. Out on Saint Claude, a streetcar groaned past, and the house ticked around them the way it always did—settling, breathing, keeping its own counsel.

"Run it forward," he said finally. "1987, Camille Marchand assumes the name Renee Thibodeaux. Why?"

"To get out of something."

"Or to get *into* something." He pulled the photographs from the archive. The first showed the 1997 intake file, spread across the legal aid desktop. The second showed Camille and Marguerite on a doorstep, young, laughing, Marguerite's hand on Camille's shoulder. Viola had studied that photograph so many times her eyes had built a false memory of it—she kept thinking there was a third person at the edge of the frame, but there never was.

"Then 1993." Sebastian tapped the baptismal record. "Renee Thibodeaux gets baptized at a church on a street that doesn't exist anymore. Five months later, Renee Thibodeaux dies."

"Except she doesn't die," Viola said. "My mother dies. As Renee."

"Right. So the death certificate is the trick. It's not covering a murder. It's covering a *retirement.* Camille Marchand needed Renee Thibodeaux to die so Camille Marchand could come back."

Viola's hands had gone still on the table, the way they did when an object was about to tell her something. She looked at the death certificate again—at the cause of death, *cardiac arrest,* at the funeral home, at the informant's signature in the corner.

The informant. She'd read past it three times.

"M. Delacroix," she read aloud. "Marguerite signed it. Marguerite reported the death of a woman she'd sponsored at a baptism five months earlier."

"She's the one who buried her."

"Buried *her.*" Viola looked up. "Sebastian, if my mother faked her own death and Marguerite signed the certificate, then Marguerite wasn't just a companion. She was the whole apparatus. The baptism, the death, the ledger—Marguerite is holding the seams."

Sebastian was quiet, and she could see him doing what he did, sorting the legal from the personal, filing each fact where it could be used. "Which means the codicil you're fighting isn't a dying woman's whim. It's an instrument. Marguerite witnessed it because Marguerite has been witnessing Camille's disappearances for thirty years."

"And the eighty days," Viola said, "isn't about the house."

"No," he said. "It's about how long she thought it would take you to find the registry."

Viola stood up and walked to the window. The padlock on the east parlor door glinted across the hall—a cheap brass thing, insulting, the kind of lock a process server carries in a pocket. Tuesday's inventory was four days away. Four days to get through a wall that Camille had spent a decade hiding.

"Okay," she said. "So why does Renee Thibodeaux die in 1993? What happened in 1993?"

Sebastian had already pulled his laptop across the table. "I still have the legal aid credentials. They flagged my badge but not the back-end. Give me a minute."

He typed. Viola watched his face. It was the face he wore when he was reading something he didn't want to be reading, all the humor drained out of it, the jaw set. She had seen it once before—in the intake file, in 1997.

"Here," he said. "Baton Rouge Police Department, incident report, November 1993." He turned the screen toward her. "Domestic disturbance. Address: seven eighteen Sweetbriar Street."

The demolished house. The empty lot with the church beside it.

Viola leaned in.

"Call came in at eleven-forty at night. Neighbor reported shouting, a woman screaming. Officers arrived, found a female victim, unconscious, transported to Our Lady of Mercy under a Jane Doe designation because she had no identification on her."

"Because Renee Thibodeaux didn't exist," Viola said.

"Because Renee Thibodeaux was a name your mother wore and left on the floor when she went out the door." Sebastian scrolled. "Male subject arrested at the scene. Charged with aggravated battery. Name—"

He stopped.

"Sebastian."

"Jules Fontaine." He said it flatly, the way you read a weather report. "Baton Rouge, 1993. Aggravated battery. Charges dismissed—get this—March 1994, on a motion by the district attorney, for insufficient evidence."

Viola put her hand flat on the table. The wood was cool. She could feel her pulse in her palm.

"Jules Fontaine beat my mother unconscious in 1993."

"Jules Fontaine beat *Renee Thibodeaux* unconscious in 1993. And then Renee Thibodeaux died of cardiac arrest five days later, according to a certificate signed by Marguerite Delacroix, and was buried in a grave that probably has a stone on it." He looked up. "Your mother walked out of that house alive, Viola. The woman who went in didn't come out. That's not a disappearance. That's a *rebirth.*"

Viola was already moving. She went through the hall, past the padlocked parlor, up the stairs two at a time, Sebastian behind her. In the safe room, the little closet off her mother's bedroom, she pulled the box from the shelf and set it on the bed. Inside were the things she had catalogued a dozen times: two silver buttons, a length of blue ribbon, a woman's watch that had stopped at 4:47, a single earring, and a hospital bracelet.

She had always read the bracelet as a piece of Camille's history—a fall, a surgery, some ordinary medical unpleasantness left in a box.

Now she read the date on it.

November 12, 1993.

The night of the disturbance.

The bracelet was plastic, the kind hospitals use when a patient comes in with no name. The name field was blank. The blood type was filled in. The attending physician's code was stamped along the edge.

"We thought this was hers," Viola said. Her voice had gone very quiet.

"It is hers," Sebastian said. "It's the arm that took the beating. And she kept it. She put it in a box and kept it for thirty years."

Viola turned the bracelet over in her fingers. Her hands read objects; that was the whole of her gift, the whole of her curse. This piece of plastic was the first thing in her mother's house that her hands refused. It was too thin for history. It was just a number.

"Why keep it?" she said.

"Because it's the reason," Sebastian said. He took the bracelet from her gently and set it back in the box, and his fingers were careful, the way they'd been careful with her since the second night in this house. "The registry, the network, the women—all of it was built for this. To get people out of houses like that one. Somewhere in that east parlor is a list of names, and somewhere on that list is the woman Jules Fontaine put in a hospital bed in 1993, and your mother spent thirty years making sure he never found out she was still alive."

Viola looked at the east wall through the doorway. Behind the plaster, the hollow. Behind the padlock, the parlor.

"Tuesday's inventory," she said. "If the court opens that room—"

"Then Jules Fontaine's lawyer gets a list of every woman your mother ever hid from him." Sebastian closed the box. "And Prejean is the one who set the date."

Viola picked up the bracelet again and slipped it into her pocket. It was the only lead she had that her mother had touched in the last hour of the old life—the life before the vanishing, the life before the name.

"Then we don't wait for Tuesday," she said. "We get into that wall tonight."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 46: The Contradiction · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads